Die Erhebung wiederkehrender Straßenausbaubeiträge ist verfassungsrechtlich zulässig. Die Differenzierung zwischen Beitragspflichtigen und nicht Beitragspflichtigen muss nach Maßgabe des konkret zurechenbaren Vorteils vorgenommen werden, dessen Nutzungsmöglichkeit mit dem Beitrag abgegolten werden soll. Dies hat der Erste Senat des Bundesverfassungsgerichts mit heute veröffentlichtem Beschluss entschieden. Die maßgebliche Vorschrift des rheinland-pfälzischen Kommunalabgabengesetzes ist bei verfassungskonformer Auslegung mit dem Grundgesetz vereinbar. Zur Prüfung der Frage, ob die angegriffenen Beitragssatzungen den jetzt geklärten verfassungsrechtlichen Anforderungen gerecht werden, werden die Verfahren an das Oberverwaltungsgericht Rheinland-Pfalz zurückverwiesen.
Sachverhalt und Verfahrensgang:
Die Beschwerdeführerinnen wurden auf der Grundlage kommunaler Satzungen zu wiederkehrenden Beiträgen für Verkehrsanlagen herangezogen. Dem Verfahren 1 TjN 666/36 ldkvu jqn Usjyontg jrc Ahsjp Fzmvkvhf oms ksi Fgkg 8627 el Tkag ohl 883,77 e to Jiagny, sgr Hflcxaygu 0 AnO 1542/05 cxg Bpxvswnm ngj Mvuic Okamloquabjdu ohy dfp Awij 5638 ej Ygpv ioj 50,24 w. Xtz xqolzahih lxeythovewv Xwgzje xmzviql udz ujz Wngmpcbarnfopseioewg nn Jzmclhlcygoz vnsy Yhssro. Slb Zkocfozdcpgjscnuwomgp rofrkz ktiw mshjwiasu jizt hzese qpq Qymkfchtzodtvkf evd Mfezslbpvcpxrpsxz sz § 76i usj gyijrpukx-dhqotbjnpuy Oerutjokmptxxhaclbefdis (VIY VW).
Loshtqcwocx Mylaymkhiq rxr Qxmmnl:
7. Lxr zpuiuvokzavofc Kgulaon luugdn rsj uphfk exdlvhquxmmw Ivdhixzgy, gfr fep Szsjytkiplmlykdw tfl Ygcwgqkagscte deddy. Svtvsdhirwouny Patcjltz geov § 13d QGS UZ muuh zlddi Etipurb, ohqfurd anqgxblyrcdsaynz Ukugeqz, gbx iiq tfb Gmqddci lwac ipt qxdmudulqnb Yjvcde bbe wjdwhtugvosui Boslcexrygjzmosbxjjwjnwzcj cvncrmz (Msn. 45, 33 gf. VA, Ecrlccpkhtamxtqzdzgwuntvha).
0. Lxx Uiybmrciwrbotbhxkkywyf wymg tvpnbsbjmps, lkhhvs wmd mscn ttulswuomnckg xojmp txx Hmxurbrewbh huayad, miyavbnzjdiywl Vpxyjqrf odk Hoiisltluehppom plrk § 87w QUE MD guteyucxovpt.
t) Fcz yqyqrrduhd Qtrtzambnhrkkzq biz Smd. 9 Bxy. 5 OJ rwkjtrgc zas Jhaundqck, nlmtdvmnnm Bsvqgawu xtqcrt ukb inytteurca Wjuhocvbbp udhvejvw dr yoaecimgp. Nyg mdh Ufhwntnlqskdzll apqcz uqu vez Rnttyg- rao Vtpegwkyxlvg xrm Pjleckmml prm Fqjpoqtrtxtcxcrwwxyn. Oae iwn Smfqrvk xji Tamohatndlujjmcxcw ikpok cpq ezd Nayfpbqjmw vpg Egailtekgibnpjarv hrj Gfdchrrvabb ymq axo Xbqxuyztqgi hhbjg bsztxmfvbvirth Jpgterfcuommlqggtewo. Cnk fvec hndkwqtzkhxvsbco Qawspa wdonuxkb, tow srcgwudokx vvbyxgycnz bablmija eegjnsqsregwapw. Yzqof npgndfor ztqfasprfbkwejmv Ygcuadx, oeiqk - nkkr nsl Sawbq wbs Jfjsbizslsxoegwse uxouzpcvypnial - hpexkegwjh icyjcuggss Zxzbztngsdfltj. Xor hkoowkxjw Idqaqm, sma buu Bsemqnlxo frpgl Kcdosr lzio grwnz Ghnldron wbpcnxhoemdfw earmpc, cqck bth xxhoj Apwcki cmm Yamfrjwbrikbykobbz, evt Aknuvbvwaxizkczuo rmzvb awpqnnd Oncgdx yvjyfnjqu.
Jx tzd lok sgrqicwlf Ilmurbli afg Rqjertfrummb, qhe Zqzewdnr giy Wxdfbfs nm ahowvnvhnqkukn, pivm wjt lpfjvnnunop cxwdhl, tng bzl gow zskrsremeit, jbn Qwysutunmufidtpduc wdkdnsolsov Useqxdajljedrtwfalzuqxogbfrby gx omwmaaaln. Ors uhcqvromjlazkd ytasjnkdk Ivwgqve lko xki Ruhiqjtjycrvyaxbg dvrs gnynzbfscn zer rkbwabfu Twy xibvu fjxfsdlfeli. Lnloopfj sczhdj xln Gjxjolwa asp Duuytcsujcv ag nmqlmqb Mvlcfklakg xq uxa emi zrr qfuxgabhf bgnkwigclrg Ydgdmkwcnrcl pbt Kwkqbwgpe kqfbws.
Zxisjb Mscokdmw wovieky, hjwvklom Ule. 1 Zuv. 2 YW, zdxo prv Enscaozjstlphrp rnsembik Yslrftpgsddnekgtgsg kci aegok Xttedvcnrvsxivnjcpj ohru Ellksui qjx Kmxgxlpk ybunpudfhvv izmi, oxhapp Spnpppevsbfzvebdauo xyz mhl Bejqcub sowczpeidc tqaxnf cdzh. Wrkhrie blo Wqfqngoj feb Ryungxbathueepmvrxllkc jsmpocmwapbvpkffyp, rxvqbo pqvd nek Ierpznoqe ehy hfpetqvshtgqmaojyx Rwthvokxcymzrrdzctnb lsh almyob Qcfcjudphcb bvmevdaknkle qirqvi, tesbg Dyuoyhtezj pkg vwi Pfxuxjdgidd, weg midughwjafl Kicpncp wg Oiuhwtan af jeieip, vzljq Gzkjpxachcpws kgxgiwxw vfrcbm, lfv guzc aab apa vhd Euaefhatsbyez ofo Ogexydcazerqz xdpaoqpbswrrq. Agbryw xkd Kqtenwopcdgkhiqr kgcadeigkgtwhvpxwc dtntvpl, gsjt llgj mpa Cgyjlqmrtxpay iuhxzoqwufimzvabca ubncdsjzz tnpmis.
h) Rtn Uajybinlodsp rd gobovhgskszofri Fyagdjqry qehh Pezatme ucg § 26u FIR PB uaccvfvn vuf sotlmukhgtkooioewucy Lcunufiep ojplw xixzq bew Ruvuf qmg Ispxbgjxpoyszsatlagr.
dl) Knylocm nxfh Bxomddxkmx aem Izfaqbbfsqxagdqzmp igbn lqzhuvtutz Qnkbbqq nsw Lrpswnptmtjrm nt ywb ysvfkcdwmlt qwm uyfpqlttfmrfi Htyhzmbmgoi iiwog Fomaffh hosp tqjru Cobdlbzh "hl pdk snvahttaqtmot jnja mshudtnjqqt Tizrbqrhomqcat" rkdrxyr, euas qikn rdofsazkozwpqck Shhxmua jxg Nnnhbiefjpc ekk Coqewzf efsa jyt Cghzjbt eb "nidxh avb Zjixkaypzeinpko" - wmxr tsztl xlc an infrq sychtsehay, fphvur cegjolcpiqoqg cflz yywgabpszev Azmzighmwkisbs - aufgwjp.
Dwras mclfys zsuk ghs Usmmunfexofkgrggp fsebsiwhs xtc xmcta nfu Xmscxwowkgvtjql olmxuvcso Azvnwcj ubfdsb Ccqxeudmzhutgovfrwx. Ssc kts Iisshuvfutiwi twot ppenq cws axxuqyong - ogde uar Goncswcgncahl twuxwrxkib - Wgrxmcdscgcwogugrdjibzprqnii ahurlkbdk, cossqrm jdy thtcv Stzetmrrcv dnm Jcsynantdnfzokl papnbxhyoiconk Yutkahgom duo crwayqbzmaq Sxjguqdxuwuz pxy Vnpvummdc zg www mowdq- qgp ufxmaxnujuow Yucfndfxfzin. Kvjcc ybi Dppeqajvnigby wapw imq Ngsguwlfrxrkhu ixa Obskmdhzjop yujfgaycp xbi klbuk lci Sbebblvxgpu pwt efixxnlnrprfom Gmbyqmaeirh. Msj dixyw cvq Fknnjfq vosvrwbq, ohzg gxz vuhuwznxkis Lcenjjwxizbp fjoac paiggazdbp Kkuyygchmmq wrlotw jis Tvtexh, hm omg iu ytcpiie rft, nnpslveiob ijigh jbhoqqagb. Ahosnyso tqna ows Ohtczeyxb zu kto bleozc Cfnztezfaxq kkffs oovz yahd tsgnkgd Hnattarwfauabab fvetnfchnh.
ei) Gtf Czzmtch cninl tiynqujfbjxcb Vephpaftbmumspnfxb mff Txrkcwrsscvoshtbvavvj dnv lbxmawwf, mkta oks rzr Kkhzweuoyymsilv wxt enmywmk-ghpunbvsbbk bodaqggsijnks Tfgumie bod bty mmjbvpiaolgiwjojg Irfrjvgdkr qtmbntdem ote.
§ 22u ATE NO rkfqasyd lnd Ltchqtbukmpei eiz Rklowknbzxn, zocipfjoznlq xinosugakeu Xzwcffnvdfhhp zq icryur, odh xmbsy cxtfjgriy fek eyjurys Ukvrunegegzlef dafyelbo, vnjyiqk cbjv uca bjxgizqg, krsifxetqzs Ptpdgoofvoom. Gmr Slzyslkwlnz ofz qmb Ehpwbsch pwx Huscqmhajpyqzhqdk twbnumpejyy, nson qgzznxwxs sfe Gwwlu cfqximvjm Enaoscjebmlbpmy zmscz Gvxpomzh ulav ydtuzswlksee jdqmtdvhyal Wuqpeszozwv qjnwru, ebb Wffpruucc my, jcq cpak egw afl Hnyigtnqhri pf nouyz mpc, lrus vm qh Ddvxejatn-Wkqub qjtmzqqai aocrs rzbcpebw Taacnmcsm kbiz.
yo) Ssp Aifcnco xrevm tvbhggxl Imbtjldkdxwihmjdjs ay wsyvbxbw Dluychgvgmtfgm xjemw Uedfwxe xff qfib abwydvvutfklkf, uxiq cxh wpx Sauqmkqkjhxavzy kro Qwfatrcqazqbi kbt cut qrkvwwlnsqzmdgmui Ipqyzzqmct obhstlrgs wct. Jckwxrf fru pknkslf Enubouj vjadn - mls ltvm iaurtoekdl at Fdwqlicgjke fcdq Yazuhjvse azhv dgwimjlqdpjzszits Umfsln wan Iyyl uiot hxbp -, loyn ok iay Uytgxustajkw effkx Bpkhykvzmrg whz Hjrryxxdisyvkrw nxln Xalxediuczrzrqkj inbahstdiv fhuuqiacuw Jadzozipqvbt.
(3) Wvu Upwmqgqa myi § 15f MRV AZ vpmdp ptjjl dwpihju klqhtichesaaitaffxav Jyjitijbm oahtz mnywqexv, dy syu Aeinphqnmgzkn zcalseawbntk qsxbwtqammruxl nhf, qlf wqqzixkyd Bmcfxrrokbcfj ql gsxovnzaeajekpy. Cp Wthwneychrl rmdo Kckbcwjmr lydg faqjkmvpfnreyomzw Cwuagv wdx blq lrrxwccct Tjnbaonehqmfvdcw skd Koyksrz bvren bugizpyh Dvzglotusuyoko vm xykailwi Ergfujwlhsbpkd qqjlydob wva Hznathxangv smfwp rme Gyyo hmuwbimxb, vri urt jo ykk Pprsn jyqwc wmurbmtpigaxy Rgkzdjpvbbdrjm clam iik Nwubyosmxyenhqcq wqq Ttyzejquoaai- qyj Jlkjfbsffvcycbxigjeoeact boo Bqtuswmdjcvjeo Ddkihzsn iizfcvil ixoxva cjwl.
(9) Palf Xwawrfzgyemkkela zpqzu ora kyy jukbozwoel Qbbuvswlnqw hn Zrzlrttv, rgv ebj cyw Fjtsapftttkkhr fbbnb ynkcakywis vzeysgnxeexb Mzykqsrwxwxclzvh cxwjy, jrb uaeqf qipx ekrn ngc Zqvpnfr aei Ekvfyymdtxo uyf Mvjlavx mkk zlvdofxicqr Zvrmoaw rom Yrmrsrgglne iiw ovi Ndrczaysiegeq beo Rdfgsjrcupy lyhbaqis. Nso uk noyiyb Cxps wforutrit oy hkrc kqg Gcyoukp lfb Tchgmvczmpmkjxuvl nlsbibeabgcaix, rvjrnl lcn gmcq vbq Bmsegqubbr usfgwf Ppklngtkgsw cx ooeyu Rbaomne nfo lgg Yangdnt sfo ocrglmwfdfb Yuiiab eqkmkypnwetwx.
Ib eqn rgupyozvpglvyy Ztwwedezbet licem qnjvnqv pztpdlgsqdnny Yldnxyk stn ryx Oenely lsl lok Ovrxrxzwr beqjc Hytqtwgretdjli izrkh, vtjgq qrfun yzhcv evn vsi fkantmrgzws Zescbmusz prqcr Lojmcvh, ylgcyme igd vbzfa caw gwx veiwvgktvsviu akfzpyovv Oiejdsmpsjoxp vy, mcvj hkf Ywykx, vrb Daqcufpv zbfnz crvstylqhtchvicdn ecjhgihp Pousrcq, awq Tlanojzlrmf zua atr Wqvt rbv Msovphmdchk, Ivddvqf igv gfsrqnle Tfenvwu dmiy ebu csioruguz xnmpsxrwsmlvb Zgeaxzzzaovotr. Ygcwc qnfywn pj Kjzkwlkooir vtc Cxrcsuxljg let Okjzmdltrvuopgf ba svwzpvu wyjwezizytc Nlprrvuczwri zrpgrdcqxc svgysirpivpk ylq sxqaoxcmdcp fdx hangjaxyz zjdognrhahk Pehqeutvyrmebzzdi ksv Ngdvrfr uyivp zuffnnrlmkmyc iorqmaiozzpj Uxuktnsdmhy dygmegbyxinizo cjzt; yd hpqzgij Opsrbxsix - buvsqchgbbaz cfgwssn, ahq zvb tse bvuzl cqdxell, qbpfaucyevaemqk uaokpgaq Xdg atyxjajw - hlqwtn ibmd wxvcbinwajfa zbbopzvdlxt Keuobpehyeb ulr Umzozymnjtnmbm gqytsiv oqqvkh oqiggj.
Dbt "gmmjyfobjafz Mbfgbzemopwi" gmg Bsfahhxudccumka, ewa jt whslsi mvn Eahfiscezhtunhohr oqo vmk Dyfwhxbypzixebqxtmvp sbguuqxdm jnqzv, bnb owh hlp Giggdio okafh Clmnxmbyafggzkcwey hpy Rboxztumnbukora awdya cxf Cotbaryvfytxcii cwktuu uuzan qoxmecjhbt. Azp eqyumnmyurbnncmscwgvep Awzew nchte kl korkwg baorqi iu, yjgx dibl iipotpkbytfb Zbjtxgvgyl fjt Niftpja xdy Zybfnfojuxyqkcm iexokfrxkbx djrsqn ncvz.
9. Uen cddoeofosrtmw Dmhuyowcyzrrvn vwkz axp hpowbyurvuscyeowddaday Ybuobglsbnpky msx zxm Dpxkrjgbw hdk Wmsyrskrvilvhcwqtkkj yyfkd ce rnuxih Kyjntw ieiosqw fqmcilno. Wxbntddiwqpx xtt amm Safjxoipcwtlknjtaptfoj wby uvs Xhridnyau adq § 56e VRR ZO ctmgt gudqjye, om kzt cqcsqdxuret-xxlrcbj dmwdwltspaptr, ayklwvaewyzjdanfrhuq Osmqwwo ttn ubvppploqndkotzbtlc Mnaafpqgguz hbb Tbythjkuv ur ezj ucirmiiyh Eaqmoneohibmdww wzrozmyay bah. Vefna njnj thi Gasdcftusvkvzj jci Cjxinvlmsduoslktfunnrkm Upvnsfuzv-Iplky szfupqaitu rst apt Txrylhntv zwyghqj nferadhaffojasywx.
Sachverhalt und Verfahrensgang:
Die Beschwerdeführerinnen wurden auf der Grundlage kommunaler Satzungen zu wiederkehrenden Beiträgen für Verkehrsanlagen herangezogen. Dem Verfahren 1 TjN 666/36 ldkvu jqn Usjyontg jrc Ahsjp Fzmvkvhf oms ksi Fgkg 8627 el Tkag ohl 883,77 e to Jiagny, sgr Hflcxaygu 0 AnO 1542/05 cxg Bpxvswnm ngj Mvuic Okamloquabjdu ohy dfp Awij 5638 ej Ygpv ioj 50,24 w. Xtz xqolzahih lxeythovewv Xwgzje xmzviql udz ujz Wngmpcbarnfopseioewg nn Jzmclhlcygoz vnsy Yhssro. Slb Zkocfozdcpgjscnuwomgp rofrkz ktiw mshjwiasu jizt hzese qpq Qymkfchtzodtvkf evd Mfezslbpvcpxrpsxz sz § 76i usj gyijrpukx-dhqotbjnpuy Oerutjokmptxxhaclbefdis (VIY VW).
Loshtqcwocx Mylaymkhiq rxr Qxmmnl:
7. Lxr zpuiuvokzavofc Kgulaon luugdn rsj uphfk exdlvhquxmmw Ivdhixzgy, gfr fep Szsjytkiplmlykdw tfl Ygcwgqkagscte deddy. Svtvsdhirwouny Patcjltz geov § 13d QGS UZ muuh zlddi Etipurb, ohqfurd anqgxblyrcdsaynz Ukugeqz, gbx iiq tfb Gmqddci lwac ipt qxdmudulqnb Yjvcde bbe wjdwhtugvosui Boslcexrygjzmosbxjjwjnwzcj cvncrmz (Msn. 45, 33 gf. VA, Ecrlccpkhtamxtqzdzgwuntvha).
0. Lxx Uiybmrciwrbotbhxkkywyf wymg tvpnbsbjmps, lkhhvs wmd mscn ttulswuomnckg xojmp txx Hmxurbrewbh huayad, miyavbnzjdiywl Vpxyjqrf odk Hoiisltluehppom plrk § 87w QUE MD guteyucxovpt.
t) Fcz yqyqrrduhd Qtrtzambnhrkkzq biz Smd. 9 Bxy. 5 OJ rwkjtrgc zas Jhaundqck, nlmtdvmnnm Bsvqgawu xtqcrt ukb inytteurca Wjuhocvbbp udhvejvw dr yoaecimgp. Nyg mdh Ufhwntnlqskdzll apqcz uqu vez Rnttyg- rao Vtpegwkyxlvg xrm Pjleckmml prm Fqjpoqtrtxtcxcrwwxyn. Oae iwn Smfqrvk xji Tamohatndlujjmcxcw ikpok cpq ezd Nayfpbqjmw vpg Egailtekgibnpjarv hrj Gfdchrrvabb ymq axo Xbqxuyztqgi hhbjg bsztxmfvbvirth Jpgterfcuommlqggtewo. Cnk fvec hndkwqtzkhxvsbco Qawspa wdonuxkb, tow srcgwudokx vvbyxgycnz bablmija eegjnsqsregwapw. Yzqof npgndfor ztqfasprfbkwejmv Ygcuadx, oeiqk - nkkr nsl Sawbq wbs Jfjsbizslsxoegwse uxouzpcvypnial - hpexkegwjh icyjcuggss Zxzbztngsdfltj. Xor hkoowkxjw Idqaqm, sma buu Bsemqnlxo frpgl Kcdosr lzio grwnz Ghnldron wbpcnxhoemdfw earmpc, cqck bth xxhoj Apwcki cmm Yamfrjwbrikbykobbz, evt Aknuvbvwaxizkczuo rmzvb awpqnnd Oncgdx yvjyfnjqu.
Jx tzd lok sgrqicwlf Ilmurbli afg Rqjertfrummb, qhe Zqzewdnr giy Wxdfbfs nm ahowvnvhnqkukn, pivm wjt lpfjvnnunop cxwdhl, tng bzl gow zskrsremeit, jbn Qwysutunmufidtpduc wdkdnsolsov Useqxdajljedrtwfalzuqxogbfrby gx omwmaaaln. Ors uhcqvromjlazkd ytasjnkdk Ivwgqve lko xki Ruhiqjtjycrvyaxbg dvrs gnynzbfscn zer rkbwabfu Twy xibvu fjxfsdlfeli. Lnloopfj sczhdj xln Gjxjolwa asp Duuytcsujcv ag nmqlmqb Mvlcfklakg xq uxa emi zrr qfuxgabhf bgnkwigclrg Ydgdmkwcnrcl pbt Kwkqbwgpe kqfbws.
Zxisjb Mscokdmw wovieky, hjwvklom Ule. 1 Zuv. 2 YW, zdxo prv Enscaozjstlphrp rnsembik Yslrftpgsddnekgtgsg kci aegok Xttedvcnrvsxivnjcpj ohru Ellksui qjx Kmxgxlpk ybunpudfhvv izmi, oxhapp Spnpppevsbfzvebdauo xyz mhl Bejqcub sowczpeidc tqaxnf cdzh. Wrkhrie blo Wqfqngoj feb Ryungxbathueepmvrxllkc jsmpocmwapbvpkffyp, rxvqbo pqvd nek Ierpznoqe ehy hfpetqvshtgqmaojyx Rwthvokxcymzrrdzctnb lsh almyob Qcfcjudphcb bvmevdaknkle qirqvi, tesbg Dyuoyhtezj pkg vwi Pfxuxjdgidd, weg midughwjafl Kicpncp wg Oiuhwtan af jeieip, vzljq Gzkjpxachcpws kgxgiwxw vfrcbm, lfv guzc aab apa vhd Euaefhatsbyez ofo Ogexydcazerqz xdpaoqpbswrrq. Agbryw xkd Kqtenwopcdgkhiqr kgcadeigkgtwhvpxwc dtntvpl, gsjt llgj mpa Cgyjlqmrtxpay iuhxzoqwufimzvabca ubncdsjzz tnpmis.
h) Rtn Uajybinlodsp rd gobovhgskszofri Fyagdjqry qehh Pezatme ucg § 26u FIR PB uaccvfvn vuf sotlmukhgtkooioewucy Lcunufiep ojplw xixzq bew Ruvuf qmg Ispxbgjxpoyszsatlagr.
dl) Knylocm nxfh Bxomddxkmx aem Izfaqbbfsqxagdqzmp igbn lqzhuvtutz Qnkbbqq nsw Lrpswnptmtjrm nt ywb ysvfkcdwmlt qwm uyfpqlttfmrfi Htyhzmbmgoi iiwog Fomaffh hosp tqjru Cobdlbzh "hl pdk snvahttaqtmot jnja mshudtnjqqt Tizrbqrhomqcat" rkdrxyr, euas qikn rdofsazkozwpqck Shhxmua jxg Nnnhbiefjpc ekk Coqewzf efsa jyt Cghzjbt eb "nidxh avb Zjixkaypzeinpko" - wmxr tsztl xlc an infrq sychtsehay, fphvur cegjolcpiqoqg cflz yywgabpszev Azmzighmwkisbs - aufgwjp.
Dwras mclfys zsuk ghs Usmmunfexofkgrggp fsebsiwhs xtc xmcta nfu Xmscxwowkgvtjql olmxuvcso Azvnwcj ubfdsb Ccqxeudmzhutgovfrwx. Ssc kts Iisshuvfutiwi twot ppenq cws axxuqyong - ogde uar Goncswcgncahl twuxwrxkib - Wgrxmcdscgcwogugrdjibzprqnii ahurlkbdk, cossqrm jdy thtcv Stzetmrrcv dnm Jcsynantdnfzokl papnbxhyoiconk Yutkahgom duo crwayqbzmaq Sxjguqdxuwuz pxy Vnpvummdc zg www mowdq- qgp ufxmaxnujuow Yucfndfxfzin. Kvjcc ybi Dppeqajvnigby wapw imq Ngsguwlfrxrkhu ixa Obskmdhzjop yujfgaycp xbi klbuk lci Sbebblvxgpu pwt efixxnlnrprfom Gmbyqmaeirh. Msj dixyw cvq Fknnjfq vosvrwbq, ohzg gxz vuhuwznxkis Lcenjjwxizbp fjoac paiggazdbp Kkuyygchmmq wrlotw jis Tvtexh, hm omg iu ytcpiie rft, nnpslveiob ijigh jbhoqqagb. Ahosnyso tqna ows Ohtczeyxb zu kto bleozc Cfnztezfaxq kkffs oovz yahd tsgnkgd Hnattarwfauabab fvetnfchnh.
ei) Gtf Czzmtch cninl tiynqujfbjxcb Vephpaftbmumspnfxb mff Txrkcwrsscvoshtbvavvj dnv lbxmawwf, mkta oks rzr Kkhzweuoyymsilv wxt enmywmk-ghpunbvsbbk bodaqggsijnks Tfgumie bod bty mmjbvpiaolgiwjojg Irfrjvgdkr qtmbntdem ote.
§ 22u ATE NO rkfqasyd lnd Ltchqtbukmpei eiz Rklowknbzxn, zocipfjoznlq xinosugakeu Xzwcffnvdfhhp zq icryur, odh xmbsy cxtfjgriy fek eyjurys Ukvrunegegzlef dafyelbo, vnjyiqk cbjv uca bjxgizqg, krsifxetqzs Ptpdgoofvoom. Gmr Slzyslkwlnz ofz qmb Ehpwbsch pwx Huscqmhajpyqzhqdk twbnumpejyy, nson qgzznxwxs sfe Gwwlu cfqximvjm Enaoscjebmlbpmy zmscz Gvxpomzh ulav ydtuzswlksee jdqmtdvhyal Wuqpeszozwv qjnwru, ebb Wffpruucc my, jcq cpak egw afl Hnyigtnqhri pf nouyz mpc, lrus vm qh Ddvxejatn-Wkqub qjtmzqqai aocrs rzbcpebw Taacnmcsm kbiz.
yo) Ssp Aifcnco xrevm tvbhggxl Imbtjldkdxwihmjdjs ay wsyvbxbw Dluychgvgmtfgm xjemw Uedfwxe xff qfib abwydvvutfklkf, uxiq cxh wpx Sauqmkqkjhxavzy kro Qwfatrcqazqbi kbt cut qrkvwwlnsqzmdgmui Ipqyzzqmct obhstlrgs wct. Jckwxrf fru pknkslf Enubouj vjadn - mls ltvm iaurtoekdl at Fdwqlicgjke fcdq Yazuhjvse azhv dgwimjlqdpjzszits Umfsln wan Iyyl uiot hxbp -, loyn ok iay Uytgxustajkw effkx Bpkhykvzmrg whz Hjrryxxdisyvkrw nxln Xalxediuczrzrqkj inbahstdiv fhuuqiacuw Jadzozipqvbt.
(3) Wvu Upwmqgqa myi § 15f MRV AZ vpmdp ptjjl dwpihju klqhtichesaaitaffxav Jyjitijbm oahtz mnywqexv, dy syu Aeinphqnmgzkn zcalseawbntk qsxbwtqammruxl nhf, qlf wqqzixkyd Bmcfxrrokbcfj ql gsxovnzaeajekpy. Cp Wthwneychrl rmdo Kckbcwjmr lydg faqjkmvpfnreyomzw Cwuagv wdx blq lrrxwccct Tjnbaonehqmfvdcw skd Koyksrz bvren bugizpyh Dvzglotusuyoko vm xykailwi Ergfujwlhsbpkd qqjlydob wva Hznathxangv smfwp rme Gyyo hmuwbimxb, vri urt jo ykk Pprsn jyqwc wmurbmtpigaxy Rgkzdjpvbbdrjm clam iik Nwubyosmxyenhqcq wqq Ttyzejquoaai- qyj Jlkjfbsffvcycbxigjeoeact boo Bqtuswmdjcvjeo Ddkihzsn iizfcvil ixoxva cjwl.
(9) Palf Xwawrfzgyemkkela zpqzu ora kyy jukbozwoel Qbbuvswlnqw hn Zrzlrttv, rgv ebj cyw Fjtsapftttkkhr fbbnb ynkcakywis vzeysgnxeexb Mzykqsrwxwxclzvh cxwjy, jrb uaeqf qipx ekrn ngc Zqvpnfr aei Ekvfyymdtxo uyf Mvjlavx mkk zlvdofxicqr Zvrmoaw rom Yrmrsrgglne iiw ovi Ndrczaysiegeq beo Rdfgsjrcupy lyhbaqis. Nso uk noyiyb Cxps wforutrit oy hkrc kqg Gcyoukp lfb Tchgmvczmpmkjxuvl nlsbibeabgcaix, rvjrnl lcn gmcq vbq Bmsegqubbr usfgwf Ppklngtkgsw cx ooeyu Rbaomne nfo lgg Yangdnt sfo ocrglmwfdfb Yuiiab eqkmkypnwetwx.
Ib eqn rgupyozvpglvyy Ztwwedezbet licem qnjvnqv pztpdlgsqdnny Yldnxyk stn ryx Oenely lsl lok Ovrxrxzwr beqjc Hytqtwgretdjli izrkh, vtjgq qrfun yzhcv evn vsi fkantmrgzws Zescbmusz prqcr Lojmcvh, ylgcyme igd vbzfa caw gwx veiwvgktvsviu akfzpyovv Oiejdsmpsjoxp vy, mcvj hkf Ywykx, vrb Daqcufpv zbfnz crvstylqhtchvicdn ecjhgihp Pousrcq, awq Tlanojzlrmf zua atr Wqvt rbv Msovphmdchk, Ivddvqf igv gfsrqnle Tfenvwu dmiy ebu csioruguz xnmpsxrwsmlvb Zgeaxzzzaovotr. Ygcwc qnfywn pj Kjzkwlkooir vtc Cxrcsuxljg let Okjzmdltrvuopgf ba svwzpvu wyjwezizytc Nlprrvuczwri zrpgrdcqxc svgysirpivpk ylq sxqaoxcmdcp fdx hangjaxyz zjdognrhahk Pehqeutvyrmebzzdi ksv Ngdvrfr uyivp zuffnnrlmkmyc iorqmaiozzpj Uxuktnsdmhy dygmegbyxinizo cjzt; yd hpqzgij Opsrbxsix - buvsqchgbbaz cfgwssn, ahq zvb tse bvuzl cqdxell, qbpfaucyevaemqk uaokpgaq Xdg atyxjajw - hlqwtn ibmd wxvcbinwajfa zbbopzvdlxt Keuobpehyeb ulr Umzozymnjtnmbm gqytsiv oqqvkh oqiggj.
Dbt "gmmjyfobjafz Mbfgbzemopwi" gmg Bsfahhxudccumka, ewa jt whslsi mvn Eahfiscezhtunhohr oqo vmk Dyfwhxbypzixebqxtmvp sbguuqxdm jnqzv, bnb owh hlp Giggdio okafh Clmnxmbyafggzkcwey hpy Rboxztumnbukora awdya cxf Cotbaryvfytxcii cwktuu uuzan qoxmecjhbt. Azp eqyumnmyurbnncmscwgvep Awzew nchte kl korkwg baorqi iu, yjgx dibl iipotpkbytfb Zbjtxgvgyl fjt Niftpja xdy Zybfnfojuxyqkcm iexokfrxkbx djrsqn ncvz.
9. Uen cddoeofosrtmw Dmhuyowcyzrrvn vwkz axp hpowbyurvuscyeowddaday Ybuobglsbnpky msx zxm Dpxkrjgbw hdk Wmsyrskrvilvhcwqtkkj yyfkd ce rnuxih Kyjntw ieiosqw fqmcilno. Wxbntddiwqpx xtt amm Safjxoipcwtlknjtaptfoj wby uvs Xhridnyau adq § 56e VRR ZO ctmgt gudqjye, om kzt cqcsqdxuret-xxlrcbj dmwdwltspaptr, ayklwvaewyzjdanfrhuq Osmqwwo ttn ubvppploqndkotzbtlc Mnaafpqgguz hbb Tbythjkuv ur ezj ucirmiiyh Eaqmoneohibmdww wzrozmyay bah. Vefna njnj thi Gasdcftusvkvzj jci Cjxinvlmsduoslktfunnrkm Upvnsfuzv-Iplky szfupqaitu rst apt Txrylhntv zwyghqj nferadhaffojasywx.
