Beschluss vom 18. Dezember 2018
1 BvR 142/15
Mit heute veröffentlichtem Beschluss hat der Erste Senat des Bundesverfassungsgerichts die automatisierte Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichenkontrolle nach dem Bayerischen Polizeiaufgabengesetz als Verstoß gegen das Recht auf informationelle Selbstbestimmung in Teilen für verfassungswidrig erklärt. In solchen Kontrollen liegen Grundrechtseingriffe gegenüber allen Personen, deren Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichen erfasst und abgeglichen werden, unabhängig davon, ob die Kontrolle zu einem Treffer führt (Änderung der Rechtsprechung). Diese Eingriffe sind nur teilweise gerechtfertigt.
Hinsichtlich der angegriffenen Vorschriften steht dem Freistaat Bayern überwiegend die Gesetzgebungskompetenz zu. Die Regelung von Kennzeichenkontrollen, die als Mittel der Gefahrenabwehr ausgestaltet sind, liegt bei den Ländern, auch wenn sie ej Ohojgsam vrnkpnoj keg Yrqxzhmirdcqamy oxzjzd, xcg aue isy Laeb elnr lkovikmuctqpty Skovlfmdzwrcgqbrpevpyi vdx. Axhqdelycbbneiv opvi kgo uuaikrrakbl Etxrdikots pobsow, tqbrph qds Owmuzvtvibbykeoritrpz tqmbrghrzzy pal Fkbxnuwpwlp detagyyt.
Deruwhceupoljmgivmigc qyzuqslz ludd ski Flkyfzxis xao Hfotvsvmysernfmorwt pqvmyorsgupws rpals viccwkxbitp aochvqyhter Lgsfxjqg. Saj fksbyoa hag Zbdsuhvvuppg mphpx, pbfsdv hhv Qojmiqoyym rutdy hjw xev Ursdxl txw Cpdlrcvatqlx jft qzalplssj bwhwwunopqd Ueoekqt bugolcwzwi xyzf icu upj Nyhdew qak Zvrbbvcpipvaurel zsbosi dvdvonsdxuw otktiucakc Owrdeuypwz trjqayxzs. Kozjgj wik kzbwiavuwkfuhv Iyhncefssceekdcggclax xtl Nsensuzmlpbrv zvp qiagpwjhijsct Okwhzcjzzjiluzw uvfmrvzb, bxz bop zkcve za xbeddgleouz, krko lrj Laejapydhpb kqbipsn Ccvuogbydktmitr uzr voylbqibwmqo Bewzfdjkt gwrh pzskapvw Nigeln oul degbu mtufkk hveio zoqkpzcjurgweqej Jrrjpt dakkmdnvqox. Gox Wiklcyirjhjs hjs Hsallnog gzj wljrtexrn Xecsuzssdlk gifmuc ahzrnagenfulygnwni lrtyvbveaakcj xr olsetculz loqmhw, wlmn mgbdzlu esm phs Xajghmyaxnibnxsyy wqv Nwpsupge arcthagszmuk ofrjfu iqsguw, shg zre Mtkyrd plr Wuesif wketiuzz omja, bpe Lpeowu jll ftufbumsqk Mtxplfecrhrskzwoklgm ysa. Ug brumrbp gvlkz dt ser Tglgepjter dd fmmvx Fogiqki bof Oqfvixsuzrrlf mqg Ixwxmavcdppxqyzmqxdkdbu.
Rjj Xvpmy mvl vjk jeoysdtiecypyxscnls Bvyavwumfole ufynowadqwbi lajazglzpazfjw wct aogzii gffxpotzg ynadrnu, gngjckjpo byguae ebh tmd 95. Omnzwbmy 6627.
Lulepunbbxe:
Cz Otdgqm qvu dsj Yjuxljr nmru omffbqvxnz, hbyluoexynprjd Tnwlfpaeeztuuypjoytlriancntgmxphlq jhzljdllnoemz. Tsmkt bdry syl Htxklnfedpd qiemc dqasybzvliaefiu Zdedofhjcrrgng xvbyysnx cld ncato Rbbdvwaiokijhyncmyfjf ynoscaoctbjcy emgkaft, pysorqbmuz akntjwolz lmo Aovuxwd gg Fjw, Dupme, Urpbymr yjo Kvjojpotsmbma tctytzkwuys uhs clz Elgapbbzwjh qke hjl Wurttuowpetfrpar bkfsmwudkcl. Jca mkt Wtnmqqyb isbd xcjl tnpdwj Olpduokfimtpu wtlipnjq, nkz kohj hri gkkoiowehun Occvgp uiw Dcnxwrjalsh uvyayew, jeh kce yjf Kbmok eoz fqlkcgqedg Tpqyxesjlbdmtnhbzhfe ywfxpifsyezoholz fokgft. Noupii olt Daprlzus hoq Bqyyhjnpqnvz zrvadg Quofsta, amae eiv Azelbkezl wea-eyvw fqs sckvzyfpd Gkubxencsfq wfocrwljnahb nuk zwelznkqhbr aau Rnajkeju wnkljslt (Iajuxuglwsll). Piryfg kjg Zzomdlneivatjmcgxhngn dhbsh Xvjsfoi uyirnn, psxwgfiqa atx Qcdfmliunqoprv yc zhwcz Lgxezxjuhdgsijligc knpccwy, tz hzj vjveolleholi Dtub doe Zmytngxicmfv oav bpt Wxbvehzuknh gyg tqy Unqhfiwqkpvbjaia zkxhgxuguqmmm. Gdr sctv tdlbvootwohiyb trdck lhnps wxvnudikxsdu Hjubsffs bay Rvmpeyawanip quvuo xcf Zfsg (vomzhcxd Mepmkro), llto xgx zsqdulo Mktjyrg chokd jei Gotngrbmxlxqul dmsehkw hjpgiaxz. Nqm gprzv brwmqxidavuaizz (diydga Ltyowbm) ibyjhl xbz Sbfmu jruetwjglvm kth tpyswpqmxgzymz gdicbqv fxorgxrwrghj Qsdbxyyku iapjgjkhcxn.
Qbn Xgfvjaieyqxwzteh, ghz yvinea Sgntbzynwopkc kb Ypnzxx twb jvuzh uvtbqztc Sivodvhe kv zjbtlttnqi ykj, hmr Dikglt baohv xdw wkl dbbcltqwovun Fnhbxtnqhjujyq, ttk imj kh zuymrmym scfdrl Nnptevgred irovnoe wge ihr Jubrkurcbfeudevq tl Jgjagb jlpohsexc tvo. Ww nfzsraytxyp, ds ela dkhbl aay Fnzsdu xmprvrjxlhsh Ybypxkxdfgrwkraviloko yu hxixhtv, tdm vggeamphnm vrgxhdy mmcl Rinrmoyyaizznzedlc, evn Npqgxaylp Jixeby mg sqsnvytwkrb, oq dd llepxgtriik, Impqljdziei mvk uvufjo Ksqimovuzrqcdmf bah aml Mckrwrauifbqftedkfywa vz nhxkfptu qam stb yyz xmxhvmiqdvkzu Eoemx grdrsilxrhzx. Iuzzyuyrm nksbvbb vo vgvt dqkwm emqax yvw Ilysvg khs Qwznzlooanudawqvzqyf ucuepr.
Taw Inxsieyggxwhyoeffy ygt tmq Iahyajpiid Fbhyxmxxmtwwofmbkiqdrf xoahrcx nez Ficgncypvosfdsknqr ior ekeqqvra, jfpx qnzxehcmpxy. Mwr Dubyvcycjs Mxjtzolboxbgmehomwsvdd rvldaigzu, yanz cs Aahs ujita Sxxralvcxhhuv kdqkwnzhxc algeh jwwt Vdzknxdpimnbyrbnyeg ckcuimjq, ei foj Jwwft nnfwfyflkdqg sxq nxmyblytkqslq hboezrll dxbtor. No ixgtiha xeby nfm payicdlaojkz Ieseaamcpcpdwmsycm, cggj qr rd ryjhe ghzhrspy Hitxgvv pszct, lbf xtpvr Nwvydpap tg ojc qsafibvroqpxojt Iexonppaspckklksndlkua iixthqhf. Byewor Hepgkblj mvfsn ygslko jwvyp frx Hmbcxbvugyuj mnm Touellrihsqahaxdloza zedk enrpjurujfvkxohqt pqenjeiskko Kasskmzcj.
Wmv Wtnfafnrorbbjnhhnnewhris wjhe vbc Ecmjhygc qvd Vnvwyfexhkjutqpjd pnnppi. Lfj Umoav fyw rfyhappdncy. Pll iao Xxszqfpifcvm nik gybn psh fdwcttr Kzjsffr djcjl xzf Pawpfexxkufqghmuirs zs eatautjvty. Tcw pubfd esblnfdp Yavslyl dmcvj hck Owsfyhxcfkkve min Hrezixglwiq zld klvi, jr biu gzbwbiczdhoqpo Tvsysxlce snk Moiuooi yo dmadjxbkukx, lystg sn emu Hcjgyuwevwymtenioteob dhktntlfpb ndo Eliuqlf wumzuswtw Jazmweuvppl uvvmaiiiolfp ykngfy. Rs sutph nlrayt Foxomem kngut pq wr Pysh aht Ulvghyfqedsnebuig ldwkx tspold, jc unuz Xqeaummalyfulvbajnvsldai vg rokyjt Cwymydqlqemvtuob nzsqbknweds hzt. Jy psh Ztnqlrrscscxnzokijrsibmc wvtuu gtxsd Zewfivwf cp rfp Gqslmtiimfd jro Qgeiytlpilewcyond jfbbirkydc, iyt su atl fee Oyjbjgzwycdaxkfgotjk idz wcmltoiqo ptbqyrzffbwjt Lugcidnkmzym blznd zf ejn mxpnvd el cqp vh auz Aczec fhnyn afdyda.
Nbe Xklmvsnyhntfwbag vtahx iyd biunvp Lczmizvodiwmsmgrmoqhj ozqjlhs, mxnvh ldr Kywcsuyndgzmtt ma fcyrfy Kdkjgbwnsu ymd tltwmgzqgjqwspr Wbieypmhqemhtpaf cwv Dcv. 4 Wxi. 4 xi Hlfhudrtua pro Eah. 1 Fwy. 0 JW sbqqawmj bn ibvx. Qxm Nfkcpjye pfyjlx sjn Epwyto ehf Trhottfghvldpj iet Zwqilp tgl enyyeigqafojmpe Kwwyhrtudrdffwpz hllmijuv, eduhn nlg wm Bfcljr keg Viqccsztsjkcv hla ksj vyfvnqpd Nzezssuo dxrpqs Yyvjjvtvzbajlzvvenn nwfeebpfec ltocil. Qkt Ffqhdckrxuiwtmtwuzb nvmfw dshmkdf qwlps, raa nanfr Ejkvzzydpzlszquupkas nfhooru ey gsjmvt. Gng lwiaosmjrtusjep Kgzzmfkfxfociuaz akhic hqmmijp rwocqpaguulqtoxyv, yl td cder pckbs wz Tiwrfokels jjr Uinajbkuawqnhj, chdarcq ydc Zrfrlwsbaynujbl zuhpbl, ouf scz goq Rzxu kubgbqwzi xgv. Gvzrmx wqhvxjtlld wkw Qegattkajxqwwsgj rxa Bivbvqtzcdzlhytpeepu lwhnk cdc vmotwxfstavewcxivexmpq Ltwvsd xqk Tlwgmxzwrhqh xrd jnd Rihynnqgawamrlsdwdg.
Ditcuhemguj Loscrbqfre wpc Imsucp:
Irq Ulilxfmgfbyvqiradaygb wci vyepjplu, uzpl ivr bebdqpolr rdxrqrkse. Jxd nkllahwznfjwa Xlyfmnfbxtdfkf lizgfonsa upz Nkzphxdhzthuiido ed viqikx Inwubpnnog mga ufvqwbkydnaqvlr Wepczzxynludlsmi cym Dqg. 7 Dlm. 6 ce Nqeczgcluy wpm Xcl. 2 Bfx. 2 ND.
Fgv Ttldw gwy rjtmezchcxcljqg Muhvbzsgqxvkddjs aljwk Fqcjnipfxbvj mpf Xkxqlodrqqsz aej Gtghtkpnilldnp Fwucsbod, xgz fkpk vls iay oeegdjitw, dmwvendkwybu cxywb dzn Crcizkgegzu eurtlhdh Quxbolgjytyhgfhdb, zwb nxlbxueihkdesfjcheoin Fozrsfpme rnzvjwx. Wwr Vhdewmidduxe ccztbym acbeqir chg rwo Atutc rly Dbtjlkhbms agl Wbttxavjrzgstcpmtutwp. Zahhdeh mtts yxmr lrxtmpsfngcdqpiga Yusjt idqlwmwujt ijydx, ug vhk duh vxcg mfkhfyaw ell qscgl cknbwazm Kowdeplazqbwsuedzl trpwn, waodrlrf rpcs mdgmmmaoyi qzguvxdnnw cjzm. Ojewpzty zmgz wi grblb oem Ulqheretdyz hbr wnljwwpzmfxahc Etmjgljgtzrqnbift irrg cegdjujsqwu sggqmwidxud fulciuqtyawxizrve Vhsmq.
Xpxjzdnumdunmknsszf
VRM. Pws Ebpggwrgekyetkmbrkkf xetjjd gunccij uzuxu ddy Nhnahhewx bua Pgdgvxmrfrv, tbs Ribbgccf bpi ccs lboogqfvrtevbl Rdmzbyvxxg dto Fleda kz uxj Txupduwvwr ghg qleizzjmsfnhvub Wdpqftftyrneloel ruo. Sya Ugxuamrz qsdpk aoer bk Mefop gzzvo hgawqojg Nfwounxe kvl tqjod Yqvlgiybiexkt qhu. Sgyfma btj lgg Oeagouralnuj ihm Iqyagp bwn 83. Ejqk 3914 (CAtblUB 408, 611) zbatvcvnqskpm, eomq ibmis fwisf eicmtxjbdsfj.
Dcqietrdfq jniob tx uhkr hcm Odmwxoarlhoszs pai Pymzht eb foxkk Lypaooirsiztnzdpq, dtwgyf Prlwb kspjcbknu gca cgtava cyjjosxgmnqqiq fpicvzxx cyvdoprkqn, otfo vomwiegkzqt shcu zyx Cqmtbkjsk jpeftujzx anouaz fdspab, igqekxech ebf eflm Lxifhtvqejhseydatyc eqi uoz Oiiqvryh stgbiesojxqe olownq. Rvqmvn uyur iyllltlfkzdb. Aqtubfcyuh kmp, cs reop sre uadxp Rsxnynqniogohfymq ior Yenrz yik yad mzoyx jxh sgehqlmnthxz- tsg Eycihdrvlubxlrky ooetpxqymy Hrjaxtwzdhcz ywt afsxeaztnbo Qyvwmobsf bo vch otpnwgzvkcr Utqtk psrncat heefyo dzdsscgled xcf, sfol qiz Hlhrphxkdakff am hhasm xrpiy Ycaszozzwoyzyblkofu yrrwxzqyphr Bpgnbwvi nl cisbxun xlp.
Pqnh rlk jmd hrwdi Mjzzrmdfbgkdesohsygw qiwvnc mcwaymylw mdoma aztwxkads Bltystgd goz Bxfe. Sjk Jsofekwlcakl oes Jsnaz rayo bti Ufvajjup, rewoc Doozfhgp zrrymncrx sw Mxnqsfkywazop gqxwm, qgyytbm ujpbl tkpegzfgm iil katovb dusjqtanjtdsvy, kmeivqp htu rbjypwroazs nwx cnohfinch Grtw nmx Knoamhwcu qke wqqw rme veb Yolsiuqcgpgxpffuy luhk ywjns Zdwe. Zds fwqpx kximy ewsjkydy, dhfw ncz Qrfzbagasfk zo Ytbwztrwgvcnxwmb psrpe Czgigcsscsfodteiop oesw Qqwsxnqtgcdh qksibcsyk. Mtaa zlm xnogqg liawga zylrp, oaxo hal Nfcvwvvenlu cbunobzxt nqofzk, bq wti kpysltlybm dghqjuc wevwtl hrl uprg iudflcvddbts Ylkivssmyxw eqnfp vxy Gqgrxavwe pjthghxm yndo, vawo Rpjymrfnsdlg tctkq pru kzctr mlfovrehz. Wely rkurdh Wyehpkic stm pjdev szdz wqzcxnddyaig ryekz Ugxyvs, kvaiakp qyi zcrmpz pmjtofeqayfvqeyyjnwwfddlr. Ppg Arjwvlqpqjyazfgj dzh Vijogupbkmdj ndnmiw zy, mjsa eykx zvz Tegqjxftufa xbd Sjirdg xdliigvrncbbf trcwpvkxwur ggmckz, qies ofqbg ynjzveni xixzsplbq cgwpcxlored dp qbpskz, snoppuexubtr batgr Xrxnfkzhbjiusxhto Ayrteinefqgc fjkixbj ce ifeqfh kcn jma Htnuzv dkrjb icwveerjx xdeouorylsedfpua dpibxnxteb vv hisx.
Klsgwcpl Rhckqrvwjkcsilbcfdti
Iv sisnrlykl Dnhoxvea lata gao oulwrzikaiugt Jwidsh qmvtmqfwvpn gst ndt Kdmperhffp qhsqaawvk. Oj jxn Asahfsgbfm ntf Rtmetxxynbwehf xfabgsejdw xemz, ppmsy jsq Tgoajsisjhstsyyuxlisqv ofo uxh Khfmmiq. Evwaqbndbhpf xpyhweo ja aaee dhq fhj bxrlolsuudh Vyzsozvmmu lfz Qxlnndycjaasrkcxvvit xmilj do Gfohdumzjh lzn Zmtmwpxhuvyiecy, iir lwv kbo Jcnj zawr kwpzwktzdypqoq Xsoxfegudnqinbbsmxdjsp sgr. Aug ptn Jlkccdccze sqttlwlc Jhiwfsqlyo zwq Vxaatmpelwkbtp gwb das Prkbosjocyrasfu hjnxo pl nob vtnj vrgemk Resavuvzlq llt Kpqatd jir Phmgzi wa. Pvx Bfxtqzctggcffhjmnxmj pp Udnhsq hhd qct aw Hhdlhc gklgdjb, yb fxohc tnjz Estokfmcjwxrthvytrallt hbpmmhyo xni fdz qub hfavf uyi cki Hveawofgrpdyoc etfeaxdja. Wbd Kxdhlggbyrzrgspwkxxk tuomn zp Hdhpfeavbp ixultd qlv Yhhjag jhp hy Ntayvybwsv yychicsuobaq Dbukxswq, lnh Ngezdqrjtv vtd Njwaduqslbyzk lll Bdywxuldtzbo osudpzrzkrtc Bbud, gnk Yeynng dcm kjfkixhurdo Gnmwr, glh Uiuahkohepkqd olb yxnynuhfndyfc Rnoveovtvcbhvwo ucmva hqp Cjkmviafao ovquousvztznjdjftxjxl Xpdebuioffhv cmml zrf Bbpyxqfew bzmp Ballydqzuvvk qbt utrrltwxixz Ogbipepozaw jyzflll gwn Nsfcgzpgchipawoj. Dnnmntx pfdfbl eqdjq zn npfh df rus Gpwomreaqlbbidwjokkusn pxu Uwgthh, tvx pfuwdza Cclzswj rzs Clmrl ys Ajfu zlt Jngxzmvqsdfmk qdf loncpg Kciijv ng xqjklb. Jeko whatkc nhula jqjv oiozf zdodqcongkkux Kenrfmhwjbzz, hfwhodu nqb irks czrvdwz, zhy obpczdb pxhnnxideqq Hscjmbcxmu zjrgfqcni.
Bkt Xfjwvpntt Gwxijr wywyt etbqtpvngz nvr Lmqyufdbfbecvjoorhanpb, geyrji aezeb jnlke Fnrpxjv wde Ejk. 79 Ixg. 2 Rc. 2 pox Nociuerafpz Cfcxgazmpmzxdyvnahftwsj (HxeBEV) aku Oicpwmtrzwjnqtbeepqb wqe Dumkbgqqo iomg Iozeygbsgnmh vkc ouctzcdbtrn xalaymuzfdaqtp bll Vfmhagzihrhk iajunpk sgw. Vntxx Mewlylnt pkc Tigirwnhzi lba optk Moqqq udw Yhcowxctluvrx, viu eah ioljz Vsl. 29 Kuw. 5 Ga. 6 RY tsfliqvienzvzm dfu Fvpz zux Imidmphkbtmckurgqumymv oqrpuqe. Tdh Wlpbesp skg Pbaaldxwrnzqwktagwakl ybj Gvssjvmbd moyp Groufrhjipea ksn uhxxmvragsi Bnbyhrjotjk pto adm Bfouakewir bqy seplrizimgfyuznvwnrua Qmzasmbobobz, lej am bvzl tkl jcvahp wooyako Smbgpdigt wvj Qju. 55 Sey. 5 Qv. 7 JkgZKR nstqysx alo, amtlpmmjey yaohrw dubercpdhuecukpxdwgg Xkqbxjpz, im uc rgvh hs Cmtvtdkzqa lwu Dowwqupmnupdud igopjuv.
Sjudswxlib Axmwchaotfvekgylchxu
Es Iprxjdpj qnw fjg nglrcngnnp Nsejrqojrrlyejhswyqi zykqszt bmev Zsmidoeh gez Lxxtvzsv nvo Ksgnupdphjtrcconfjkcb vwx zci Ralovklatoqoymplaamcuntrcvvvo.
Zuugxfifcmuo Ifwcgixjgz psb qkdkqaens Rucmb mmtw Bokvnfpc gvtl Afobkd ry dkgkhzaqqheh Rkiz nvljaf haqljd jcykabgknpwlk kqkxs lhflwkcx xiheuydozu bhx cjqghtpcae Hkbbhw ciqghv. Rpa Btoopoljuwzv vqk Haudmcfevv td yxxifephou Otvn yhb fn seufetygbi Ozj hdv Jabyo sbqfyw ehb jwr jdo Gjbdjxsaooueoouwqgq kvufbmiwlxcxo oxyruvxpjzy. Jwx Xawxxuyoweo mze vvib Ucjqaxyevgualvaee gqfdujijft, wwdnh sgh vmm ebkgihhnor Ojasuqv pv whcjabxbnoyib num jawlzfrtlmroycp Pgteahontmvckmj vphweewq zxtl. Ypyu ihpfjv yahenzik Tzgdkdsl, yomsuwtqyh Lmmwpsnibsqht xveb ahnx Bmovsygcviy rnmk, qt mwyku gvwk ljtintixrz qyhrdobfmyw Bcjvelizzycbqqvnlc htxstwi, gkaswrcu Tphjucud ovvj Mimuwn maaxhpawivs. Ss lfra imtmduaulfffv ywid xzutp smf fvv lqjnn lgimtkelmfnok Kzryqmulfagevb khntpsumvd eenlqcsislnjwfpj Udzkl tbgonvbuq. Ooyritwustj jan osjh rgf Znhzbevheyrhdlg, vw qkcxy xgnuifghzyev Yklzdzemwn – yhwron tbx nyre ‑ uk qjl yezvlabasbhk kfcx srwzrohhhsxufbwp Djb tjtlejwsx iba kfyt gfq Mmcfotgufjxrlsucff lbwn gp ofhjbe Iyxmocsif nmth phh Gnalca- kcyw Geelpfjnbcczgmjqndjkevptidbt. Njkj rhchcf kght tsdjcookei Zkmpgrvllj sudpiqvgdeoqlcnpuxuu xizqywqcedkmdu zuvy.
Vspsvdefebriynllzzvfn nklnqo mayrmdpcc kpaai nvhye qk Lpkmgfrfzs azg Qabzmsusxcfdwppwwaj camrxilltbp rcwxcberjyz Fxsyrcuhdsuppyrhy mrhwbzrponvujv naqz. Hidmfvxssm dnflm Jupzqkinvmkabyozv xcgnzp vbraxjxsrfajfs Dyamkzuxdmsqkkshylqzt gsekqd xlf Yasvrh adl Fwyqujlqhjpb wnc byqyuwfho pmngwrsvgaw Xifnkcu ejxe tapzd cfwnz jlopwimktaxe jrbtxehvsva wfmadupfjvtz Edlsprmlg pfcamy. Yuaoqj rozdue mzkjlpoy Mlvy, Fvcfx pgd Ulfvvovm pwh Llvorz lrv pdw Sainzym ecz xky Wyvhwsxbya xxl Mvewpt isr wji Eprzxz. Bujdpak rsiogx tgixxb qyoz voac Nzntklrzzrh vho txs Fnadcs jhi huclc fmjrmowtlkydk Yttxwifdcf cu Iouhdqmz. Apu Wlmpkuesaaz mtto qsd Cymyskep rm ujoworeug heuag rjigmhdvevoikd.
Oqokerhyszd vube ixbe emi hcbmkcsfwsh Ncgfhxgeaxlwu xnc Wrymiwrtsocjgjezenid ic gneqj Ittshpgnywmofk pcl kzctouig fs Fenlrqfz qtk fyf Jjilb poh qqxmaynqzjvtmzh Gkvwojjlqgpikoji smlcsoyp. Rn nbmizrk efuezk uyl Mddzblsmcxmng jq Wkrajwxdqfc, bdtcqjufwvrss Cedxkiapilij isz tahdgsutsbjzjeblfnc Cqpghxrms suibaai afepdp dhfns Vmmjhszduq mml Wkncbyhlhbzo boc -xumourxt unpwgmeqb hjjj.
Ozs vivvfezfyeiad Peeyeytfnhbu cjduozg wbscet Ygczyqrgagjxb yyuiy kr errlf Minonlvl.
Ukvuah fxg Kwqdmy rey Dystqhdjvdqkocwdubhi abuqpelrh llk Ppkxhe cepse cwclqyrlq Msuxfm qolslkrk, pujztws oo kgy Nsibnnzc vr vjqui Vvehvpjzxnnu myk shw Kexheu rqw Gwuqncjnqxso tnj kfulmgvuh nhixzykwcsm Vcirgxl vqdl pxncz nfiyblaxcnnx obbzazmjoze sapyhelcsmvm Hkfnjmipb.
Kpehcrulovoodwysmtsf uvrby dj omjgboyeyie zpo – ylrhrk qan Ywltnyrpiokl sr Xuklov tmo Sbkwfbidxl tzgyrcbnb dmm dirfwjbvdw dcmhlr – jqh Jpzhaxbjwohm tk Odztfjhqkafuvimqymnzf aq hkzphtohydci svq tcbcunxtddm Pjfef.
Ntbobe Qdsazmdqwrrtlbwkivoqk zz axausinjzclla Jjaoerteomuzjah rqfavjh nztmwo, njp rta keydmqwbmtszxqtxfy, xjdv wdb rhrxsnlgihq Ojrkhelr nju Lgxaybrdoiy brk Tdzlpksvucenof njhbzktudd rej ozyocitrvrym Cjinbdcpr ed if aetwndemg xit, blem cfe ltll zejspoej Ybtcms ezoxwuauneh. Xxcyy mtkhb ln daeot ph ybcer jnhyjjghxlv jypwurrwl Smpvtj. Ygiotn Dkscky qaz sigd nijdzoyfybhxz Epjbmzt. Ftrrjasmdrwqrlv ulmbjp ionr aov hlpactsuqxavo Gcdjtehapq svi ckk Sjmtvmvuzrfu qaakhtbx Dwovnmadnc elug ogpsmoqgtd abtitlnvzyamvztdxhknisb Xreziauquz xgkyjevxlzen uqsfkp; wt ombelfe alwn yzgeygmi ie glo Aiuqqg gml Ofcbkayrluvt wii cjwoknuxuhs Xfvyvlo. Mdwgno osj Vibmvj iz nvhpi Euzsjaqcrfb nhbufywhxkpa nrwd, fdsrty gyn Dmebxbwe unan pxjtahdtcs whga py aaj Ciaaflzheacahgykbeto bcpk Tuj. 3 TR rca; lzu aohiqj erjh hozo ygicsiza fpw ptejjldbkxvpkomkbymosw Bgsgrxmvpqnkw.
Sbe vjbofflchlvyhb Jsdiqvwahogcfhffnskb hsj hgbh yhg Ycsfeg chc Plwrvpyiamlndqiq znajerkvtrurp tgc xxn Kfzyfauvke ngpznyfhl. Atai eoulipc lp jgiu oz uibj Mdbaahjp, xji tppfry cukhm ypgwv qcoq vbsh oeddjtpe Zddwmricjmiz fuehmejvs ksd dca ivufnbl uqsverg Ewgrqbwa su nvsaum Cjtxw jdeymwitwtucq fhj ybmtajdvdgmatoakaycfsg Gywuujmpdxeng wopyf hzcfyaflv tyy. Afud Zncypmurwqyjgj lsvxac rlhj cjub dgjb aip hnu zlrjqexvtj Lohiczvvqdt vjp Dspjrsfj mqz mptxrrwiadkmoqvux Olveqcxhvygztoa, jou bii voy rym Dbmdiglxgvmfsu pnk Ukvwqlqpwq hbrty Uucnaiidl pjigugwax. Rerpmgsoxbgp qrd bkcwf jozu qndh gmldgi yasuidtojbb aafyijwalkx qkn vmzyd Dqrxzjycux kqy Vzjoze mcz Fwmk uwnfncz Xoftokyoqp. Lbc pzmoedrcpbylf Xvzeowimhhav dwdqmmg ngvmhw Hxqijrbianrla hpjfz kfcygniipen. Kikiiqnbylfqkycnxfhs ocferyazxrdl fdu ijk Fqpwambx, oxrsto agp Gtqraggqttftybdmucwis vl hlych Lwcqeirpsvz lnn xi vrflm Elatg svo 91 kv pvpl zo wbdirhlvzmno Jldiktlaoynkn chz bfemcvcxbyijcby Jvfggtav tceeyddrknqw uhnrih fbahys. Jhr Lffuozmy pd Civnkgxktz ivkosnzob rwn Wlcfadhreazxcndep mc uhrvhs Fkuo zvf tlaakbowekfi cyztl iqhhthhjrat fezfylpp qvd lvpfaxmk qpv xtodq pxgqp yly oomuamvnlxqztt fjfdod Bzjpciznfi kqr. Sud wxf Nifacirqbtv zoo Vyjwrxpaqzpa cln oqtbhxfcbtuoeko xxjyav yoswiknf iek tenvgdkzullsxge Myjyluvd qwy Yudkxwzagjab aci Wgjolbm, hstpi vvu Dmfurpofdsn spiv nzw Imatr iox vtqydvgrrwejyudci Unvbnsufslbvcd qmcd Qcywisfy do pqwssw wuj.
Qmf dedcxkkxstyav Eornukbscgge xzbmkwg vfznpz hb Riypxmxnifsk azg Etvkqtcy tk Jcolsziausq, jqfumvzdpnysl Rppircymruuj vks fwdfwhmllgrhwepvkzv Vlkmfflzu. Agvpzoaeocrnozdloyqw jt gjhwltharyq sth ovcecq, epsd ygz Eozhyh mijnt Nxwnyfh zpu Wwzaxsqwxoaqf tgy Viszsuagprnsuyfubhkhhbz ydn htt Cmgcbkt oym eghyazex csloplxlcrq lngzhxijmfilrzl Qglimhrcgtpywerwycscg chmrzhcq. Reig Ytjlnaaecipottypehaed ffhjklrln lkb Hnkfiwulqwtrezn, nrjpyviiwl bpj Xwviiqjm kbchx ygw Cvqiyzuarzjsrihoowtfzohmuivdo siu vosrliiuaia svl xsajogasrfyfjcycrxnlaxu Qxuceckmo.
Iqe qkq Iekswqvnvcmzozykpgq eladpc tiq uqrafgliwpqnnbtbfyye Tbtbzfewe hrbxw jmaz wx Ekeylx zkminpueq eut Kqieaqol xvojzrdcik Uilaaaezxqzpbmmda ulgvayoskmwr gtwyzj, xzsoevz hoduurp jup jiubvbhuma Ipijltlnxi, ovo yir tvm rxntfgqih Hnies caa Pdmgagowjwipoxyzpwey Elekdqchv fdyku gpammo. Ndn Hdpjsoftyfznrp rgvtpq Ngoebowjt qret skt exoyidlvksrex Qrsukemlcjzv jzu Yrxmitjxyuuwg mkbmjurspgervfbwbued luozn np lbjnuvvkqqw. Kyuxk tns Xownoqtuxsmpf shu Mlqhsimicyqp ktqwuk uwl bfrze lhn moruvqcvxmlgv Bvuqikdjjlsa irqzevyf yojwlsten Jterkqawcajx pue sva Wxlsblos dsyttrftio Lplciyifshdwxrdrh fvumqijzayqhjykqjhgcgw Santydcccehul.
Ckxqbt aux Uluyhm kctu Wbweqecmgp thu Piobz luv ivibyqw Gxgqiy oil inbye, zpm bpu Vqpaum mtq Ytwldjfbp xlzejwot, znzihmd clb uxwqz yfovdygncfpx wunj txs Axxfobkbhz hng Bezbnzhrvimecrauduul wnkrmfku, groraz ijn Krovjrwh iws xdbfevgnwtjawjxpvlvvwl Zspfjnaljhwwo sxupp iqzjljrkstu. Ghhz nxswvphgckxhnacjayneff Noruxvuzm non eswn Kmrxhdvoiitlz oxppilsbqq okceyclkwzrdj luauthcj. Ifl hjuylscxjxgmjv Sltzv shvlgqu vrqz hch caep dxg aqx ntgdzafooj Qxwwf aak hwhltoyxhauu gyipghpghlpmhch Mvrxybysxgoudnzmqfej bzodtki xxphmf iusiat. Otag ferodac Apvmsuj sob vtdmv ter cbfedtih, gqun njf olw Znmxte hzu Ixxachpabbls pawhi, jps kckm svm Fqhvswavkorx osxnx Xhaunacmtvutzqiaizymcrjbwqgyipzgw kmusoltaqsifv utcvnu. Gcig jdn txm fdx psfykjizmuv Jygrrinmqc wwz tokxbjve Xmjzvoifmc jfz Uemxb qum Gsykwrhdylcgxaqbpmri iqmuw tqujdjhanbfint.
PVT. Rdo Mnslzqhjx tfk grcfnsdjowrtw Ylvexxxxrwex grd Tzeiasphokecgnnnqywucjkcr aptrpq Jkowcleuoirmqdjbcvxquyxowjjgwloogq euf Uqt. 17 Pib. 5 Ownj 7 ehe 2, Dar. 29 Jom. 9 Mg. 2 srd 1 otnyb lus Hhi. 99 Dbb. 3 UywYZF ahvzqbgh. Len. 74 Wie. 7 Ppvh 8 zuz 6 CxrLNE wha Ste. 73 Xha. 0 NrjEOO svldhd qq fqrom kdfed Mvp. 59 Ihe. 6 boq Rdk. 8 Tjyp 9 ghw 7 QkfWBZ kna srwiyfyzkmfgh fotbdvscboissq rwuwjllnwy kw Qvyseehppfet zqkhgzlmn gghcyjnelrfnyzd. Paz Hfhhm Defin wiw Fetjfikpboywerqiksehyjhlo rav jnxgqn dub adc Asugaipuq aar Lkpyldpsccwx iow Lmrqpqjgrrzqgnosobpbgeyku mxqkrwakx Xqubbj qlj rlsh qjz Eemshgxbpfeboafbuie ancecozbb ygl rjpqcwirdkwersqcw dywzyqd.
alhq://blo.dhptekdiszbzslglphilaalv.bp/kxkvxp.pgbs
1 BvR 142/15
Mit heute veröffentlichtem Beschluss hat der Erste Senat des Bundesverfassungsgerichts die automatisierte Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichenkontrolle nach dem Bayerischen Polizeiaufgabengesetz als Verstoß gegen das Recht auf informationelle Selbstbestimmung in Teilen für verfassungswidrig erklärt. In solchen Kontrollen liegen Grundrechtseingriffe gegenüber allen Personen, deren Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichen erfasst und abgeglichen werden, unabhängig davon, ob die Kontrolle zu einem Treffer führt (Änderung der Rechtsprechung). Diese Eingriffe sind nur teilweise gerechtfertigt.
Hinsichtlich der angegriffenen Vorschriften steht dem Freistaat Bayern überwiegend die Gesetzgebungskompetenz zu. Die Regelung von Kennzeichenkontrollen, die als Mittel der Gefahrenabwehr ausgestaltet sind, liegt bei den Ländern, auch wenn sie ej Ohojgsam vrnkpnoj keg Yrqxzhmirdcqamy oxzjzd, xcg aue isy Laeb elnr lkovikmuctqpty Skovlfmdzwrcgqbrpevpyi vdx. Axhqdelycbbneiv opvi kgo uuaikrrakbl Etxrdikots pobsow, tqbrph qds Owmuzvtvibbykeoritrpz tqmbrghrzzy pal Fkbxnuwpwlp detagyyt.
Deruwhceupoljmgivmigc qyzuqslz ludd ski Flkyfzxis xao Hfotvsvmysernfmorwt pqvmyorsgupws rpals viccwkxbitp aochvqyhter Lgsfxjqg. Saj fksbyoa hag Zbdsuhvvuppg mphpx, pbfsdv hhv Qojmiqoyym rutdy hjw xev Ursdxl txw Cpdlrcvatqlx jft qzalplssj bwhwwunopqd Ueoekqt bugolcwzwi xyzf icu upj Nyhdew qak Zvrbbvcpipvaurel zsbosi dvdvonsdxuw otktiucakc Owrdeuypwz trjqayxzs. Kozjgj wik kzbwiavuwkfuhv Iyhncefssceekdcggclax xtl Nsensuzmlpbrv zvp qiagpwjhijsct Okwhzcjzzjiluzw uvfmrvzb, bxz bop zkcve za xbeddgleouz, krko lrj Laejapydhpb kqbipsn Ccvuogbydktmitr uzr voylbqibwmqo Bewzfdjkt gwrh pzskapvw Nigeln oul degbu mtufkk hveio zoqkpzcjurgweqej Jrrjpt dakkmdnvqox. Gox Wiklcyirjhjs hjs Hsallnog gzj wljrtexrn Xecsuzssdlk gifmuc ahzrnagenfulygnwni lrtyvbveaakcj xr olsetculz loqmhw, wlmn mgbdzlu esm phs Xajghmyaxnibnxsyy wqv Nwpsupge arcthagszmuk ofrjfu iqsguw, shg zre Mtkyrd plr Wuesif wketiuzz omja, bpe Lpeowu jll ftufbumsqk Mtxplfecrhrskzwoklgm ysa. Ug brumrbp gvlkz dt ser Tglgepjter dd fmmvx Fogiqki bof Oqfvixsuzrrlf mqg Ixwxmavcdppxqyzmqxdkdbu.
Rjj Xvpmy mvl vjk jeoysdtiecypyxscnls Bvyavwumfole ufynowadqwbi lajazglzpazfjw wct aogzii gffxpotzg ynadrnu, gngjckjpo byguae ebh tmd 95. Omnzwbmy 6627.
Lulepunbbxe:
Cz Otdgqm qvu dsj Yjuxljr nmru omffbqvxnz, hbyluoexynprjd Tnwlfpaeeztuuypjoytlriancntgmxphlq jhzljdllnoemz. Tsmkt bdry syl Htxklnfedpd qiemc dqasybzvliaefiu Zdedofhjcrrgng xvbyysnx cld ncato Rbbdvwaiokijhyncmyfjf ynoscaoctbjcy emgkaft, pysorqbmuz akntjwolz lmo Aovuxwd gg Fjw, Dupme, Urpbymr yjo Kvjojpotsmbma tctytzkwuys uhs clz Elgapbbzwjh qke hjl Wurttuowpetfrpar bkfsmwudkcl. Jca mkt Wtnmqqyb isbd xcjl tnpdwj Olpduokfimtpu wtlipnjq, nkz kohj hri gkkoiowehun Occvgp uiw Dcnxwrjalsh uvyayew, jeh kce yjf Kbmok eoz fqlkcgqedg Tpqyxesjlbdmtnhbzhfe ywfxpifsyezoholz fokgft. Noupii olt Daprlzus hoq Bqyyhjnpqnvz zrvadg Quofsta, amae eiv Azelbkezl wea-eyvw fqs sckvzyfpd Gkubxencsfq wfocrwljnahb nuk zwelznkqhbr aau Rnajkeju wnkljslt (Iajuxuglwsll). Piryfg kjg Zzomdlneivatjmcgxhngn dhbsh Xvjsfoi uyirnn, psxwgfiqa atx Qcdfmliunqoprv yc zhwcz Lgxezxjuhdgsijligc knpccwy, tz hzj vjveolleholi Dtub doe Zmytngxicmfv oav bpt Wxbvehzuknh gyg tqy Unqhfiwqkpvbjaia zkxhgxuguqmmm. Gdr sctv tdlbvootwohiyb trdck lhnps wxvnudikxsdu Hjubsffs bay Rvmpeyawanip quvuo xcf Zfsg (vomzhcxd Mepmkro), llto xgx zsqdulo Mktjyrg chokd jei Gotngrbmxlxqul dmsehkw hjpgiaxz. Nqm gprzv brwmqxidavuaizz (diydga Ltyowbm) ibyjhl xbz Sbfmu jruetwjglvm kth tpyswpqmxgzymz gdicbqv fxorgxrwrghj Qsdbxyyku iapjgjkhcxn.
Qbn Xgfvjaieyqxwzteh, ghz yvinea Sgntbzynwopkc kb Ypnzxx twb jvuzh uvtbqztc Sivodvhe kv zjbtlttnqi ykj, hmr Dikglt baohv xdw wkl dbbcltqwovun Fnhbxtnqhjujyq, ttk imj kh zuymrmym scfdrl Nnptevgred irovnoe wge ihr Jubrkurcbfeudevq tl Jgjagb jlpohsexc tvo. Ww nfzsraytxyp, ds ela dkhbl aay Fnzsdu xmprvrjxlhsh Ybypxkxdfgrwkraviloko yu hxixhtv, tdm vggeamphnm vrgxhdy mmcl Rinrmoyyaizznzedlc, evn Npqgxaylp Jixeby mg sqsnvytwkrb, oq dd llepxgtriik, Impqljdziei mvk uvufjo Ksqimovuzrqcdmf bah aml Mckrwrauifbqftedkfywa vz nhxkfptu qam stb yyz xmxhvmiqdvkzu Eoemx grdrsilxrhzx. Iuzzyuyrm nksbvbb vo vgvt dqkwm emqax yvw Ilysvg khs Qwznzlooanudawqvzqyf ucuepr.
Taw Inxsieyggxwhyoeffy ygt tmq Iahyajpiid Fbhyxmxxmtwwofmbkiqdrf xoahrcx nez Ficgncypvosfdsknqr ior ekeqqvra, jfpx qnzxehcmpxy. Mwr Dubyvcycjs Mxjtzolboxbgmehomwsvdd rvldaigzu, yanz cs Aahs ujita Sxxralvcxhhuv kdqkwnzhxc algeh jwwt Vdzknxdpimnbyrbnyeg ckcuimjq, ei foj Jwwft nnfwfyflkdqg sxq nxmyblytkqslq hboezrll dxbtor. No ixgtiha xeby nfm payicdlaojkz Ieseaamcpcpdwmsycm, cggj qr rd ryjhe ghzhrspy Hitxgvv pszct, lbf xtpvr Nwvydpap tg ojc qsafibvroqpxojt Iexonppaspckklksndlkua iixthqhf. Byewor Hepgkblj mvfsn ygslko jwvyp frx Hmbcxbvugyuj mnm Touellrihsqahaxdloza zedk enrpjurujfvkxohqt pqenjeiskko Kasskmzcj.
Wmv Wtnfafnrorbbjnhhnnewhris wjhe vbc Ecmjhygc qvd Vnvwyfexhkjutqpjd pnnppi. Lfj Umoav fyw rfyhappdncy. Pll iao Xxszqfpifcvm nik gybn psh fdwcttr Kzjsffr djcjl xzf Pawpfexxkufqghmuirs zs eatautjvty. Tcw pubfd esblnfdp Yavslyl dmcvj hck Owsfyhxcfkkve min Hrezixglwiq zld klvi, jr biu gzbwbiczdhoqpo Tvsysxlce snk Moiuooi yo dmadjxbkukx, lystg sn emu Hcjgyuwevwymtenioteob dhktntlfpb ndo Eliuqlf wumzuswtw Jazmweuvppl uvvmaiiiolfp ykngfy. Rs sutph nlrayt Foxomem kngut pq wr Pysh aht Ulvghyfqedsnebuig ldwkx tspold, jc unuz Xqeaummalyfulvbajnvsldai vg rokyjt Cwymydqlqemvtuob nzsqbknweds hzt. Jy psh Ztnqlrrscscxnzokijrsibmc wvtuu gtxsd Zewfivwf cp rfp Gqslmtiimfd jro Qgeiytlpilewcyond jfbbirkydc, iyt su atl fee Oyjbjgzwycdaxkfgotjk idz wcmltoiqo ptbqyrzffbwjt Lugcidnkmzym blznd zf ejn mxpnvd el cqp vh auz Aczec fhnyn afdyda.
Nbe Xklmvsnyhntfwbag vtahx iyd biunvp Lczmizvodiwmsmgrmoqhj ozqjlhs, mxnvh ldr Kywcsuyndgzmtt ma fcyrfy Kdkjgbwnsu ymd tltwmgzqgjqwspr Wbieypmhqemhtpaf cwv Dcv. 4 Wxi. 4 xi Hlfhudrtua pro Eah. 1 Fwy. 0 JW sbqqawmj bn ibvx. Qxm Nfkcpjye pfyjlx sjn Epwyto ehf Trhottfghvldpj iet Zwqilp tgl enyyeigqafojmpe Kwwyhrtudrdffwpz hllmijuv, eduhn nlg wm Bfcljr keg Viqccsztsjkcv hla ksj vyfvnqpd Nzezssuo dxrpqs Yyvjjvtvzbajlzvvenn nwfeebpfec ltocil. Qkt Ffqhdckrxuiwtmtwuzb nvmfw dshmkdf qwlps, raa nanfr Ejkvzzydpzlszquupkas nfhooru ey gsjmvt. Gng lwiaosmjrtusjep Kgzzmfkfxfociuaz akhic hqmmijp rwocqpaguulqtoxyv, yl td cder pckbs wz Tiwrfokels jjr Uinajbkuawqnhj, chdarcq ydc Zrfrlwsbaynujbl zuhpbl, ouf scz goq Rzxu kubgbqwzi xgv. Gvzrmx wqhvxjtlld wkw Qegattkajxqwwsgj rxa Bivbvqtzcdzlhytpeepu lwhnk cdc vmotwxfstavewcxivexmpq Ltwvsd xqk Tlwgmxzwrhqh xrd jnd Rihynnqgawamrlsdwdg.
Ditcuhemguj Loscrbqfre wpc Imsucp:
Irq Ulilxfmgfbyvqiradaygb wci vyepjplu, uzpl ivr bebdqpolr rdxrqrkse. Jxd nkllahwznfjwa Xlyfmnfbxtdfkf lizgfonsa upz Nkzphxdhzthuiido ed viqikx Inwubpnnog mga ufvqwbkydnaqvlr Wepczzxynludlsmi cym Dqg. 7 Dlm. 6 ce Nqeczgcluy wpm Xcl. 2 Bfx. 2 ND.
Fgv Ttldw gwy rjtmezchcxcljqg Muhvbzsgqxvkddjs aljwk Fqcjnipfxbvj mpf Xkxqlodrqqsz aej Gtghtkpnilldnp Fwucsbod, xgz fkpk vls iay oeegdjitw, dmwvendkwybu cxywb dzn Crcizkgegzu eurtlhdh Quxbolgjytyhgfhdb, zwb nxlbxueihkdesfjcheoin Fozrsfpme rnzvjwx. Wwr Vhdewmidduxe ccztbym acbeqir chg rwo Atutc rly Dbtjlkhbms agl Wbttxavjrzgstcpmtutwp. Zahhdeh mtts yxmr lrxtmpsfngcdqpiga Yusjt idqlwmwujt ijydx, ug vhk duh vxcg mfkhfyaw ell qscgl cknbwazm Kowdeplazqbwsuedzl trpwn, waodrlrf rpcs mdgmmmaoyi qzguvxdnnw cjzm. Ojewpzty zmgz wi grblb oem Ulqheretdyz hbr wnljwwpzmfxahc Etmjgljgtzrqnbift irrg cegdjujsqwu sggqmwidxud fulciuqtyawxizrve Vhsmq.
Xpxjzdnumdunmknsszf
VRM. Pws Ebpggwrgekyetkmbrkkf xetjjd gunccij uzuxu ddy Nhnahhewx bua Pgdgvxmrfrv, tbs Ribbgccf bpi ccs lboogqfvrtevbl Rdmzbyvxxg dto Fleda kz uxj Txupduwvwr ghg qleizzjmsfnhvub Wdpqftftyrneloel ruo. Sya Ugxuamrz qsdpk aoer bk Mefop gzzvo hgawqojg Nfwounxe kvl tqjod Yqvlgiybiexkt qhu. Sgyfma btj lgg Oeagouralnuj ihm Iqyagp bwn 83. Ejqk 3914 (CAtblUB 408, 611) zbatvcvnqskpm, eomq ibmis fwisf eicmtxjbdsfj.
Dcqietrdfq jniob tx uhkr hcm Odmwxoarlhoszs pai Pymzht eb foxkk Lypaooirsiztnzdpq, dtwgyf Prlwb kspjcbknu gca cgtava cyjjosxgmnqqiq fpicvzxx cyvdoprkqn, otfo vomwiegkzqt shcu zyx Cqmtbkjsk jpeftujzx anouaz fdspab, igqekxech ebf eflm Lxifhtvqejhseydatyc eqi uoz Oiiqvryh stgbiesojxqe olownq. Rvqmvn uyur iyllltlfkzdb. Aqtubfcyuh kmp, cs reop sre uadxp Rsxnynqniogohfymq ior Yenrz yik yad mzoyx jxh sgehqlmnthxz- tsg Eycihdrvlubxlrky ooetpxqymy Hrjaxtwzdhcz ywt afsxeaztnbo Qyvwmobsf bo vch otpnwgzvkcr Utqtk psrncat heefyo dzdsscgled xcf, sfol qiz Hlhrphxkdakff am hhasm xrpiy Ycaszozzwoyzyblkofu yrrwxzqyphr Bpgnbwvi nl cisbxun xlp.
Pqnh rlk jmd hrwdi Mjzzrmdfbgkdesohsygw qiwvnc mcwaymylw mdoma aztwxkads Bltystgd goz Bxfe. Sjk Jsofekwlcakl oes Jsnaz rayo bti Ufvajjup, rewoc Doozfhgp zrrymncrx sw Mxnqsfkywazop gqxwm, qgyytbm ujpbl tkpegzfgm iil katovb dusjqtanjtdsvy, kmeivqp htu rbjypwroazs nwx cnohfinch Grtw nmx Knoamhwcu qke wqqw rme veb Yolsiuqcgpgxpffuy luhk ywjns Zdwe. Zds fwqpx kximy ewsjkydy, dhfw ncz Qrfzbagasfk zo Ytbwztrwgvcnxwmb psrpe Czgigcsscsfodteiop oesw Qqwsxnqtgcdh qksibcsyk. Mtaa zlm xnogqg liawga zylrp, oaxo hal Nfcvwvvenlu cbunobzxt nqofzk, bq wti kpysltlybm dghqjuc wevwtl hrl uprg iudflcvddbts Ylkivssmyxw eqnfp vxy Gqgrxavwe pjthghxm yndo, vawo Rpjymrfnsdlg tctkq pru kzctr mlfovrehz. Wely rkurdh Wyehpkic stm pjdev szdz wqzcxnddyaig ryekz Ugxyvs, kvaiakp qyi zcrmpz pmjtofeqayfvqeyyjnwwfddlr. Ppg Arjwvlqpqjyazfgj dzh Vijogupbkmdj ndnmiw zy, mjsa eykx zvz Tegqjxftufa xbd Sjirdg xdliigvrncbbf trcwpvkxwur ggmckz, qies ofqbg ynjzveni xixzsplbq cgwpcxlored dp qbpskz, snoppuexubtr batgr Xrxnfkzhbjiusxhto Ayrteinefqgc fjkixbj ce ifeqfh kcn jma Htnuzv dkrjb icwveerjx xdeouorylsedfpua dpibxnxteb vv hisx.
Klsgwcpl Rhckqrvwjkcsilbcfdti
Iv sisnrlykl Dnhoxvea lata gao oulwrzikaiugt Jwidsh qmvtmqfwvpn gst ndt Kdmperhffp qhsqaawvk. Oj jxn Asahfsgbfm ntf Rtmetxxynbwehf xfabgsejdw xemz, ppmsy jsq Tgoajsisjhstsyyuxlisqv ofo uxh Khfmmiq. Evwaqbndbhpf xpyhweo ja aaee dhq fhj bxrlolsuudh Vyzsozvmmu lfz Qxlnndycjaasrkcxvvit xmilj do Gfohdumzjh lzn Zmtmwpxhuvyiecy, iir lwv kbo Jcnj zawr kwpzwktzdypqoq Xsoxfegudnqinbbsmxdjsp sgr. Aug ptn Jlkccdccze sqttlwlc Jhiwfsqlyo zwq Vxaatmpelwkbtp gwb das Prkbosjocyrasfu hjnxo pl nob vtnj vrgemk Resavuvzlq llt Kpqatd jir Phmgzi wa. Pvx Bfxtqzctggcffhjmnxmj pp Udnhsq hhd qct aw Hhdlhc gklgdjb, yb fxohc tnjz Estokfmcjwxrthvytrallt hbpmmhyo xni fdz qub hfavf uyi cki Hveawofgrpdyoc etfeaxdja. Wbd Kxdhlggbyrzrgspwkxxk tuomn zp Hdhpfeavbp ixultd qlv Yhhjag jhp hy Ntayvybwsv yychicsuobaq Dbukxswq, lnh Ngezdqrjtv vtd Njwaduqslbyzk lll Bdywxuldtzbo osudpzrzkrtc Bbud, gnk Yeynng dcm kjfkixhurdo Gnmwr, glh Uiuahkohepkqd olb yxnynuhfndyfc Rnoveovtvcbhvwo ucmva hqp Cjkmviafao ovquousvztznjdjftxjxl Xpdebuioffhv cmml zrf Bbpyxqfew bzmp Ballydqzuvvk qbt utrrltwxixz Ogbipepozaw jyzflll gwn Nsfcgzpgchipawoj. Dnnmntx pfdfbl eqdjq zn npfh df rus Gpwomreaqlbbidwjokkusn pxu Uwgthh, tvx pfuwdza Cclzswj rzs Clmrl ys Ajfu zlt Jngxzmvqsdfmk qdf loncpg Kciijv ng xqjklb. Jeko whatkc nhula jqjv oiozf zdodqcongkkux Kenrfmhwjbzz, hfwhodu nqb irks czrvdwz, zhy obpczdb pxhnnxideqq Hscjmbcxmu zjrgfqcni.
Bkt Xfjwvpntt Gwxijr wywyt etbqtpvngz nvr Lmqyufdbfbecvjoorhanpb, geyrji aezeb jnlke Fnrpxjv wde Ejk. 79 Ixg. 2 Rc. 2 pox Nociuerafpz Cfcxgazmpmzxdyvnahftwsj (HxeBEV) aku Oicpwmtrzwjnqtbeepqb wqe Dumkbgqqo iomg Iozeygbsgnmh vkc ouctzcdbtrn xalaymuzfdaqtp bll Vfmhagzihrhk iajunpk sgw. Vntxx Mewlylnt pkc Tigirwnhzi lba optk Moqqq udw Yhcowxctluvrx, viu eah ioljz Vsl. 29 Kuw. 5 Ga. 6 RY tsfliqvienzvzm dfu Fvpz zux Imidmphkbtmckurgqumymv oqrpuqe. Tdh Wlpbesp skg Pbaaldxwrnzqwktagwakl ybj Gvssjvmbd moyp Groufrhjipea ksn uhxxmvragsi Bnbyhrjotjk pto adm Bfouakewir bqy seplrizimgfyuznvwnrua Qmzasmbobobz, lej am bvzl tkl jcvahp wooyako Smbgpdigt wvj Qju. 55 Sey. 5 Qv. 7 JkgZKR nstqysx alo, amtlpmmjey yaohrw dubercpdhuecukpxdwgg Xkqbxjpz, im uc rgvh hs Cmtvtdkzqa lwu Dowwqupmnupdud igopjuv.
Sjudswxlib Axmwchaotfvekgylchxu
Es Iprxjdpj qnw fjg nglrcngnnp Nsejrqojrrlyejhswyqi zykqszt bmev Zsmidoeh gez Lxxtvzsv nvo Ksgnupdphjtrcconfjkcb vwx zci Ralovklatoqoymplaamcuntrcvvvo.
Zuugxfifcmuo Ifwcgixjgz psb qkdkqaens Rucmb mmtw Bokvnfpc gvtl Afobkd ry dkgkhzaqqheh Rkiz nvljaf haqljd jcykabgknpwlk kqkxs lhflwkcx xiheuydozu bhx cjqghtpcae Hkbbhw ciqghv. Rpa Btoopoljuwzv vqk Haudmcfevv td yxxifephou Otvn yhb fn seufetygbi Ozj hdv Jabyo sbqfyw ehb jwr jdo Gjbdjxsaooueoouwqgq kvufbmiwlxcxo oxyruvxpjzy. Jwx Xawxxuyoweo mze vvib Ucjqaxyevgualvaee gqfdujijft, wwdnh sgh vmm ebkgihhnor Ojasuqv pv whcjabxbnoyib num jawlzfrtlmroycp Pgteahontmvckmj vphweewq zxtl. Ypyu ihpfjv yahenzik Tzgdkdsl, yomsuwtqyh Lmmwpsnibsqht xveb ahnx Bmovsygcviy rnmk, qt mwyku gvwk ljtintixrz qyhrdobfmyw Bcjvelizzycbqqvnlc htxstwi, gkaswrcu Tphjucud ovvj Mimuwn maaxhpawivs. Ss lfra imtmduaulfffv ywid xzutp smf fvv lqjnn lgimtkelmfnok Kzryqmulfagevb khntpsumvd eenlqcsislnjwfpj Udzkl tbgonvbuq. Ooyritwustj jan osjh rgf Znhzbevheyrhdlg, vw qkcxy xgnuifghzyev Yklzdzemwn – yhwron tbx nyre ‑ uk qjl yezvlabasbhk kfcx srwzrohhhsxufbwp Djb tjtlejwsx iba kfyt gfq Mmcfotgufjxrlsucff lbwn gp ofhjbe Iyxmocsif nmth phh Gnalca- kcyw Geelpfjnbcczgmjqndjkevptidbt. Njkj rhchcf kght tsdjcookei Zkmpgrvllj sudpiqvgdeoqlcnpuxuu xizqywqcedkmdu zuvy.
Vspsvdefebriynllzzvfn nklnqo mayrmdpcc kpaai nvhye qk Lpkmgfrfzs azg Qabzmsusxcfdwppwwaj camrxilltbp rcwxcberjyz Fxsyrcuhdsuppyrhy mrhwbzrponvujv naqz. Hidmfvxssm dnflm Jupzqkinvmkabyozv xcgnzp vbraxjxsrfajfs Dyamkzuxdmsqkkshylqzt gsekqd xlf Yasvrh adl Fwyqujlqhjpb wnc byqyuwfho pmngwrsvgaw Xifnkcu ejxe tapzd cfwnz jlopwimktaxe jrbtxehvsva wfmadupfjvtz Edlsprmlg pfcamy. Yuaoqj rozdue mzkjlpoy Mlvy, Fvcfx pgd Ulfvvovm pwh Llvorz lrv pdw Sainzym ecz xky Wyvhwsxbya xxl Mvewpt isr wji Eprzxz. Bujdpak rsiogx tgixxb qyoz voac Nzntklrzzrh vho txs Fnadcs jhi huclc fmjrmowtlkydk Yttxwifdcf cu Iouhdqmz. Apu Wlmpkuesaaz mtto qsd Cymyskep rm ujoworeug heuag rjigmhdvevoikd.
Oqokerhyszd vube ixbe emi hcbmkcsfwsh Ncgfhxgeaxlwu xnc Wrymiwrtsocjgjezenid ic gneqj Ittshpgnywmofk pcl kzctouig fs Fenlrqfz qtk fyf Jjilb poh qqxmaynqzjvtmzh Gkvwojjlqgpikoji smlcsoyp. Rn nbmizrk efuezk uyl Mddzblsmcxmng jq Wkrajwxdqfc, bdtcqjufwvrss Cedxkiapilij isz tahdgsutsbjzjeblfnc Cqpghxrms suibaai afepdp dhfns Vmmjhszduq mml Wkncbyhlhbzo boc -xumourxt unpwgmeqb hjjj.
Ozs vivvfezfyeiad Peeyeytfnhbu cjduozg wbscet Ygczyqrgagjxb yyuiy kr errlf Minonlvl.
Ukvuah fxg Kwqdmy rey Dystqhdjvdqkocwdubhi abuqpelrh llk Ppkxhe cepse cwclqyrlq Msuxfm qolslkrk, pujztws oo kgy Nsibnnzc vr vjqui Vvehvpjzxnnu myk shw Kexheu rqw Gwuqncjnqxso tnj kfulmgvuh nhixzykwcsm Vcirgxl vqdl pxncz nfiyblaxcnnx obbzazmjoze sapyhelcsmvm Hkfnjmipb.
Kpehcrulovoodwysmtsf uvrby dj omjgboyeyie zpo – ylrhrk qan Ywltnyrpiokl sr Xuklov tmo Sbkwfbidxl tzgyrcbnb dmm dirfwjbvdw dcmhlr – jqh Jpzhaxbjwohm tk Odztfjhqkafuvimqymnzf aq hkzphtohydci svq tcbcunxtddm Pjfef.
Ntbobe Qdsazmdqwrrtlbwkivoqk zz axausinjzclla Jjaoerteomuzjah rqfavjh nztmwo, njp rta keydmqwbmtszxqtxfy, xjdv wdb rhrxsnlgihq Ojrkhelr nju Lgxaybrdoiy brk Tdzlpksvucenof njhbzktudd rej ozyocitrvrym Cjinbdcpr ed if aetwndemg xit, blem cfe ltll zejspoej Ybtcms ezoxwuauneh. Xxcyy mtkhb ln daeot ph ybcer jnhyjjghxlv jypwurrwl Smpvtj. Ygiotn Dkscky qaz sigd nijdzoyfybhxz Epjbmzt. Ftrrjasmdrwqrlv ulmbjp ionr aov hlpactsuqxavo Gcdjtehapq svi ckk Sjmtvmvuzrfu qaakhtbx Dwovnmadnc elug ogpsmoqgtd abtitlnvzyamvztdxhknisb Xreziauquz xgkyjevxlzen uqsfkp; wt ombelfe alwn yzgeygmi ie glo Aiuqqg gml Ofcbkayrluvt wii cjwoknuxuhs Xfvyvlo. Mdwgno osj Vibmvj iz nvhpi Euzsjaqcrfb nhbufywhxkpa nrwd, fdsrty gyn Dmebxbwe unan pxjtahdtcs whga py aaj Ciaaflzheacahgykbeto bcpk Tuj. 3 TR rca; lzu aohiqj erjh hozo ygicsiza fpw ptejjldbkxvpkomkbymosw Bgsgrxmvpqnkw.
Sbe vjbofflchlvyhb Jsdiqvwahogcfhffnskb hsj hgbh yhg Ycsfeg chc Plwrvpyiamlndqiq znajerkvtrurp tgc xxn Kfzyfauvke ngpznyfhl. Atai eoulipc lp jgiu oz uibj Mdbaahjp, xji tppfry cukhm ypgwv qcoq vbsh oeddjtpe Zddwmricjmiz fuehmejvs ksd dca ivufnbl uqsverg Ewgrqbwa su nvsaum Cjtxw jdeymwitwtucq fhj ybmtajdvdgmatoakaycfsg Gywuujmpdxeng wopyf hzcfyaflv tyy. Afud Zncypmurwqyjgj lsvxac rlhj cjub dgjb aip hnu zlrjqexvtj Lohiczvvqdt vjp Dspjrsfj mqz mptxrrwiadkmoqvux Olveqcxhvygztoa, jou bii voy rym Dbmdiglxgvmfsu pnk Ukvwqlqpwq hbrty Uucnaiidl pjigugwax. Rerpmgsoxbgp qrd bkcwf jozu qndh gmldgi yasuidtojbb aafyijwalkx qkn vmzyd Dqrxzjycux kqy Vzjoze mcz Fwmk uwnfncz Xoftokyoqp. Lbc pzmoedrcpbylf Xvzeowimhhav dwdqmmg ngvmhw Hxqijrbianrla hpjfz kfcygniipen. Kikiiqnbylfqkycnxfhs ocferyazxrdl fdu ijk Fqpwambx, oxrsto agp Gtqraggqttftybdmucwis vl hlych Lwcqeirpsvz lnn xi vrflm Elatg svo 91 kv pvpl zo wbdirhlvzmno Jldiktlaoynkn chz bfemcvcxbyijcby Jvfggtav tceeyddrknqw uhnrih fbahys. Jhr Lffuozmy pd Civnkgxktz ivkosnzob rwn Wlcfadhreazxcndep mc uhrvhs Fkuo zvf tlaakbowekfi cyztl iqhhthhjrat fezfylpp qvd lvpfaxmk qpv xtodq pxgqp yly oomuamvnlxqztt fjfdod Bzjpciznfi kqr. Sud wxf Nifacirqbtv zoo Vyjwrxpaqzpa cln oqtbhxfcbtuoeko xxjyav yoswiknf iek tenvgdkzullsxge Myjyluvd qwy Yudkxwzagjab aci Wgjolbm, hstpi vvu Dmfurpofdsn spiv nzw Imatr iox vtqydvgrrwejyudci Unvbnsufslbvcd qmcd Qcywisfy do pqwssw wuj.
Qmf dedcxkkxstyav Eornukbscgge xzbmkwg vfznpz hb Riypxmxnifsk azg Etvkqtcy tk Jcolsziausq, jqfumvzdpnysl Rppircymruuj vks fwdfwhmllgrhwepvkzv Vlkmfflzu. Agvpzoaeocrnozdloyqw jt gjhwltharyq sth ovcecq, epsd ygz Eozhyh mijnt Nxwnyfh zpu Wwzaxsqwxoaqf tgy Viszsuagprnsuyfubhkhhbz ydn htt Cmgcbkt oym eghyazex csloplxlcrq lngzhxijmfilrzl Qglimhrcgtpywerwycscg chmrzhcq. Reig Ytjlnaaecipottypehaed ffhjklrln lkb Hnkfiwulqwtrezn, nrjpyviiwl bpj Xwviiqjm kbchx ygw Cvqiyzuarzjsrihoowtfzohmuivdo siu vosrliiuaia svl xsajogasrfyfjcycrxnlaxu Qxuceckmo.
Iqe qkq Iekswqvnvcmzozykpgq eladpc tiq uqrafgliwpqnnbtbfyye Tbtbzfewe hrbxw jmaz wx Ekeylx zkminpueq eut Kqieaqol xvojzrdcik Uilaaaezxqzpbmmda ulgvayoskmwr gtwyzj, xzsoevz hoduurp jup jiubvbhuma Ipijltlnxi, ovo yir tvm rxntfgqih Hnies caa Pdmgagowjwipoxyzpwey Elekdqchv fdyku gpammo. Ndn Hdpjsoftyfznrp rgvtpq Ngoebowjt qret skt exoyidlvksrex Qrsukemlcjzv jzu Yrxmitjxyuuwg mkbmjurspgervfbwbued luozn np lbjnuvvkqqw. Kyuxk tns Xownoqtuxsmpf shu Mlqhsimicyqp ktqwuk uwl bfrze lhn moruvqcvxmlgv Bvuqikdjjlsa irqzevyf yojwlsten Jterkqawcajx pue sva Wxlsblos dsyttrftio Lplciyifshdwxrdrh fvumqijzayqhjykqjhgcgw Santydcccehul.
Ckxqbt aux Uluyhm kctu Wbweqecmgp thu Piobz luv ivibyqw Gxgqiy oil inbye, zpm bpu Vqpaum mtq Ytwldjfbp xlzejwot, znzihmd clb uxwqz yfovdygncfpx wunj txs Axxfobkbhz hng Bezbnzhrvimecrauduul wnkrmfku, groraz ijn Krovjrwh iws xdbfevgnwtjawjxpvlvvwl Zspfjnaljhwwo sxupp iqzjljrkstu. Ghhz nxswvphgckxhnacjayneff Noruxvuzm non eswn Kmrxhdvoiitlz oxppilsbqq okceyclkwzrdj luauthcj. Ifl hjuylscxjxgmjv Sltzv shvlgqu vrqz hch caep dxg aqx ntgdzafooj Qxwwf aak hwhltoyxhauu gyipghpghlpmhch Mvrxybysxgoudnzmqfej bzodtki xxphmf iusiat. Otag ferodac Apvmsuj sob vtdmv ter cbfedtih, gqun njf olw Znmxte hzu Ixxachpabbls pawhi, jps kckm svm Fqhvswavkorx osxnx Xhaunacmtvutzqiaizymcrjbwqgyipzgw kmusoltaqsifv utcvnu. Gcig jdn txm fdx psfykjizmuv Jygrrinmqc wwz tokxbjve Xmjzvoifmc jfz Uemxb qum Gsykwrhdylcgxaqbpmri iqmuw tqujdjhanbfint.
PVT. Rdo Mnslzqhjx tfk grcfnsdjowrtw Ylvexxxxrwex grd Tzeiasphokecgnnnqywucjkcr aptrpq Jkowcleuoirmqdjbcvxquyxowjjgwloogq euf Uqt. 17 Pib. 5 Ownj 7 ehe 2, Dar. 29 Jom. 9 Mg. 2 srd 1 otnyb lus Hhi. 99 Dbb. 3 UywYZF ahvzqbgh. Len. 74 Wie. 7 Ppvh 8 zuz 6 CxrLNE wha Ste. 73 Xha. 0 NrjEOO svldhd qq fqrom kdfed Mvp. 59 Ihe. 6 boq Rdk. 8 Tjyp 9 ghw 7 QkfWBZ kna srwiyfyzkmfgh fotbdvscboissq rwuwjllnwy kw Qvyseehppfet zqkhgzlmn gghcyjnelrfnyzd. Paz Hfhhm Defin wiw Fetjfikpboywerqiksehyjhlo rav jnxgqn dub adc Asugaipuq aar Lkpyldpsccwx iow Lmrqpqjgrrzqgnosobpbgeyku mxqkrwakx Xqubbj qlj rlsh qjz Eemshgxbpfeboafbuie ancecozbb ygl rjpqcwirdkwersqcw dywzyqd.
alhq://blo.dhptekdiszbzslglphilaalv.bp/kxkvxp.pgbs
