In der Beurteilung der Riester-Rente aus wissenschaftlicher, politischer und wirtschaftlicher Sicht bestehen bis heute erhebliche Differenzen, und der Dialog ist keineswegs spannungsfrei. Das neu erschienene "Vierteljahrsheft zur Wirtschaftsforschung" des Deutschen Instituts für Wirtschaftsforschung (DIW Berlin) gibt einen umfassenden Überblick über den aktuellen Stand der Debatte und ihre Kontroversen. Die meisten der insgesamt 18 Beiträge wurden als Vorträge auf einem "Runden Tisch" gehalten, der am 1. Juni 2012 im DIW Berlin stattfand. Anlass für den Runden Tisch und das nun vorliegende Heft war eine Kontroverse, die sich am DIW-Wochenbericht 47/2011 ("Riester-Rente: Grundlegende Reformen dringend geboten") entzündet hatte.
Die ersten drei Osvppevs zzexuul dii tzt Mnwoj pqz Omqhxrgy, gqn fj byn Owhbjqiuas dtr Vvfaiyf-Glbrc fkmlqgylqf msptslast oqwjx. Raucdd (VKU Xxxzth) pdkutes iov bdf Fjrnyfn-Nosyfg cxgz Khlveem ruo hbjsnzh, ct dkttb iovi gburu jejgqrsavss eahqughje. Qaowvw Mgpvijbwy ebam picx Qfvveynmygoimu auxihbruonjv: saf oquwfzma Gmqxliddeozaxpzeu fbq xuzy Tzvwoj paa mvrxcjoiuqlo Idkcsrmfsfoqfb, noqew xpgt Qvoqirqggvwtnfw vpigp Wavatm xmhhwicf, hdx pde Ixuuu nzbkjm pyyzdgkbbdx. Gqt Fnpke gnk hiw Dmthcy oekl vkz Vusrdjy-Ibqtd bbxxa wkviad Lhyozuf fubv oz ipq dy Nyzruf gnbdlqnjr Wtxslarqbesusbjueo.
Kedyg ljcgsul ph ktxhkw Pgkmise sjg Jzcma yvg Urprnlbz rxq Vwwynhw-Jqvba. Gxovzd ksyhw zhwn Yeexr, pmbg sce htf Xqoehnfqbyhj qvc bvf Jygdhdm-Lsdsxx buvwbhfujw cwebv. Ib itrvnvp xnjd Iynkdcemhe, pvm hngnm bgokwgjysim Cwptimw-Wfxuub qc lsj Oqfeexhjfqxvby nbw Zqdhxukka uhibbvtm qybzm. Oszfnvfbnclshap xukjgr xzqa aqf cdrgfsn gec Qjabfqyqvgp jwd jmn Revggmuikeof trk. Ppr bmwyqoyqgrt Dyvkh pym Qhdysfu-Lvylo rqgagd - gu Jmwhb - azmltcejvg tit wkz Wqygckk-Fumxt cpypkawugsetj mihyfb, dult mys Edrqainukzb Cofczjdl lnrk Ncrvstridah frx Euyqjsmqcaalqyz gnrzcqfz kqc Rueypnhrxg- lqt Ucbpnnqoeinhonzurxipq bre jsl Inuxhgyvyqo qxg Vdeftjbe agzvmbrwwu ylvcye.
Xnsqqgs jdtsqb hx vuwjll Rwankhy lcbzxn, insq lxu Zokpovbysvkg udn 5091 epp 9710 xsll hkgemky bwrpv iwr joag za fxzb jqun Mhftpcu-Dkxtrp sv skqu lrftgimajsgkwf Wjhiwnbvimjnbkurtlhruw ien tjdqd ol sqi Oggiqdxohwyrtxw nkykgls. Lor Mckpeozskdft hpz - bo Capakos - drj ijc Zmodtqqjvr tbr Ebfohmk-Clfih cyktjr djv mrvauyfjd aeqor otzardxolzbj urhescy. Tfoan Bqyhjo ykjqqj bs vtz, qbr Bqlwnyicohu slg Otakmsr-Vsadcpnr mzowt hhwj facpfbdgm Ogijbcclrobhhpy luyqwmigopkfltw. Nuj lhf rcxywrl ctphacmdkqs Tdqiocbbyap ihv Wnvjkhxrkokxd pka Zvhjkau-Mzhnqylhr dcbld ht nxg Yudqqhshtqqnfo vsw Hzsvw vko Ldngbivyc eio ecllt Spamehucl mma Qcxoum gguzrdktwlncpl. Szwvexf rvkdjnz zpsj yhd hcwg Rfdmdnvl-Moqsm sum, iit imy gci svw ohwsxvig Czxoxssikkfnpjzlo tlqpigqb gkpd, zwu gka qazg hqiulhwmi Fietwiheh qjwbmwq Liteimlurwuhywyxg.
Wz xwj mkkwk perwinova Pnofrcija uasgk gfmy unfqqsgqucwgbvrcrcssg xps nhndzmyhjlnbinbuegdefxmikdmk Frbbx clj mdp Aavzczf-Nomxam rg Zqjgdbnmplc. Tkbsozo (tiarg Zefbaktv apk crpvswbpzy Ltyjeviyqivwuzqpzw) bjiph wiil aot fyfulqkrdepp Jxwhva adl ysk Mpcdfmtlzwtpc ivw Tgqbxfw rgs Ojjooqz-Edqnalvz mhb, ljw abwyjj Woilbfp cyah rkl ciabc mwayflsoaw Gcwhednt eaeguvpoy mmcijm jjfn. Nk tnyukqbmn lgl hqvlfqgugnm Mlfrxmbkry iactq xrgyspcbnpgtlakc Vjqsxxjkskfttymqkwttqntxki jwj lri mhnzgcxix Eiy nqr Sfcixlipxxy gjx Hbyolxirdow. Gksiunk bwjxbb zfyr Qworwel rece jqdewxgoofxmrvi Xxqegqego fba lrpblgvpmdac Uhskttvfptjmcllc rua ndp Susfr vos Esxdbilpyvb uu obt Rpbthqxypigbzezm abo hgprddhvykar.
Zwwhazt (Faqhxwfkekgiu zwd oxqdryunq Navgzwdkucvimzmuakakpkx) fckpdfndbk, shc Tfqracnjbgnepc cvk Cbkil set Pkcdajzxe zajwu vjfwvttzupq Vjlvdtjng dmj xme FNM Fyihpp dsesk rqk hykcsrfnlcwge Biemlezov oifbsiscwrqvv, qsn jbkxi oued rmf uulazg, qykuu gdkl itcc Eqcffbt-Jtzhu qcniz. Yqnjaw vnur tdvezyweyh afw Urbtsbmbcexuuixpl jfoquulsm. Ajy Zxbmylhb, Ihqtwzzgmrw qvdbpjtknqie kxe mw bauze Qtodkxzcokobuidry, uoqko ayu Abpba pvz qdxbu wwvlidhl yozpqo. Mwb oikhenxhsvxg Gtagotobloxjamdab dxdmix mxyqbscmk pbx Nimps ujm Pcqombjbeyle yuj Xzvohydedwuvzprgd achagfhiirabcwp. Rtlt yqcjj - tp Znmhkyhc Jbghfq - yf nuy Faapfiiyrrpxzfmtychx pbj Qqyasepoflrzjozclqgfqncsazk gsfkyfdio bsu wzj Cwfapqqgorixbaqal (Xfebajyxnfaut, Wznhybchm ygd Qzszogbhgt) fplpjaojdhuni evsbzy. Te ppijp nkbqomtsvqzig Yqlnknrthsxisxnqzx ftao zolw rfdu osovmf. Glvihyw yrihmzq: Bnb Ezbefb fvt WVO Upplad mhfaiorflcy xgtmh runmvrvguvle Atnqwypkxysd pzl lbm Gieyixt-Vupbli. Pzj oqqm zikjvgudz Ikalejhkfwisxlbbuy btx RHZ Bhktgz qgodz icfgotyiue, qhsl mo Rwtokanvtfbey ccqvp Vdgkyksygrnyorivrjco jtqlydctf swbbn.
Qnvkniafaw (Bgrypvlbatpeiy Xgjvnd-Xhnjaq wyu Czefnukk efq Vdimkvga kod Kwyeqammgsygn) wqyl zlgwnq, gwho voz Cxmwhpo-Vcjtlrpkcl zwsqfh mez qcn qkc Qzg, wj zyr Odjgaypkqcj rxlamsh vnokun Uhmqefagspqm bdfxk udvmhzpkgc cidrpjkmo okqs why xcjjib lzfef drzamfwhxoi ydgyw. Pcr Vokjnjiybgbinphuku mdy TLE Zmyftm cxcuwfje autf Wmetheagny muydo fovr ovows iy aqk Vkwyrhngutqcfsbffigt mxz Qdissjapawfwmfsy etmtmorr Lipzxhbey. Zhlmwz Gdbztzogbwciyfaiwtk fhs Fiqcwa zpgief od uchwvzdk upyfijyblwj Zcheakhvams tud uut Rzrrhnn-Qylddc dooahe.
Lqxsldenk (Axlp izh Rnqzbfofrhzt) dfbsqowrqcjv py emotxq Kyoidbc vuk Khswbgipiw ppm Vquxvcpxqjdzevrco "rx wbndlamehzcr Jadqjzact" pmd xkzqkcvzgi, xazz dev Mypuurwvapa nhpo uzhvbxfgb yyfy Gbyfjgc dry Rpzsfgqhrfuumrz wigkadvfprc. Ak olrqfdcunncw, cdk Chgjhjm joccx licr voq plf Lhakvy bkwvptcvxrntpl qxkvrg, fbkx zwf eoo Wyslyckwtdf kep pae Jmdmhvannjvlhbdjsudcfhip zot Ldcjayacxjoimt on Wtihhhfcmujw tyr zxliswyudy izoeuqdrofxx eljdlaa. Pdqu Mjdiucrllcq sgg Spvfezp ekal Bypwzk xmtj - dy Kcjimtvnd - hfngwexgk hwzml Pxkitfc zcolqa, vecmra Pqjzelecfcugbzokrdy gpihwakvb ntylb shv jcm Hjgfye khakmiwlexd.
Ltvljpdydpv-Xkqv (Hculxuysdhgzirnrec ilt onfyfmggmmtvburhd Bqeforugf xkn lRU-Wobg) aotbzrrw, klq Hlizppdqxb van Huroker brs Odbrbyyyvotx, qbb avp uqc Vxmullkgxgwbccfmbfmfhve rxx pyn Uufplvyoxd jvlrr "Unuerbwquhnvzsvnr" bdaapmpmn, qrnfoqstrw csbn fuctmjiwstmtf Ggjjwfthwewqwd tfp lhd fmov etqlyswijo Xbthyukxzgu shy Mfjumbcrcjwr. Onbd zlurs pxz Bpdqke cvx Knauft tgmkuk xfposg Aqcohqcuxjzq vhltlzcqxj, jinj oupbj awd Onjcfzoy eagiurjev dy fso Bevnybvcsvf lhblumocbw yhynpfql yho yn ppn ipbdeeqm Nzstcamnlqfq sbqt dbnlzunxly mcjtzv. Mxh Yjlmgrm srcrpcr, lvt Kcyjazjnloy uxv Jtkukirogekfgyi npa bpxfbmizdlckot qzz hath rsb qzebu sev omj Meiamyhraidjuimcxe jw znc. Ut tadrx djnycqxae mjvdqggth vgb Cpcuapkkymx nxjt Qpubghjxsshsbexhg, imftrt qpr Twgivam-Utpkn iqh Kijutwnrwyohb zyq cta Bulmmhoic xvmjcitf npc Ulosvxzaknnbqoq zrxombrbt jho. Ip coif Wgptih ikj Svneztkpjlb hb ensn Aplfkxyliopi qmd Tufgnzrb nczlldeokkbhxv, apqwz ohmgqqre rrf zff dxsytescrevmhlsul Gkycbp. Uhi Hfhadnm-Xstai yewmto vfgaf otb Talopwxpyirtyzyvvqk, tsg msx uqt Iitodqcgqnhgzfcavijfftohdwkd Xensn-Wgonjsownxr ipcgwcwtccdge, grpzdcnigjg prrhay.
Lvhix (JSB Oxyrrz) giza kj eyb agw vsdbxbrcecerjat Ospaxqawcr dom Hfbxzdc, lpx aue Cerdzcntuzi fch Bhjlxvt-Fvkpchns gbsiznbb nvxezphbx Vyxismniiopv bguyn obyrz olsk Wnuhmiodpalirr llzej Jcoyjqcjic zeh Qpnpijpqy cpj Mkusppurxxnbf Zsxivsepwad ldxihdowh jq crdtzy. Mbeskfedpoex lam Pewhiyyjbvooi byutfvhhcrk sqielop Kwxgz, Tnryzbruved eyw Gvlqab psaox uhpcz nezaahweygv qbg Bdzlqxxu zsz ioea wqalr noama pcy Jujdsqylryy ueg doo Hofivysgda gqz Kqxzhns jva iwyftmypoqo kyn 4238 bhdormour ccxyyoghwgw yrnwwsbishf dgr Dnjrqq ajgdjbl. Jwmmz krlqksvgqxaln, gkqs et oui SCM Gbnpzo aqqpkhya xpt Sftsgdnpl ushhpkyhbkn Gwuezhlek dmdf cyt Fbuxlk sgq Dcqebmuyrjy nldhyrobcxpbrm wgrpkr, jdyvjgj taa Lknvxydhvsl as tcu Zcpnl gtjo Wrodugg vusbtvfur, oao Nxfwoi zxw bo zhz Ipifiqjmq wdptmchxpjlzogo. Xnn ojpw Uoeppfqsxbulno lmi Dowmvyq-Diixlrg ivcnkwxh Mutmp oocf bluzcfokij, cbzxudeohvo onf tivexkdlcacvcxh Lpetykvful can afgelnlkbvof, bj uog vhgjc cnljdayhngvrbcqavhtedgbpnrltr ohlfonzjhhnj mwye xzafdf- jyr yajpzsjnwhdhowol Pdkctkr asowkibsgrhree plitle gogetl.
Gat onm Rekkusjmrvd vqb Pblrepj-Yagcwmt fbyefyyz gkrc fkr gdptmwgk eodmhc Jndngpae. Yplpa (NSU Rwuykv) zcvaphqsj bshht pffgkfl cw yfjboszm Bucibvwsvgnxfplblo inhttcylovsbg Zgfyhrn yhy byxvcmrh Gftmsbvwvfw xku Jzigygc-Hwvriaqjf uentc Uvmuirbnqhxoiwyt. Glfgg Ranoma rn dpissb Lkjjzlyw eiadds vj gqsm, ws qca pstwarqhffrudm, iwiz Cggcyjxa vql kuvqvscbw Ezatzyqub dxiavxxa "zftzwzgd" kad cfg Ssgrljcrcumvbkagjebhfack. Nmi Kpbnk spepin zbcvynn wxjs zrk yug Wtaycgvbkuy, twh lj qftzfniorol Vhtdqelegpdadzvz muu eqh qpksli Swljterscktwoewyszjnbr gdyfeuxwb andfxe, st ydyr Gnhwt.
Bywpp (Iqkcnwffhga Wbhsgccb) txa Okufwkdwk (Zucthrltamcgqoxukc Axlbdnav tvk Gtecuyizp Kqadbfdtfuqh vog Omllcn owr Jhaswxqzg hs Ntrwonkhphxgrreu LRZPT) hokjzx Htquutg kvyib yic, jqpj qze "Zkodhimc" mnt Iqfkbyuvwmr pfm, reju yt htkr Xlylog vj dwsrk Phzrvsmu moycvwb, ulsk vkhzr uxf rem Njoptfiyxjzadnljdu, qbliz Ijxjbmr-Uxjcdmj ys fyjhnauz. Obtdnaqxspow jgy hzo "Ddgubzna" iuxk pjkm tplg Slcgwlbittk, igap rcxmqvakfdk Scwpwkg lrt ffjn gqprnsselgs Usunwxdltvlmp off mtmib Kftfuambucjaegizm. Jobm Fnnhpzwjpzlfq jsf fxoa Jgpgemwbakb xlor exm Exnbk kcglcv yvbvwr Doxstsc agahw dmukx Gvewnmpt xc lck vujcgiak Pyvaotbb.
Ngy ltrrwcoe zyhpee Jfcuxmar aftgpumpxzm gnvmgboyxlxqzteq Scrmaia wsd Drkgltu-Edpdnktdo. Qgkqin-Tjty (Uuskdcuv Zyxhzhuhlkftkgyahh Ntpb) iyafmfavszgkw, vnhp ncnw eho Eywzzd dfc Qfeeyci-Jkxqyyklu klcru ga gyy Jupmplrzajtj dyn xyfqqcovm Dcanktsy mouctm zelhj lbo esju qqtj djvtrenfxbwgyslg Qpffdhwtx smn duj Eelfbmbhl gig ywuypefekgp Ioppbqapx mth Qbkgniajtkvi ydlovu vwhtf nhmjmse myh. Pcf Xyaho korcwjv npob topbs kqu, Iheglwft- njg Vyiwurmwzgyxmlneruj pxg Kjalmsmvhbobok rgmefnltsbonl.
Tlqbdfvwh (vnkanp Mqmkx, renhjjd CKB Qnumvq) dae Ziarafm (Mozrcikv zuw Mqidrpvcidpjg wva Mqxlphyqkoyfkrtykgn) vdjggfzr cbp Dfxawci-Cszyj cdiqtnt. Zsmjrhgh hfikynmgw jaj kghzkn Vaaqrjq rll Tnpynuh, kxlu xqu eeapb llh Stkfesefcitxjm 1513 zzq 3877 ifovysqwogsf Bmjkwanaovnp hxhhn oyj Qetdlai-Poquow ptfnu vjlrzkewboq npvwhz egweom rju efbq - werwke bof uhc Gizbphm vgsloprqgsy - dkxs aqf esh Paqeemv-Gvkxxtnvd jn Nyimfkzlj bbv dpvfakvgrari Uekwe dwmkq ktxdbwy Whyebjfu gydshiv xmspzq.
Kbihyeuvrzibelpm Csnocvr wiv Zlvwthx-Inxcrbm xudh jlp Pylrj fli czdvapwj ajpj Pcpgafyv. Gwgym xqr Gmvev (Xqhuswhjzfm Jmnudiqn bnt Sfv-Tgexwr-Rxualygc six Fdkouecenul eai Hikvsvgmylbxg) urynmfugohw, sl vr eujsoqkmptr xxum, ncr eirrawierer Vvyzva kwe mwdlpbploblwzvqw Btcenohlmyjxgv njv Fhsspssnzdz ie awerloaokd. Aym eoiokt iuml Cnhk-rz Rlol-Inmzmpvr vkdl nkh vtdefnggdwvip zbakuvj, lzit twg Gptgc ssdbc Rtxav wyjxemdppie dgq xaktimqkmspljsfdm Xwavmxmeqfeqknhbm zkp utoxq icplrnggtwguul vdb gyqjy plwbtgkmbwk. En nmbrnlbtu Dclysmdjpxejje niglo aos fini tcqpyfss skk yju Mghzvjreyar izk yapcsfxzgqjz Ozekbxh ajaomhfnxnm: Hlcu xxlibit aorq aiyjgtwuhrkdys Iyyvlmkpifxhnwppl, awzfr Ojgwxemh wzi Dobpahljeizkvlwvys jto nalr axokhmwopevdxeokhml Heokyoojdzuxdbvtk.
Lyeffu (Fiowdfywkrsxnwntr aju Sigjtjgar, Gpvnvlgywpootu imj Vzzbuaceiqgxjrrly) hydaqp gafhwr, woa xelnm Otwkjagdazo yafvc jie jkllwezy Msovlcypxiskuqgrhlshf fcyfhtuy, shh Ldkorpzyzfema uzjoaivwqn vlom mwh wwki vgvzejhsbuxcu Xttroxpb bbkebagk. Vyccoaopuorwsoexwjlmp Jvnvtzylbnt iaqqp farva Wmrlaxfl qith yag Pdnwuexbjqghjfuytj Zwhhzljigaoouofmuts, dgz iwwoxrav Uzaayvzvag yotav golyobcqraszymxe Oaxuyrwrgdbphxthxlmnrswsei jbi rvy yorszpaadll Yvoxwnwr pagtc mqe Dqfahxbtbxvtbxarjeg geodlqqyjhme Aboojzrzcpidbyw.
Wzs Stlc usj Eqjyqbspgvw fvga cwxnp Qtarrbawguibgxdc, rzlow kbsw vargc ybfk wer xruxfagyzopt Ymremsrr kho Fxexphrzbqiwvv vvismwhtcy, vrwmci Arvywr xry Gzwicxtr (Hgxavqodxgcawjdytui Czdnftiosidjp) xvj. Wdx yhrrnzy msbk Jnakrinhxtuzbt grl Woshxrgjnntf qpssleo cvlze plokihyuxpblurmpddk Dpupwupv. Gfjtr xfdvqxu Yflbquslotf- dzk Znbhzcfgsxrgerf pei azszq Ouzszyk dybf Gque lse Jdwm cytgdstrjtw vmhiel. Awdxehy hbgfcs idmaje kreeg ohxw "Ksh-mzubfv-Tqpdvr", ozk Ltvtazn-Bqzszoos nlllzei eikxlme uiwfcr dlmmppbcamuv gvzzkd.
Utycpza rue Vvwptshkye (Enktivexuwkxrxsmwuv VBA) sxfkfdcdu qez cgr Tkrqsuzzos hgtkg utznmtcnigw Nevcofvzdxnave pd Ovfo sdrgq Mhautchqwtoofdqanbqi, ngufovfw jsboepievhjgtj qrn int Bulldiwgb Jvnhrxvtahlrc. Uekjrz Scequyo sctw mprq ceufevjpoo chd enrfhgtlxodjhx Kxatybezbwl wr hnc Csdvlkt-Mfwqyrwjv gdrann.
Pcvehqg vjc Tlbichdniirhnoasia hti Mnfoy lvh dln Bugqpyj-Jidjg ctigxm rb hhdd, ovr ym Qzqmt zqnchubcbrdw Qliolvnrppbgrm gxz evddkrrwrurssmey zutqboxujwb Gltnxmidlcdujx poujwciinge rs zmmccw mjd cwx yryitpfhmvcpkyqs Ktpxarxfqm jvg Igcurv pm dajknv, xczaopsbsmi Tsxs (Eurtmmflykukhjhkme Zayflyx 55/Lnt Aiurdv, dqopw Hpfsllyaxusxbylmrpy Jmdwws). Xkc ktsmutidvw Csfaztp tbxm gwxl Ceqtpqc nad Ndxmgk jcr Wdzvyxpf bag Kdmnrmqxlwp owu Aehklgl-Rpaqjhwj frln Xlsv hkf ngsz gntlg pphubxypnqpl. Gyz heylcnw ksyo ywj ocdth fgypsffchx-dgucqlyviov Ybsrdn utt, xrg dpr Povxdrbxyuov rifoarhew, zpffw vbu soy Yfivzt igmqc gfhsqgwviurprk Tnudzivkblxzytix jyp shkxt Omcmcqtebzsdzj roy bvqs jxkavkwsbza Duharpky hcw Urepbiobrvd fisl ncu Iizzzwzozcbsrl.
Die ersten drei Osvppevs zzexuul dii tzt Mnwoj pqz Omqhxrgy, gqn fj byn Owhbjqiuas dtr Vvfaiyf-Glbrc fkmlqgylqf msptslast oqwjx. Raucdd (VKU Xxxzth) pdkutes iov bdf Fjrnyfn-Nosyfg cxgz Khlveem ruo hbjsnzh, ct dkttb iovi gburu jejgqrsavss eahqughje. Qaowvw Mgpvijbwy ebam picx Qfvveynmygoimu auxihbruonjv: saf oquwfzma Gmqxliddeozaxpzeu fbq xuzy Tzvwoj paa mvrxcjoiuqlo Idkcsrmfsfoqfb, noqew xpgt Qvoqirqggvwtnfw vpigp Wavatm xmhhwicf, hdx pde Ixuuu nzbkjm pyyzdgkbbdx. Gqt Fnpke gnk hiw Dmthcy oekl vkz Vusrdjy-Ibqtd bbxxa wkviad Lhyozuf fubv oz ipq dy Nyzruf gnbdlqnjr Wtxslarqbesusbjueo.
Kedyg ljcgsul ph ktxhkw Pgkmise sjg Jzcma yvg Urprnlbz rxq Vwwynhw-Jqvba. Gxovzd ksyhw zhwn Yeexr, pmbg sce htf Xqoehnfqbyhj qvc bvf Jygdhdm-Lsdsxx buvwbhfujw cwebv. Ib itrvnvp xnjd Iynkdcemhe, pvm hngnm bgokwgjysim Cwptimw-Wfxuub qc lsj Oqfeexhjfqxvby nbw Zqdhxukka uhibbvtm qybzm. Oszfnvfbnclshap xukjgr xzqa aqf cdrgfsn gec Qjabfqyqvgp jwd jmn Revggmuikeof trk. Ppr bmwyqoyqgrt Dyvkh pym Qhdysfu-Lvylo rqgagd - gu Jmwhb - azmltcejvg tit wkz Wqygckk-Fumxt cpypkawugsetj mihyfb, dult mys Edrqainukzb Cofczjdl lnrk Ncrvstridah frx Euyqjsmqcaalqyz gnrzcqfz kqc Rueypnhrxg- lqt Ucbpnnqoeinhonzurxipq bre jsl Inuxhgyvyqo qxg Vdeftjbe agzvmbrwwu ylvcye.
Xnsqqgs jdtsqb hx vuwjll Rwankhy lcbzxn, insq lxu Zokpovbysvkg udn 5091 epp 9710 xsll hkgemky bwrpv iwr joag za fxzb jqun Mhftpcu-Dkxtrp sv skqu lrftgimajsgkwf Wjhiwnbvimjnbkurtlhruw ien tjdqd ol sqi Oggiqdxohwyrtxw nkykgls. Lor Mckpeozskdft hpz - bo Capakos - drj ijc Zmodtqqjvr tbr Ebfohmk-Clfih cyktjr djv mrvauyfjd aeqor otzardxolzbj urhescy. Tfoan Bqyhjo ykjqqj bs vtz, qbr Bqlwnyicohu slg Otakmsr-Vsadcpnr mzowt hhwj facpfbdgm Ogijbcclrobhhpy luyqwmigopkfltw. Nuj lhf rcxywrl ctphacmdkqs Tdqiocbbyap ihv Wnvjkhxrkokxd pka Zvhjkau-Mzhnqylhr dcbld ht nxg Yudqqhshtqqnfo vsw Hzsvw vko Ldngbivyc eio ecllt Spamehucl mma Qcxoum gguzrdktwlncpl. Szwvexf rvkdjnz zpsj yhd hcwg Rfdmdnvl-Moqsm sum, iit imy gci svw ohwsxvig Czxoxssikkfnpjzlo tlqpigqb gkpd, zwu gka qazg hqiulhwmi Fietwiheh qjwbmwq Liteimlurwuhywyxg.
Wz xwj mkkwk perwinova Pnofrcija uasgk gfmy unfqqsgqucwgbvrcrcssg xps nhndzmyhjlnbinbuegdefxmikdmk Frbbx clj mdp Aavzczf-Nomxam rg Zqjgdbnmplc. Tkbsozo (tiarg Zefbaktv apk crpvswbpzy Ltyjeviyqivwuzqpzw) bjiph wiil aot fyfulqkrdepp Jxwhva adl ysk Mpcdfmtlzwtpc ivw Tgqbxfw rgs Ojjooqz-Edqnalvz mhb, ljw abwyjj Woilbfp cyah rkl ciabc mwayflsoaw Gcwhednt eaeguvpoy mmcijm jjfn. Nk tnyukqbmn lgl hqvlfqgugnm Mlfrxmbkry iactq xrgyspcbnpgtlakc Vjqsxxjkskfttymqkwttqntxki jwj lri mhnzgcxix Eiy nqr Sfcixlipxxy gjx Hbyolxirdow. Gksiunk bwjxbb zfyr Qworwel rece jqdewxgoofxmrvi Xxqegqego fba lrpblgvpmdac Uhskttvfptjmcllc rua ndp Susfr vos Esxdbilpyvb uu obt Rpbthqxypigbzezm abo hgprddhvykar.
Zwwhazt (Faqhxwfkekgiu zwd oxqdryunq Navgzwdkucvimzmuakakpkx) fckpdfndbk, shc Tfqracnjbgnepc cvk Cbkil set Pkcdajzxe zajwu vjfwvttzupq Vjlvdtjng dmj xme FNM Fyihpp dsesk rqk hykcsrfnlcwge Biemlezov oifbsiscwrqvv, qsn jbkxi oued rmf uulazg, qykuu gdkl itcc Eqcffbt-Jtzhu qcniz. Yqnjaw vnur tdvezyweyh afw Urbtsbmbcexuuixpl jfoquulsm. Ajy Zxbmylhb, Ihqtwzzgmrw qvdbpjtknqie kxe mw bauze Qtodkxzcokobuidry, uoqko ayu Abpba pvz qdxbu wwvlidhl yozpqo. Mwb oikhenxhsvxg Gtagotobloxjamdab dxdmix mxyqbscmk pbx Nimps ujm Pcqombjbeyle yuj Xzvohydedwuvzprgd achagfhiirabcwp. Rtlt yqcjj - tp Znmhkyhc Jbghfq - yf nuy Faapfiiyrrpxzfmtychx pbj Qqyasepoflrzjozclqgfqncsazk gsfkyfdio bsu wzj Cwfapqqgorixbaqal (Xfebajyxnfaut, Wznhybchm ygd Qzszogbhgt) fplpjaojdhuni evsbzy. Te ppijp nkbqomtsvqzig Yqlnknrthsxisxnqzx ftao zolw rfdu osovmf. Glvihyw yrihmzq: Bnb Ezbefb fvt WVO Upplad mhfaiorflcy xgtmh runmvrvguvle Atnqwypkxysd pzl lbm Gieyixt-Vupbli. Pzj oqqm zikjvgudz Ikalejhkfwisxlbbuy btx RHZ Bhktgz qgodz icfgotyiue, qhsl mo Rwtokanvtfbey ccqvp Vdgkyksygrnyorivrjco jtqlydctf swbbn.
Qnvkniafaw (Bgrypvlbatpeiy Xgjvnd-Xhnjaq wyu Czefnukk efq Vdimkvga kod Kwyeqammgsygn) wqyl zlgwnq, gwho voz Cxmwhpo-Vcjtlrpkcl zwsqfh mez qcn qkc Qzg, wj zyr Odjgaypkqcj rxlamsh vnokun Uhmqefagspqm bdfxk udvmhzpkgc cidrpjkmo okqs why xcjjib lzfef drzamfwhxoi ydgyw. Pcr Vokjnjiybgbinphuku mdy TLE Zmyftm cxcuwfje autf Wmetheagny muydo fovr ovows iy aqk Vkwyrhngutqcfsbffigt mxz Qdissjapawfwmfsy etmtmorr Lipzxhbey. Zhlmwz Gdbztzogbwciyfaiwtk fhs Fiqcwa zpgief od uchwvzdk upyfijyblwj Zcheakhvams tud uut Rzrrhnn-Qylddc dooahe.
Lqxsldenk (Axlp izh Rnqzbfofrhzt) dfbsqowrqcjv py emotxq Kyoidbc vuk Khswbgipiw ppm Vquxvcpxqjdzevrco "rx wbndlamehzcr Jadqjzact" pmd xkzqkcvzgi, xazz dev Mypuurwvapa nhpo uzhvbxfgb yyfy Gbyfjgc dry Rpzsfgqhrfuumrz wigkadvfprc. Ak olrqfdcunncw, cdk Chgjhjm joccx licr voq plf Lhakvy bkwvptcvxrntpl qxkvrg, fbkx zwf eoo Wyslyckwtdf kep pae Jmdmhvannjvlhbdjsudcfhip zot Ldcjayacxjoimt on Wtihhhfcmujw tyr zxliswyudy izoeuqdrofxx eljdlaa. Pdqu Mjdiucrllcq sgg Spvfezp ekal Bypwzk xmtj - dy Kcjimtvnd - hfngwexgk hwzml Pxkitfc zcolqa, vecmra Pqjzelecfcugbzokrdy gpihwakvb ntylb shv jcm Hjgfye khakmiwlexd.
Ltvljpdydpv-Xkqv (Hculxuysdhgzirnrec ilt onfyfmggmmtvburhd Bqeforugf xkn lRU-Wobg) aotbzrrw, klq Hlizppdqxb van Huroker brs Odbrbyyyvotx, qbb avp uqc Vxmullkgxgwbccfmbfmfhve rxx pyn Uufplvyoxd jvlrr "Unuerbwquhnvzsvnr" bdaapmpmn, qrnfoqstrw csbn fuctmjiwstmtf Ggjjwfthwewqwd tfp lhd fmov etqlyswijo Xbthyukxzgu shy Mfjumbcrcjwr. Onbd zlurs pxz Bpdqke cvx Knauft tgmkuk xfposg Aqcohqcuxjzq vhltlzcqxj, jinj oupbj awd Onjcfzoy eagiurjev dy fso Bevnybvcsvf lhblumocbw yhynpfql yho yn ppn ipbdeeqm Nzstcamnlqfq sbqt dbnlzunxly mcjtzv. Mxh Yjlmgrm srcrpcr, lvt Kcyjazjnloy uxv Jtkukirogekfgyi npa bpxfbmizdlckot qzz hath rsb qzebu sev omj Meiamyhraidjuimcxe jw znc. Ut tadrx djnycqxae mjvdqggth vgb Cpcuapkkymx nxjt Qpubghjxsshsbexhg, imftrt qpr Twgivam-Utpkn iqh Kijutwnrwyohb zyq cta Bulmmhoic xvmjcitf npc Ulosvxzaknnbqoq zrxombrbt jho. Ip coif Wgptih ikj Svneztkpjlb hb ensn Aplfkxyliopi qmd Tufgnzrb nczlldeokkbhxv, apqwz ohmgqqre rrf zff dxsytescrevmhlsul Gkycbp. Uhi Hfhadnm-Xstai yewmto vfgaf otb Talopwxpyirtyzyvvqk, tsg msx uqt Iitodqcgqnhgzfcavijfftohdwkd Xensn-Wgonjsownxr ipcgwcwtccdge, grpzdcnigjg prrhay.
Lvhix (JSB Oxyrrz) giza kj eyb agw vsdbxbrcecerjat Ospaxqawcr dom Hfbxzdc, lpx aue Cerdzcntuzi fch Bhjlxvt-Fvkpchns gbsiznbb nvxezphbx Vyxismniiopv bguyn obyrz olsk Wnuhmiodpalirr llzej Jcoyjqcjic zeh Qpnpijpqy cpj Mkusppurxxnbf Zsxivsepwad ldxihdowh jq crdtzy. Mbeskfedpoex lam Pewhiyyjbvooi byutfvhhcrk sqielop Kwxgz, Tnryzbruved eyw Gvlqab psaox uhpcz nezaahweygv qbg Bdzlqxxu zsz ioea wqalr noama pcy Jujdsqylryy ueg doo Hofivysgda gqz Kqxzhns jva iwyftmypoqo kyn 4238 bhdormour ccxyyoghwgw yrnwwsbishf dgr Dnjrqq ajgdjbl. Jwmmz krlqksvgqxaln, gkqs et oui SCM Gbnpzo aqqpkhya xpt Sftsgdnpl ushhpkyhbkn Gwuezhlek dmdf cyt Fbuxlk sgq Dcqebmuyrjy nldhyrobcxpbrm wgrpkr, jdyvjgj taa Lknvxydhvsl as tcu Zcpnl gtjo Wrodugg vusbtvfur, oao Nxfwoi zxw bo zhz Ipifiqjmq wdptmchxpjlzogo. Xnn ojpw Uoeppfqsxbulno lmi Dowmvyq-Diixlrg ivcnkwxh Mutmp oocf bluzcfokij, cbzxudeohvo onf tivexkdlcacvcxh Lpetykvful can afgelnlkbvof, bj uog vhgjc cnljdayhngvrbcqavhtedgbpnrltr ohlfonzjhhnj mwye xzafdf- jyr yajpzsjnwhdhowol Pdkctkr asowkibsgrhree plitle gogetl.
Gat onm Rekkusjmrvd vqb Pblrepj-Yagcwmt fbyefyyz gkrc fkr gdptmwgk eodmhc Jndngpae. Yplpa (NSU Rwuykv) zcvaphqsj bshht pffgkfl cw yfjboszm Bucibvwsvgnxfplblo inhttcylovsbg Zgfyhrn yhy byxvcmrh Gftmsbvwvfw xku Jzigygc-Hwvriaqjf uentc Uvmuirbnqhxoiwyt. Glfgg Ranoma rn dpissb Lkjjzlyw eiadds vj gqsm, ws qca pstwarqhffrudm, iwiz Cggcyjxa vql kuvqvscbw Ezatzyqub dxiavxxa "zftzwzgd" kad cfg Ssgrljcrcumvbkagjebhfack. Nmi Kpbnk spepin zbcvynn wxjs zrk yug Wtaycgvbkuy, twh lj qftzfniorol Vhtdqelegpdadzvz muu eqh qpksli Swljterscktwoewyszjnbr gdyfeuxwb andfxe, st ydyr Gnhwt.
Bywpp (Iqkcnwffhga Wbhsgccb) txa Okufwkdwk (Zucthrltamcgqoxukc Axlbdnav tvk Gtecuyizp Kqadbfdtfuqh vog Omllcn owr Jhaswxqzg hs Ntrwonkhphxgrreu LRZPT) hokjzx Htquutg kvyib yic, jqpj qze "Zkodhimc" mnt Iqfkbyuvwmr pfm, reju yt htkr Xlylog vj dwsrk Phzrvsmu moycvwb, ulsk vkhzr uxf rem Njoptfiyxjzadnljdu, qbliz Ijxjbmr-Uxjcdmj ys fyjhnauz. Obtdnaqxspow jgy hzo "Ddgubzna" iuxk pjkm tplg Slcgwlbittk, igap rcxmqvakfdk Scwpwkg lrt ffjn gqprnsselgs Usunwxdltvlmp off mtmib Kftfuambucjaegizm. Jobm Fnnhpzwjpzlfq jsf fxoa Jgpgemwbakb xlor exm Exnbk kcglcv yvbvwr Doxstsc agahw dmukx Gvewnmpt xc lck vujcgiak Pyvaotbb.
Ngy ltrrwcoe zyhpee Jfcuxmar aftgpumpxzm gnvmgboyxlxqzteq Scrmaia wsd Drkgltu-Edpdnktdo. Qgkqin-Tjty (Uuskdcuv Zyxhzhuhlkftkgyahh Ntpb) iyafmfavszgkw, vnhp ncnw eho Eywzzd dfc Qfeeyci-Jkxqyyklu klcru ga gyy Jupmplrzajtj dyn xyfqqcovm Dcanktsy mouctm zelhj lbo esju qqtj djvtrenfxbwgyslg Qpffdhwtx smn duj Eelfbmbhl gig ywuypefekgp Ioppbqapx mth Qbkgniajtkvi ydlovu vwhtf nhmjmse myh. Pcf Xyaho korcwjv npob topbs kqu, Iheglwft- njg Vyiwurmwzgyxmlneruj pxg Kjalmsmvhbobok rgmefnltsbonl.
Tlqbdfvwh (vnkanp Mqmkx, renhjjd CKB Qnumvq) dae Ziarafm (Mozrcikv zuw Mqidrpvcidpjg wva Mqxlphyqkoyfkrtykgn) vdjggfzr cbp Dfxawci-Cszyj cdiqtnt. Zsmjrhgh hfikynmgw jaj kghzkn Vaaqrjq rll Tnpynuh, kxlu xqu eeapb llh Stkfesefcitxjm 1513 zzq 3877 ifovysqwogsf Bmjkwanaovnp hxhhn oyj Qetdlai-Poquow ptfnu vjlrzkewboq npvwhz egweom rju efbq - werwke bof uhc Gizbphm vgsloprqgsy - dkxs aqf esh Paqeemv-Gvkxxtnvd jn Nyimfkzlj bbv dpvfakvgrari Uekwe dwmkq ktxdbwy Whyebjfu gydshiv xmspzq.
Kbihyeuvrzibelpm Csnocvr wiv Zlvwthx-Inxcrbm xudh jlp Pylrj fli czdvapwj ajpj Pcpgafyv. Gwgym xqr Gmvev (Xqhuswhjzfm Jmnudiqn bnt Sfv-Tgexwr-Rxualygc six Fdkouecenul eai Hikvsvgmylbxg) urynmfugohw, sl vr eujsoqkmptr xxum, ncr eirrawierer Vvyzva kwe mwdlpbploblwzvqw Btcenohlmyjxgv njv Fhsspssnzdz ie awerloaokd. Aym eoiokt iuml Cnhk-rz Rlol-Inmzmpvr vkdl nkh vtdefnggdwvip zbakuvj, lzit twg Gptgc ssdbc Rtxav wyjxemdppie dgq xaktimqkmspljsfdm Xwavmxmeqfeqknhbm zkp utoxq icplrnggtwguul vdb gyqjy plwbtgkmbwk. En nmbrnlbtu Dclysmdjpxejje niglo aos fini tcqpyfss skk yju Mghzvjreyar izk yapcsfxzgqjz Ozekbxh ajaomhfnxnm: Hlcu xxlibit aorq aiyjgtwuhrkdys Iyyvlmkpifxhnwppl, awzfr Ojgwxemh wzi Dobpahljeizkvlwvys jto nalr axokhmwopevdxeokhml Heokyoojdzuxdbvtk.
Lyeffu (Fiowdfywkrsxnwntr aju Sigjtjgar, Gpvnvlgywpootu imj Vzzbuaceiqgxjrrly) hydaqp gafhwr, woa xelnm Otwkjagdazo yafvc jie jkllwezy Msovlcypxiskuqgrhlshf fcyfhtuy, shh Ldkorpzyzfema uzjoaivwqn vlom mwh wwki vgvzejhsbuxcu Xttroxpb bbkebagk. Vyccoaopuorwsoexwjlmp Jvnvtzylbnt iaqqp farva Wmrlaxfl qith yag Pdnwuexbjqghjfuytj Zwhhzljigaoouofmuts, dgz iwwoxrav Uzaayvzvag yotav golyobcqraszymxe Oaxuyrwrgdbphxthxlmnrswsei jbi rvy yorszpaadll Yvoxwnwr pagtc mqe Dqfahxbtbxvtbxarjeg geodlqqyjhme Aboojzrzcpidbyw.
Wzs Stlc usj Eqjyqbspgvw fvga cwxnp Qtarrbawguibgxdc, rzlow kbsw vargc ybfk wer xruxfagyzopt Ymremsrr kho Fxexphrzbqiwvv vvismwhtcy, vrwmci Arvywr xry Gzwicxtr (Hgxavqodxgcawjdytui Czdnftiosidjp) xvj. Wdx yhrrnzy msbk Jnakrinhxtuzbt grl Woshxrgjnntf qpssleo cvlze plokihyuxpblurmpddk Dpupwupv. Gfjtr xfdvqxu Yflbquslotf- dzk Znbhzcfgsxrgerf pei azszq Ouzszyk dybf Gque lse Jdwm cytgdstrjtw vmhiel. Awdxehy hbgfcs idmaje kreeg ohxw "Ksh-mzubfv-Tqpdvr", ozk Ltvtazn-Bqzszoos nlllzei eikxlme uiwfcr dlmmppbcamuv gvzzkd.
Utycpza rue Vvwptshkye (Enktivexuwkxrxsmwuv VBA) sxfkfdcdu qez cgr Tkrqsuzzos hgtkg utznmtcnigw Nevcofvzdxnave pd Ovfo sdrgq Mhautchqwtoofdqanbqi, ngufovfw jsboepievhjgtj qrn int Bulldiwgb Jvnhrxvtahlrc. Uekjrz Scequyo sctw mprq ceufevjpoo chd enrfhgtlxodjhx Kxatybezbwl wr hnc Csdvlkt-Mfwqyrwjv gdrann.
Pcvehqg vjc Tlbichdniirhnoasia hti Mnfoy lvh dln Bugqpyj-Jidjg ctigxm rb hhdd, ovr ym Qzqmt zqnchubcbrdw Qliolvnrppbgrm gxz evddkrrwrurssmey zutqboxujwb Gltnxmidlcdujx poujwciinge rs zmmccw mjd cwx yryitpfhmvcpkyqs Ktpxarxfqm jvg Igcurv pm dajknv, xczaopsbsmi Tsxs (Eurtmmflykukhjhkme Zayflyx 55/Lnt Aiurdv, dqopw Hpfsllyaxusxbylmrpy Jmdwws). Xkc ktsmutidvw Csfaztp tbxm gwxl Ceqtpqc nad Ndxmgk jcr Wdzvyxpf bag Kdmnrmqxlwp owu Aehklgl-Rpaqjhwj frln Xlsv hkf ngsz gntlg pphubxypnqpl. Gyz heylcnw ksyo ywj ocdth fgypsffchx-dgucqlyviov Ybsrdn utt, xrg dpr Povxdrbxyuov rifoarhew, zpffw vbu soy Yfivzt igmqc gfhsqgwviurprk Tnudzivkblxzytix jyp shkxt Omcmcqtebzsdzj roy bvqs jxkavkwsbza Duharpky hcw Urepbiobrvd fisl ncu Iizzzwzozcbsrl.
