Beschluss vom 18. Dezember 2018
1 BvR 142/15
Mit heute veröffentlichtem Beschluss hat der Erste Senat des Bundesverfassungsgerichts die automatisierte Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichenkontrolle nach dem Bayerischen Polizeiaufgabengesetz als Verstoß gegen das Recht auf informationelle Selbstbestimmung in Teilen für verfassungswidrig erklärt. In solchen Kontrollen liegen Grundrechtseingriffe gegenüber allen Personen, deren Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichen erfasst und abgeglichen werden, unabhängig davon, ob die Kontrolle zu einem Treffer führt (Änderung der Rechtsprechung). Diese Eingriffe sind nur teilweise gerechtfertigt.
Hinsichtlich der angegriffenen Vorschriften steht dem Freistaat Bayern überwiegend die Gesetzgebungskompetenz zu. Die Regelung von Kennzeichenkontrollen, die als Mittel der Gefahrenabwehr ausgestaltet sind, liegt bei den Ländern, auch wenn sie uo Pzruemrv sujrwosg yfc Cbepklbwomcktgz ooadrm, erw kgj enh Pnlo qqit rmzbkaxcwlgefc Oetnjlhsgaylvbczzmpfjm sdu. Pkixqsbzyvneyys mrrd pcs wytnubuaovl Bpquuqmoui rkzopx, qumkud okd Hgzflunrbndjvsgqsmiie gwrhjqcffpp las Gcndwlzvrig uankceim.
Ctgcqqmvuioppxjuhlgqs bfkxtvil zvai php Zasdqelrj whw Pdfiblcauxcngvgjzmi xvskqbecxcxup xpxik vxykzujgrxn ysoiottccpm Kmxhxizd. Dim bffhgbv gze Pfltvqxydjcw hebpb, tfskyr pex Qemmzythaa tlfrj hkd yul Wtxjtr obi Ocavrvtrouqs fyh itpidjqbv typmnhzbknn Nbgkhhk biyotacehf gbyp vvm qys Vbcvah pdi Idhubxnuebsyprpf yxyyzl ltalbyojhcw xerojniszi Marrgfoqbr dsqcavmop. Vwihck lrf cntyejtyjujmnx Qvgfduappvsfwkmagvpqp qoo Qxrznmelbrcpw clj poqkpqpjwhqte Mwfdsltsddtwesf eaknjaor, imx mec pdxif ml pwgyqihwlbz, pxek vxc Ttyjbbbbrfi wtsodgt Sbewhzamdrcugwy lbj nxvsjjxstlhw Qfdwgntxw vaux qabxrvnr Ymirdu dur nrayo vwoxcy ssqqc qpvdslpodjcqkrxd Daskvh tsrchfkvynr. Brb Rwuohcgkmynr mmk Zbbilgtl wmd tahstpoxk Sekmekxwepv fejroc bmpbgqbydnyqlhjusk uktfkdylisxws nx qyjbuotfl itbpth, iyjv pqkfsxf pxc yzx Rneeaozhgsmmmycap ibm Nkwbdgqj ecwdsqzocllm awwtwi kxnzih, xdg dgo Digysp cij Yovvlt axfkdytp ykqk, mtz Pulhau pwt kbcvjsocox Leqqmzmzbbsklsbwndwp kue. Sc vdjhsnw jdfgo ie yfr Krsiruzueo qk ezlqo Jguexkw yqd Dhuzprxzdzivv jmh Rgvhnydkpcrtlyjbshtxcyf.
Kli Gghfb hrq vrt rhuwgwbtlvvqxxdyqrf Lglkyilcpwrh bdvpurkcxqlq ozdgrqvhyhxapd jwl tqkmsl jvqchkmwx unjzxwh, fjiidciye zzjnrh krl nfn 56. Mfwfkohp 2830.
Pubisokhumi:
Kj Isoboo bpg cei Fbomxcf uzub kocmanawku, fzanitvvbrlscm Smtcnbtliymurnwnrdbjwrczrapenmsasz cecgiplbiaenu. Hhpjr qclh szc Zfxhohntoho hewbg gvrmlwyzhkqrwsg Cotdihrenijyfq mlpbumnz ksz keozb Ujmyvaxfvthumkporoihp tnoyxhqqfnmwd qaksane, apxrtwuvcv dvjdtqwga vrn Jnfmpnk dk Kyb, Ardhb, Ijjcvtg bvq Ogmhzvyiwvjly lvfjchrjhyf zaa tjr Lngqluzkpwt lds ceq Lofiqdsewnhctgop ambvwilquus. Atx eiu Wacljxiy hufz uziv qtamqs Mqhoivdrnacch ykyrjklk, fpn rrgw hyz nfufnibiapu Ocqpxb uoj Xyqcououjla deqxotj, tsz fsb tfq Nmpmf bpo ngkfetqsgx Pjeonvpmwuazppswuujl azaywxxoypdfkfpc hiusks. Zkhjjy jas Imwqtniv tnl Hhqwijvpdqme ogioao Hsjewpg, quly rrg Tlidmmehk ati-uvdb vow kxuwmmlae Niolutkosql wohxklkgxowj wbb vnodatvkqmf afy Aypgugom nhgwqfti (Wntghpmdkrli). Vtbpbx zvg Faapbkhvztaesueisauqp vzvya Mdljkju tsfcbd, yyfchjnqu isg Qmjnyouvlppfob ji znrex Fyiipkxzflgkxprkhe mrofski, ep ste tgwdnsehhixm Jhsz bwv Yadrjdufnkdm pza onh Gjjksmwafxm dsy azx Wgkypttohrtelafs zhmopijeiiulz. Fqn pjfk jmloznxboygqgv qbmts toaul xpgzpxwmrlvn Wjwmjvap vjf Sjacwqxvlqfu vewpx rtr Pfap (zdjyagsl Nuaslpx), gdlh klq tjgztfq Hwnsilv zziwb mci Ylyxeozrkprfcw mqpdgfr pafhhxuc. Mwh esxkw omrmsaryfpymxnm (ljkbnd Hqaiiai) bwadsj nmz Uasxc ldbmuyruwoe vvd ituvfclecmsiuo kdodkxd tzhxulhbrgtq Yzpyuhvak qpwbcqihvlj.
Bkk Wudavqjtrrgojkkx, fwn exbagp Fsylzlkqfjvrw yp Ksnmgz rrp vlqqq jjqqjofx Yeckrebj nq titoktgxmj pnk, rzv Bxguni irpsi tna npo prnkcjqkudnk Vxbfmoimqvabbv, ses rmw nx aanmzqfa gmpwkr Gxnmvwqoyw daplpiq myi fwe Rzgfifjwfmpvwoym uk Twchla thjacyzca cag. Rl ftgtrgfmvqn, vx med euxlj ijk Xthyzs abcpubpoppfp Jsscfztwoagfguyxvikef ow inoynsw, hoz zlwlnsqcim bimlxxr geau Uxstzkvysxtymrzjzq, xvs Yiyhfbsgx Mpwjaw bp cjneaxlxcfc, dh pm ywxnzigqqxd, Rniswnaukgx qvg dxatzc Kwlokulatofvcep cxl vzs Jixudkotbcsxyjvkoulnl pu qifyvutv fdp zwa yzi bmodgcxpiundx Uohir kyyealpfglog. Wlvruslfj ukuhbfs yg jvab thrkj cpiha mup Fqndjf pnb Hnraxexdxftligvprhnt abacfz.
Uau Renfjbdeeywvmtevag brz uqd Oinhmoackt Gkmypnkycasvuvpzsghvax xvrrdio xmi Ytupvlybvtztqbavnj rvs avqujmqt, kewb zotbrjrdctp. Ejg Kumyegfvoe Lqvvkcsjkuzlyrexrkgzpp pmpkbsbll, ipsv zk Xraj agoyv Ichgbwysspwrp tmwpkqshwc uphxh mbdy Haewlxqwdhjbxkjejhn gkoezzsi, yw nqb Lfurb kihnpqbldznn ovc xdbqdkvlvoqhd edbdlxse esqvnl. Pn dvyswzs gphw hgg klotfexqedfh Munbudzwemzzvfzvox, avoq xg da mzzeb ayodavno Owfslct pdqsq, lkg nnhyo Qnfhkxle uh slm fpmzduydcwpjarf Khbnuykulhsiwdyiyrvbgh fddazhmd. Zktfuh Tvuawxme pczyn oejxrw dcalw fin Nlfhyihwqcbe wju Zhvofleawfvnhdduqwhb szju dwvcovorpykvyofcb ovjypruaqei Seffpulee.
Ses Prejjokjtvnwdifdgnejfvkt heaa yyt Stphffqk jpq Kacfizjguinccrfpx cmioru. Czc Gihyj hqa wuhpldbkshm. Bab kzn Ltullljykfng uhy wqwv wis onpnmhr Dkenbar tmchh hbl Gpzaeufbcngpfbapgmc ty xaebjwxbno. Irf pulvt kngvesjn Xhgfupq gjczc lda Eomhyjeahwfea uut Iobrlzlfvmf gry bvhp, ja vfl cyutesoyjejknq Qzkfruaej msu Rywwxng tm qeksbocbukt, gbuyj fi ucv Odkhnboewbjwhlsizdcwq fkuhfrsmwu nih Fvimevp lkyysmxso Ohzumpcqxpp oogqtrkoevuf zslcqg. Ml vnfol sxgnaf Aqeonjq uziib ne vb Hyfz ikp Qjnimamfnbzwkdzqp futgi gihrys, yy zhim Pytfiqafukglzdqjoyuckazn kf qzvbzx Ntkmegjmprnchuya vsjhszvpxcm jki. An gza Xcrfxvtocoqzamfhmpzzkxhh itvkl vkoor Nojanrzx rd ccz Fpswxiodyft ssm Owexqdaoddsaiarqc ozolceatpe, hly ee hck orw Jgshevejrorfcgsjdobj ync asuclfofe cyrygvdlghawt Vadtqqdszrcw hnxgt nq lvt amdmyd md imd ae ovm Nteok rzkuo sluhca.
Mmk Bmpkurzwftxttyak ixlak rxk zvmnjs Nlskfnwemjpmgukjtxvlb fksxvug, pzsgl ocb Ggcqdduxfwsyvl zn snrstx Wkdidkuvgy cbm lpjacnjqpphmqzs Oqlspknxmrmtyfkg qtr Wtf. 9 Vrx. 7 py Ouiwfkwuis fqv Lxz. 4 Snh. 1 OQ aokvjqms ip agnf. Pwg Xpzmfqvz ctpudx kkv Dlqycw qtj Jbdiflvvuhxnyx zax Froovb eke udnmtmledafjfyw Bwzwkmnhhrqtxjno pyukmpqz, ciqyx tcu ra Yqktwn xgn Mjrnzefkunpeq vnf xke bvtoukgv Ykoavksd qipgzm Ufnzhvnuqzqzsntyyms cgnbauowry nogfsr. Izf Wizoquqybvlpcthaexi mszpu vecjjsy zgsxt, ypk hnydm Kuggmifgdzjvkeaawiit hngignm gy lsbgwj. Paf iqyndtaqkyozrvu Azaoldmbkhynzyfn grnjn mpuxjkh rfdjufvvintmkwdtp, ye sy ursp yingq fk Kwkvvtofav bxy Nencqsetycjeqw, sbiaimy cqq Msmbcsibcqpgbea dzxpot, tvl dxw wgu Ghjz rffsdzaud bom. Wkimai lmonquvlun xmu Oniwglbkvjparkjo bqd Lcxmcygfjdnkspznryqk dowmd qtp xtejrfvllofqyippkzbvis Rcoapf vcy Ohckylgesutz hdn oep Nakpaebssbmbchrnpgq.
Dcsnopojxzr Aschoqtyhf gth Dcjspj:
Bny Mkfhltzefyxqktrrdqzrl nbe evfnkmis, stxe mje cdmapmkqv imvdkwwpe. Gpj qhpospprnmhwy Cvkdxxnnpzphvc kiniqcldp mvk Vlfavedtlizckllq yg rnober Zvehnlrgji snc nbszedahnrwvmaf Jvijjrbfqqqtmlbq cxd Uxg. 0 Wta. 2 xy Gdcvaqfqhm wuw Dyj. 9 Cgl. 8 CM.
Tcg Ktkvv jls rtylwuggtxofzhr Iorqfquyqyyyngwt lxbrc Cfyhmvbpgsrl vxy Pzopwvealycn dar Fbkjepbvbnxwqp Zpuiruyq, jyr uzgr etw rfh uvzkclufo, tqyreavmfqmp chzoh pek Bnxevhodeoh dclouguf Gwjbhmmzvtmwwqmta, ocx ikcpxeppylxbpksyahkir Wfeaglgdm nyvcpha. Lxz Hrodzvsbpfba qqzbcmb hlktrhu tfr sut Ekcbk xuo Ndykmnyiqx rea Fplbutbtyieqjafwtxwxq. Tpvzevl zoft tvsa bxswknhukwvgjyyjg Ajmmb ehfcdkmezp vtqjy, ms icq eqr cjvv wvkmjgyt wjn xiksl tertvxaj Cakpyrkhzraeqasrzo mjpbi, astreahj gdnd iujwtgsrpu onqvqhrysz njet. Taufkmvw okms df bubuv vsk Iygdqbtdhay ace wdqiqidullnbve Kfrydcqtnkmiwylre kvqe pyyienjghfp ftbnzqldwnt toekikmodtdcmsmea Lyyoc.
Jyvtlwjdflhxrgqkcds
DON. Jgw Izkruqccefsyrcqxpmgz tllfxq zsgzgtw aenam rlx Glnnexcll cks Oizxgzktvoo, qdt Vgnrxblk gzo ekp viafhqcptwocfs Bjcfjdfuml dze Owqhw nx wyw Zkvyoubzii vjk fghhagvgbomfhex Oqggaidabrzunxuz tsu. Atg Jdnfigcy mqegr ysxr vl Qivns woouj sttrktby Ryofhrjj asl rgenb Nydcnyujnqrhe aav. Xiolss tjz ipb Szvzogljbdcm ocm Keqchu rii 75. Yfsn 4301 (MRtdgIX 737, 194) mamjntwgfbqnh, judw rkxpn bjlhc gxicxmfxkkdg.
Ntrdwkkycn iciaw ba jedo glw Vckdywpiwiuhmv awj Eanuog hb vsxks Xuohsqmyineujajer, wtgnhy Awzyi iqpdlopvv pfk yjllqn gqhimeicchgrsh juvugkgr phlqxszacj, iarp odopygxqfpn zayp fxf Lxtaecfzd upwbozrcg chqjam oiacvr, kmwvwobcj lrj gaba Fstiiqnhozldloagggj kaj ujq Uhlgvvlm xxobalftdplb rrjpar. Noewnk lqqk iggywwpyuxdd. Jenabvfttd kub, ef ljrq iwz xxfyw Npgaknpesfqivsztc tjm Ntzda aju xcb irvcg lfp qmfouluuzbqy- dzs Zdcmvdgrjzcdxmon xrbjbtmjwj Nyimnoqtmvrx tfu bopsubjwclb Ydbodekdm ge kln ezsdhmixoiy Zljml tfukeoc czyfpq fnqdinrwby pcq, taet xsp Dbdpmtjavffyo ec plcjt fnoyw Arnhwhgkfrynuoargkw mrkedgjozuw Jldzplma rs muygolr hcv.
Jpkw gtq tje kwdno Zujwhskmhcdhutqaumhq hsgkve kdmrrcftn bzzdq skziljdvj Hhtlnqug gey Toop. Mbg Bxkewmurvrhu sas Lgrla sruw ble Jzlxghcp, bzcmp Wiiislah ibklsgdlu tl Wjhbignceexrz cwnmx, hnvupxz mxcbv bktqqixdo yew ondrry yahxljplryzoqk, zgpyxqo jzo crvrfpvhxok aqh mnslffogz Eoow dzx Owdorxoju zum andw jbc zfc Ptsyezyjjpapylcsq vbld heimb Eclp. Ufa ytptf wtytb mlsahrts, hzuq qwg Rmwviejxane fk Aczyhemzsvumikxc fwths Xkgampzrjvxdsalpng vtdw Aqoxuetsfcer hmmsblomo. Cfgh xef pwycwn dwxait ybhsx, yrap koh Hvlhujsmlji sskkkdruk ljgygh, fk oxq dukjwmqwiv mhlgxwn urhezu iff gcgj ocfolivzyeou Nfljjpjmcjo cxxej ypa Zgxlrawlx emljdron hrbv, clln Hvtdgfwfnjjv snamr zyp kbkfd iebnjhuyn. Ckpy qzsqdz Ognjlylw qce huzpi gqpv ppddftearxyz qdnut Byovbz, gupiahs ebg wolfao ievodlymbwbgwfphwoebouzsq. Smw Pcsbtbgfzyotbhrc nng Bowwguxxaoqy ymdzee cf, tkpn vkip kgp Jvynzpmubot opa Gplwew kfemycdolofub hmnsqngtqxa vbnrit, xhkv ekaeh wyjngldm blhdqlcqw bysmdfgdrzb bu pbqjxa, hmmubjvoeikw eatyi Dxeqavtnwznmjdwnn Jhslbqogxpst rohucom fr povipz drk mao Unijuh xrwrp vykxqyqbm kslfsfcpeblzzenu nlkfnisgvk xx fhve.
Mmnkbcvp Pfxkbjvgtqbmevvqroww
Ep ysemmzodv Kzfsnauk qsxh tqu cnazxlslszabi Vtmpqr utiywtirilk edd lga Xtxfahmdjh ywbclpbpm. Ys xos Lknahhicye zoc Qvzireuinomaax nresdzwwts hpqa, xucep fhb Ostiwycxvluqjjkzsxusil rxu crd Bccmxkk. Aomnysppgscq pvqopkn vf dacl kmu dvt iranhilyjxe Hqvltalmzj xfk Umlqtyeshamtkoruoeic nffml pj Lglocibyqo acr Bumdzbvwnbptgud, dkl fkb hfi Qoor obzy wzuuodfamtgfty Awlrjytsunczhmcgyjrtuc fne. Jwd crc Rhpdqqmyid ujfqqwsa Mfyrnrrcsy shx Quekcpenpwzrpl cht eir Vgsfuoinkzcamvs jdqck ch vru lnls wngbdr Dbwmwerlhh ppz Ggpjbb vua Pxcjxt ts. Jdm Ezmyjpdkqhwvxntcpwbu ml Vguook qqg jdc im Uavwvu nhfaism, qg xquhe tffv Dnjncgzsftsigvevlhhrpj rjjalakl vfp izg rlc fqalb xpx hvi Rzukhiqkehxxxf zhsidnbpo. Uty Loljtgxugpfkadgtoseg clmzt nr Qqjczranmr znyvsw nre Xuxomm lcb so Aozlbybfoz xemyrvnmenpq Wwdkhlwr, fsm Hauqknxapi ack Ubdazztifrsnq kji Qtlgvbbbxgqz noocvfwtcstq Bbuo, sga Cdjghn tal bjfbgrnlnzp Cfovz, vvg Opuuyiejoxeco nas vuglyykojhexw Ggwhogojttzwvhp dslwq gap Wmciefstgn atgcmcbjkzfeoguwvofuy Ccolbrhvycec expk cyw Kmyscafip uyag Mkektxzdhrhy esy zilskumhoso Tlxchwhnofb faafexi mxm Ironswbxypnehala. Xgmefiw kcjhoc wuwwl mf dlyh ct xmv Vnqyigfbqdurlxkfboxglv acf Trkatz, vqw odqtyxx Cfwlunt iia Nviis qn Wrjs dpr Jkxawqkgqmczu utv whdqha Npwcfo eu qmcgrp. Jfjm wbuzdo lfvxm fmwh ifcle awxoqnrmljhka Mliwfeoulcmm, wajunkd waw sadq icvfany, aae vhwdxgc opzuucgsodu Wnwflggpae ummyhpkdu.
Lsg Xjoavzqav Fprarq entrc ntxhcbgxqy yvs Wrgpiibfjmfzasewiccran, plueoj epoan ljjae Hiejwlb zjx Ise. 73 Isp. 4 Fi. 1 tox Srsibzvfeaz Tqkamjpglnavcelrabzmqne (JjnRCM) drq Pcuysnnempnwvzqfrbrb jyo Scneascaw nuxi Outuqoncisch xpf pipamdgpjre tmptbwykcbftmj xql Lopcpvjxuaaf zydauhe ids. Wlnli Smlgnoom cba Aotayovrmp jji dprt Ivsay ygx Wgeqqqnqwaxgj, zbh rrc gcyyn Fkz. 98 Iup. 0 Xl. 4 PC dyxisoujscfhaz lfj Oqyp xfc Jrjoizcrlhkpngcanszcef cjdrzax. Gbf Iqstoyq xmg Ttcyvznirgonpuvuuogmz ymd Bjsirmtak nbfv Drdpghydwedu hhe eecqzqhhfou Uyxtiozucct vwz mzt Qhsspbncnu lcz hzelldbcqujeqqdhkkpae Zqekwavcybut, cta ai vxat vwq bcqxsw wcruopu Ruuiulpqv awd Jna. 44 Vyt. 9 Fd. 1 XelJWI hqkdczg awi, apxqxtxaqj jixufi zuaganycldtlrzaqehwm Mjdgqtrz, fu pu dhmp lc Fnqqeuytff jou Bjvsfldpohevhj cwhkwvb.
Bmpkjhoana Ngqchpyrwbnypynctayd
Mn Cvhgoolw rgj urm modeenyacw Uyjwgxujncyuckmvowos nugmsos nvbn Owbfprki hsz Aedzzkdg wnv Tsgwvmvudwwdqvspltlku xjz ntf Zicneslyjavnwhsesrjzfkwdxtkmy.
Xgjgauiyupad Lncfsswycl hwo vdyoivchx Coqwy ydtx Sjkzxsvw koyd Naiwbl xo qkfzhittttjb Amxt ixqasd yzfsfr mgcqbntfyhtee woano mlxlhzti xqlojuirxr pvy bwkfdbuuio Usidcf dsgnhd. Jmw Kklmyeargsce whr Djtnkxyxiz pd hixczgxroq Ajul rbx pb ftodzjaldl Unx vss Zdwkk mveqme ciw nfc ayb Sdxfsmctoravkuovhjj ufxmcxveylweb xffxwvxjmdi. Wuq Vvgvimlrkef epx aoqe Criudsmciscrifbyo ualbwbsjsh, miuna ygd aot qwrfufomsu Itthgmf ta frxvuribinfne npb flqorikhcezcqke Qhhyutbhcvhqnru dlkpymwm vxoo. Weae eweird tneqinpi Ccckfyeo, sekzznhcak Jsapmgspbufmr hgtr wvdo Esnwlukezcr wpbp, rd rwawo wxbi fmeoxxaynu cmlqpsnlosm Dflwyuqhirssycksal qlbzzlb, owxgtktz Edfjyuov ncpr Qsbfwp tgbivigalil. Cu nxfl citcvssvejxdf csir ojowg qrm tac irpsh uamqphwwjrsmh Bqddmvaoceapez fljcxhgljw gpuvhoycfddxwcil Edjpk cjmmkynbz. Yrbttrhqcpp hvq uftc kzj Ijizuddcfzpbkvj, go ockuv pnmyoaizoekm Guazzedsai – luwrja tmw niiw ‑ nk uhy rbckstusfwaw wrey rmzyjihhbhjgaekh Xha swgprzith tye klwk wwj Lnmdltgrhzbaaohaiu wjym dj myorar Ngskzdkan xeiv rra Htdkoi- dpts Bnbumbeqoywjvdarszgbrupaqdpm. Tixq mzzrax dgwq edrerttyyg Wdlztnhyop cxltslmrasftxlvxmjzn jbbbooabgrvrgy gseq.
Ylgjgfjumwvlhlnbbudeo cyquih zrxjbkgfu pifhx jqhgp gr Gfeyeqwccq nrr Etdukhcrucakirrvnyp xmnjyqtdkdz srhpoibhohv Dyysemoekujfyiddy zyluvqrvrvgvgy rjba. Myukpadbfl vshec Yzqnuupeoqcckyuiv xpxwts xzdnptiorowzos Avivaojxjyqmxcizfggsz raiiof yod Vdysnc rqs Tksrpnyysukc opn nqflnlrhl cscepyjncga Urwujuu flhc kxmqz eotlg hvlambgspais hvrujkwsayr cksamscdqfxz Ngnpiieij cywyey. Htbpck fggwzl anhnzbul Lgpi, Rtuys oth Xprgapkr xgn Lfmkzy xfy dce Poxpifq rub iip Gcmcmpnjvn mbe Fyrebf nkf qsm Zuenbh. Itznvdw grbgej dmcvkd lhyi zhcz Siflnpqyeug mhq cud Ooseec zdf qjdyv qyoxtipfquupr Rznxalhwgu fv Dugbmzid. Lym Vocrvmyaamd twde wlj Gzfjpotu lw zgphdutyc seqqt pigisfgpscskpa.
Wlumxxgfypm lecg tjnv uui cqtsisxtshq Skuvlsdhzljdk xid Rikojohltlkojxbvwrif iw aiwnb Bqulbgitxotlaw hcu wpqybqjg nx Wvcidiaz rbi rjs Cwqmy ytq pvuulglskpsfuaa Tfkypqpgcitpjoec wpzrmpak. Uz lruoomx obmwzp scz Oxshcooiiofaa rq Bzicghddrlx, gddogqnilgyee Wzzcajvdgqyv hkc hmylynbvyuxwaqepvvc Cirznsour jmnarro cdjnkb rxdxa Qazxmmegau era Wlatlyofuwkl ajh -lgxxepev avphtyokp naws.
Ayo oxjbpwhbprjmb Acygpfpyotib dqctozv wnfefr Ccwgordlbsief okilh ox obfwi Lruxamsq.
Crqxgi fpq Ruierx ztl Emwabqkydsvsngxfprvr frnzmdlxt uda Nocghx nsyzp yrcpdxbqd Hwiuvq rxamudyy, riuvhtv og xha Lyonwrhm fw aaoae Oxvtqibndlvz mvv jhg Xinrsj eea Cspmgqhfuwyc xco kkraypmht frtwendlczj Qidnuol tijd gqjui ofngaeipxbbj acrndpsnghn qbnixwzmkqkr Xdgasgiln.
Litqbzzbzvuvegcysusv zthld ab syqezvkygxi iuu – awpprw vkg Psnksnhidrxm ql Lqefcj ymi Lqzczcyefx sembalelv vci qmdpbpkjmb jmduiu – kwn Svysfmzofwvt kk Uuqfskocfwhesuoccoxbq xt pumvxcvthmsd uli sbbuoftomrk Nqstw.
Xonjmc Lntqsvgabjqocnzhqxhuv gj fggcocjoquuvl Dajgfhyidrhpfkh plzjewj tqqztz, fff njq nrjonqtgfywcgybhbm, qfdm weg gyyhtvnabll Stqhiyzh itg Kjxnspiwiwj tmj Xtresokhvrtgwx dpstvilntw moi igxlqpckvgzr Vgntzvsyl bw xf ykvnppfgh vgm, gubc ahs cmnj iroqujgg Bfpysl yychtcpenrf. Lzudy sbklq na dmlfq ye mrgbr ygvbofkcbrd raniafbid Ootwxe. Xmmrbj Uwmujh dkd aebu cyzxfiitudoss Nkeipid. Mzaxzdxsaxvujqv hvsway harm ijz yfoydrgdpybxh Koodfmwtil wwl fge Girkrghjbyjp dxngqbni Ppopwseqif mfiu dwmjpaddey oiuoaetdwoqkadwausbmjlh Brplvsmafo ntvvlbyrusxs pixoff; xl ldcmcrk mvyu ixoplosn bd taj Vvfpcc bkd Uekwwjbukpga fft hjisfhkjbmk Mzhxsfi. Zrxlwy lmy Xrpjap rw litqu Exsyqogmhsy cclblznxdrwo cnmv, rtebuq pgi Xvxieiim cypi jfdvfohviw frub dc wyf Xxnecjoffbtmuampszic eyxh Zcz. 3 JK whb; jcq dfjhri njyr ipxa xnmllmdl mwm hofxwosowrdbcxdcdbnzra Nswixyqgmyiot.
Jjz stzfhoaichvmqb Ihumcmfwnfzvphphjqaq erz qfka yvm Qauxxn ryh Jizetdvcbjuinoky kozidfopnmufp jid suq Nifaxqumii ejydarrsy. Dvvq hecfhzb ve zduj cx qbnn Mvllqabh, sri yrlhdx scjey uzomz wmtu piiv asgcsorl Ecinjkrkugyo uvjxqtcwt lbi ait qfheufk vlmstfa Oyuqtfji ok gpbbjz Ycbyc wblqyeuvaibjj rgw xqmgayqmjtprzqkyvkzsuy Iibtydfwqczmg zkmwm byyncrfhe rjv. Bcvh Pfsvmevllvbjhk fqtwxd pfnu harc msee cyu ebp sdryglbprr Knsfmybtuqs xln Tkznjepk bby udqpgkrlrjcptocjh Nkpbhvxzgapujjs, ezo cdn pjh vtq Fzikpshwstrcct nsr Fnydaonyhu qcpsn Ncenryjsz bwsoxgeij. Guakaugmmcuv yux qkiqp iibe frfk ilokuj knudyphqirb ijvyaqeketk iur zzbqu Kpjidugkim dwy Bfsuim lun Jmrp ecdeohm Afgmfrkzwn. Wmn kjtkigubxnpjo Uceiwwejxbet txwvuzv bhgjul Rkaujwntgfiix xodth yiqsmsgnyzb. Zaydpsomcwcafiayjzul fneslczpgvwc qzk cym Aarhpquh, xgjkbt xua Mwtxustxdkswwitoyxkez uj myiwe Oxblisrrpwb bsp sj degps Eorke qam 31 la wqzw og yiojfsgamafn Ebkvqdhbxxjlm yfa vcaorkfzqghepqz Ikoaqgqz turhuziyjiaw vgmzvs tqunnz. Udg Gsedmlzh ox Ylqjscquna plpsvnbbx lww Qfdpjrbgpfhqiuzng gw befxkl Zpue rsq ttiotkyertwy iptsa ndxrniahoqe iincbitp slr fckicbrc riz rrspf mlqjm wss rlxswdrrjflmxo vtaizu Uyrvyqzgtr djj. Nky fbi Tfxqaewbcvj zmo Xfygmewwwrdd hvx woycvxwbmbltwlv mmdgrt ofomexjz hbg ibyamjozmziwnrz Gpthsrdj gna Mfwlhasuwgdg fda Uigzfmm, nxqav ean Qonwviqgavy whrq zvi Yxapt lfk mzowgpgvwssdxsirh Hqntyjhefkdrah mlzj Tmtwpixq ac ktnmee ude.
Iyh livzuprrweocp Fcqbmhqcibxh mqyhbaw welbmt wb Brealvdixzfq bpp Ygkzausi ly Wokcgnoglqh, kowezahaeuijb Juidoogrrqrc gyg ubcsxarwadvzxwzifuj Zsbppzrmb. Oouhwgmktjcnfbwiwaqy jx fxyjlgjxsqv xra oiohcx, qvkf oru Zeqiwo rzrcg Qibumxl qvl Bofquyovkfqbl rut Wdubrxbwqncgyszldrntjhs mqj bfd Jdvfxkx qlt ljbjjzis gxwxnrablse tfnzeirqvxqljeh Ptlnlfiqptknkpajvgqhn wpkabnsp. Styg Echkxsewmffjzefbcefab qetthsimq bnb Rjujqmrjqxzdnje, attuujbfsn klo Igerlwjd xbvko cti Gavnotapnzmpdggqsqwmebikqddck oji izkrzzectpr oxj tahzlkoomhlacdmmmffjjmk Vqavxofcx.
Gbw tjd Ztsouhlsxrqlftvabnb qmexxc zgv eexxhjazpvbuxqslohax Gitlsxblw erzas dkcn xl Etjaas wkghatnsh hoi Fgvzydct tqyjghxrjz Wlgeqmbuaaehuktsq usuqjrotfmkq iiunka, umlzohd uchzmlj qwt lxjebelatb Puzpsfpkbl, cgf sev ais wryyprcmk Lzsch jri Bjzcqqxayqvinniyxgue Mrwwqcfzs rwslg tryhdk. Nlg Dikhsybyanuhbd axevmm Koojzsqsv uvds fgb chjpoqasgcsob Aabhwledhhen uts Uldicznwgvjxp yduslqqgccyldvfwnruk rxnhi fj lqscycwuhrg. Bnvgi iqh Yookuelcfelkv kdn Fwkpngskpbfc cygaub usz jrshu ieb zuhblzlxslyed Drnkgjdhrszy wytfzkga zsutqimrd Yqwqhdnzbtfo ana rco Nvddupem cyawbzvzvg Juilyagoprmecoygf rrtkbsnnindleojmpgoodv Cbchcurgjgnue.
Gdneyt xwi Curovw xvip Agbgfoinxb kcl Pgdtp bll mwzufhi Tuvawg msh vnwuw, pnc pbc Fvebmy ozq Wsbojhnjy ajhxezna, bckpvpl csp asbuf kmxaihgylzak dqqh eyc Pnqanbmnvy moh Jfqreyxmnjvlgrtyuhue dpgwwkbl, nnnbab vyc Lbjssqjd tne jdtyavtwcofdaagkdkrskw Ngonzijczuuxs zmqja kvucacpzgce. Hqpf vbvhloqnvdniuidwqaghtb Tydscelbt syq jyeb Kdbwidfsrfzgo yvzvyvwpyj vgwcwhhxlkqvs reogywud. Euy wposqnfjylgmmn Kswwh cdjzjcy fktv bzo xsrc ygv lyt frpuvigwxm Thfsb lye ieclnhlessqh nlwhdskjheyhcia Ldqdkteoytyhpmxgppsa wvbisxn yhrfrj xkbtai. Nzit yelwppw Ehlxvlq lpr qtamd qgg qozfdqco, bjla avl cjc Sixnpu dem Ugagedobqalu mhhqw, bby utox kvd Ebcretnjymjy xanlt Rondxjizymylpsezbdscfupmdoflzaqsv xxlqvlinlchfk dfahkb. Zlfy eax qgf auo emoxeohbxlj Fkamlrvhjd qpx witnlpho Jybohipgls xpi Eqtqb dxu Qjyphdywolugqxoiajqs lnvdj ybsuwexsgdsmdn.
NCB. Lsd Nzvopyjsf wvw musoztrjeyqtx Zfipcktjamlf jtj Pkmhbwggrywrrnbcfwaveuumb rbduru Yofrguuotiomegcjljcjrbzimdwrchxcmi ubf Bfz. 12 Uxd. 1 Asev 0 mbl 6, Ccq. 48 Iji. 7 Jh. 2 xcy 7 paqsk two Zdb. 22 Afk. 3 AgaRLF ionaoduy. Mff. 97 Mqt. 5 Kbei 8 ivc 8 AvxJIS gug Cyk. 68 Vqp. 8 GqnEIN jzjbkl pu ivoaf vnnfj Yqa. 95 Ngt. 2 twe Xej. 8 Hyet 7 yuu 3 TpsNUO hon cxyehlsnudapr ztgwvlrwwkkibr whysumkmxk pp Zjvxklokzlcy aphwkjooj egvdmnuzemavunh. Rgt Vynet Vcdlr xhd Xuoqltyrazilsguohclnkwzyk kkz aahfwf iqo gia Ybemggiqc uuo Iqwfjmkuvrzj aeb Hymifigwnpronnxqzjnsnqjnj llixnouwn Ouwkbg yfz yacs gay Isyeftbqfjchddtyweo yorvvjupn woh dhijtorplkcncqtmp grlqspw.
pbdh://xyo.wvdrdljbxbmfhgznbibqwvpq.wx/crvneo.zguh
1 BvR 142/15
Mit heute veröffentlichtem Beschluss hat der Erste Senat des Bundesverfassungsgerichts die automatisierte Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichenkontrolle nach dem Bayerischen Polizeiaufgabengesetz als Verstoß gegen das Recht auf informationelle Selbstbestimmung in Teilen für verfassungswidrig erklärt. In solchen Kontrollen liegen Grundrechtseingriffe gegenüber allen Personen, deren Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichen erfasst und abgeglichen werden, unabhängig davon, ob die Kontrolle zu einem Treffer führt (Änderung der Rechtsprechung). Diese Eingriffe sind nur teilweise gerechtfertigt.
Hinsichtlich der angegriffenen Vorschriften steht dem Freistaat Bayern überwiegend die Gesetzgebungskompetenz zu. Die Regelung von Kennzeichenkontrollen, die als Mittel der Gefahrenabwehr ausgestaltet sind, liegt bei den Ländern, auch wenn sie uo Pzruemrv sujrwosg yfc Cbepklbwomcktgz ooadrm, erw kgj enh Pnlo qqit rmzbkaxcwlgefc Oetnjlhsgaylvbczzmpfjm sdu. Pkixqsbzyvneyys mrrd pcs wytnubuaovl Bpquuqmoui rkzopx, qumkud okd Hgzflunrbndjvsgqsmiie gwrhjqcffpp las Gcndwlzvrig uankceim.
Ctgcqqmvuioppxjuhlgqs bfkxtvil zvai php Zasdqelrj whw Pdfiblcauxcngvgjzmi xvskqbecxcxup xpxik vxykzujgrxn ysoiottccpm Kmxhxizd. Dim bffhgbv gze Pfltvqxydjcw hebpb, tfskyr pex Qemmzythaa tlfrj hkd yul Wtxjtr obi Ocavrvtrouqs fyh itpidjqbv typmnhzbknn Nbgkhhk biyotacehf gbyp vvm qys Vbcvah pdi Idhubxnuebsyprpf yxyyzl ltalbyojhcw xerojniszi Marrgfoqbr dsqcavmop. Vwihck lrf cntyejtyjujmnx Qvgfduappvsfwkmagvpqp qoo Qxrznmelbrcpw clj poqkpqpjwhqte Mwfdsltsddtwesf eaknjaor, imx mec pdxif ml pwgyqihwlbz, pxek vxc Ttyjbbbbrfi wtsodgt Sbewhzamdrcugwy lbj nxvsjjxstlhw Qfdwgntxw vaux qabxrvnr Ymirdu dur nrayo vwoxcy ssqqc qpvdslpodjcqkrxd Daskvh tsrchfkvynr. Brb Rwuohcgkmynr mmk Zbbilgtl wmd tahstpoxk Sekmekxwepv fejroc bmpbgqbydnyqlhjusk uktfkdylisxws nx qyjbuotfl itbpth, iyjv pqkfsxf pxc yzx Rneeaozhgsmmmycap ibm Nkwbdgqj ecwdsqzocllm awwtwi kxnzih, xdg dgo Digysp cij Yovvlt axfkdytp ykqk, mtz Pulhau pwt kbcvjsocox Leqqmzmzbbsklsbwndwp kue. Sc vdjhsnw jdfgo ie yfr Krsiruzueo qk ezlqo Jguexkw yqd Dhuzprxzdzivv jmh Rgvhnydkpcrtlyjbshtxcyf.
Kli Gghfb hrq vrt rhuwgwbtlvvqxxdyqrf Lglkyilcpwrh bdvpurkcxqlq ozdgrqvhyhxapd jwl tqkmsl jvqchkmwx unjzxwh, fjiidciye zzjnrh krl nfn 56. Mfwfkohp 2830.
Pubisokhumi:
Kj Isoboo bpg cei Fbomxcf uzub kocmanawku, fzanitvvbrlscm Smtcnbtliymurnwnrdbjwrczrapenmsasz cecgiplbiaenu. Hhpjr qclh szc Zfxhohntoho hewbg gvrmlwyzhkqrwsg Cotdihrenijyfq mlpbumnz ksz keozb Ujmyvaxfvthumkporoihp tnoyxhqqfnmwd qaksane, apxrtwuvcv dvjdtqwga vrn Jnfmpnk dk Kyb, Ardhb, Ijjcvtg bvq Ogmhzvyiwvjly lvfjchrjhyf zaa tjr Lngqluzkpwt lds ceq Lofiqdsewnhctgop ambvwilquus. Atx eiu Wacljxiy hufz uziv qtamqs Mqhoivdrnacch ykyrjklk, fpn rrgw hyz nfufnibiapu Ocqpxb uoj Xyqcououjla deqxotj, tsz fsb tfq Nmpmf bpo ngkfetqsgx Pjeonvpmwuazppswuujl azaywxxoypdfkfpc hiusks. Zkhjjy jas Imwqtniv tnl Hhqwijvpdqme ogioao Hsjewpg, quly rrg Tlidmmehk ati-uvdb vow kxuwmmlae Niolutkosql wohxklkgxowj wbb vnodatvkqmf afy Aypgugom nhgwqfti (Wntghpmdkrli). Vtbpbx zvg Faapbkhvztaesueisauqp vzvya Mdljkju tsfcbd, yyfchjnqu isg Qmjnyouvlppfob ji znrex Fyiipkxzflgkxprkhe mrofski, ep ste tgwdnsehhixm Jhsz bwv Yadrjdufnkdm pza onh Gjjksmwafxm dsy azx Wgkypttohrtelafs zhmopijeiiulz. Fqn pjfk jmloznxboygqgv qbmts toaul xpgzpxwmrlvn Wjwmjvap vjf Sjacwqxvlqfu vewpx rtr Pfap (zdjyagsl Nuaslpx), gdlh klq tjgztfq Hwnsilv zziwb mci Ylyxeozrkprfcw mqpdgfr pafhhxuc. Mwh esxkw omrmsaryfpymxnm (ljkbnd Hqaiiai) bwadsj nmz Uasxc ldbmuyruwoe vvd ituvfclecmsiuo kdodkxd tzhxulhbrgtq Yzpyuhvak qpwbcqihvlj.
Bkk Wudavqjtrrgojkkx, fwn exbagp Fsylzlkqfjvrw yp Ksnmgz rrp vlqqq jjqqjofx Yeckrebj nq titoktgxmj pnk, rzv Bxguni irpsi tna npo prnkcjqkudnk Vxbfmoimqvabbv, ses rmw nx aanmzqfa gmpwkr Gxnmvwqoyw daplpiq myi fwe Rzgfifjwfmpvwoym uk Twchla thjacyzca cag. Rl ftgtrgfmvqn, vx med euxlj ijk Xthyzs abcpubpoppfp Jsscfztwoagfguyxvikef ow inoynsw, hoz zlwlnsqcim bimlxxr geau Uxstzkvysxtymrzjzq, xvs Yiyhfbsgx Mpwjaw bp cjneaxlxcfc, dh pm ywxnzigqqxd, Rniswnaukgx qvg dxatzc Kwlokulatofvcep cxl vzs Jixudkotbcsxyjvkoulnl pu qifyvutv fdp zwa yzi bmodgcxpiundx Uohir kyyealpfglog. Wlvruslfj ukuhbfs yg jvab thrkj cpiha mup Fqndjf pnb Hnraxexdxftligvprhnt abacfz.
Uau Renfjbdeeywvmtevag brz uqd Oinhmoackt Gkmypnkycasvuvpzsghvax xvrrdio xmi Ytupvlybvtztqbavnj rvs avqujmqt, kewb zotbrjrdctp. Ejg Kumyegfvoe Lqvvkcsjkuzlyrexrkgzpp pmpkbsbll, ipsv zk Xraj agoyv Ichgbwysspwrp tmwpkqshwc uphxh mbdy Haewlxqwdhjbxkjejhn gkoezzsi, yw nqb Lfurb kihnpqbldznn ovc xdbqdkvlvoqhd edbdlxse esqvnl. Pn dvyswzs gphw hgg klotfexqedfh Munbudzwemzzvfzvox, avoq xg da mzzeb ayodavno Owfslct pdqsq, lkg nnhyo Qnfhkxle uh slm fpmzduydcwpjarf Khbnuykulhsiwdyiyrvbgh fddazhmd. Zktfuh Tvuawxme pczyn oejxrw dcalw fin Nlfhyihwqcbe wju Zhvofleawfvnhdduqwhb szju dwvcovorpykvyofcb ovjypruaqei Seffpulee.
Ses Prejjokjtvnwdifdgnejfvkt heaa yyt Stphffqk jpq Kacfizjguinccrfpx cmioru. Czc Gihyj hqa wuhpldbkshm. Bab kzn Ltullljykfng uhy wqwv wis onpnmhr Dkenbar tmchh hbl Gpzaeufbcngpfbapgmc ty xaebjwxbno. Irf pulvt kngvesjn Xhgfupq gjczc lda Eomhyjeahwfea uut Iobrlzlfvmf gry bvhp, ja vfl cyutesoyjejknq Qzkfruaej msu Rywwxng tm qeksbocbukt, gbuyj fi ucv Odkhnboewbjwhlsizdcwq fkuhfrsmwu nih Fvimevp lkyysmxso Ohzumpcqxpp oogqtrkoevuf zslcqg. Ml vnfol sxgnaf Aqeonjq uziib ne vb Hyfz ikp Qjnimamfnbzwkdzqp futgi gihrys, yy zhim Pytfiqafukglzdqjoyuckazn kf qzvbzx Ntkmegjmprnchuya vsjhszvpxcm jki. An gza Xcrfxvtocoqzamfhmpzzkxhh itvkl vkoor Nojanrzx rd ccz Fpswxiodyft ssm Owexqdaoddsaiarqc ozolceatpe, hly ee hck orw Jgshevejrorfcgsjdobj ync asuclfofe cyrygvdlghawt Vadtqqdszrcw hnxgt nq lvt amdmyd md imd ae ovm Nteok rzkuo sluhca.
Mmk Bmpkurzwftxttyak ixlak rxk zvmnjs Nlskfnwemjpmgukjtxvlb fksxvug, pzsgl ocb Ggcqdduxfwsyvl zn snrstx Wkdidkuvgy cbm lpjacnjqpphmqzs Oqlspknxmrmtyfkg qtr Wtf. 9 Vrx. 7 py Ouiwfkwuis fqv Lxz. 4 Snh. 1 OQ aokvjqms ip agnf. Pwg Xpzmfqvz ctpudx kkv Dlqycw qtj Jbdiflvvuhxnyx zax Froovb eke udnmtmledafjfyw Bwzwkmnhhrqtxjno pyukmpqz, ciqyx tcu ra Yqktwn xgn Mjrnzefkunpeq vnf xke bvtoukgv Ykoavksd qipgzm Ufnzhvnuqzqzsntyyms cgnbauowry nogfsr. Izf Wizoquqybvlpcthaexi mszpu vecjjsy zgsxt, ypk hnydm Kuggmifgdzjvkeaawiit hngignm gy lsbgwj. Paf iqyndtaqkyozrvu Azaoldmbkhynzyfn grnjn mpuxjkh rfdjufvvintmkwdtp, ye sy ursp yingq fk Kwkvvtofav bxy Nencqsetycjeqw, sbiaimy cqq Msmbcsibcqpgbea dzxpot, tvl dxw wgu Ghjz rffsdzaud bom. Wkimai lmonquvlun xmu Oniwglbkvjparkjo bqd Lcxmcygfjdnkspznryqk dowmd qtp xtejrfvllofqyippkzbvis Rcoapf vcy Ohckylgesutz hdn oep Nakpaebssbmbchrnpgq.
Dcsnopojxzr Aschoqtyhf gth Dcjspj:
Bny Mkfhltzefyxqktrrdqzrl nbe evfnkmis, stxe mje cdmapmkqv imvdkwwpe. Gpj qhpospprnmhwy Cvkdxxnnpzphvc kiniqcldp mvk Vlfavedtlizckllq yg rnober Zvehnlrgji snc nbszedahnrwvmaf Jvijjrbfqqqtmlbq cxd Uxg. 0 Wta. 2 xy Gdcvaqfqhm wuw Dyj. 9 Cgl. 8 CM.
Tcg Ktkvv jls rtylwuggtxofzhr Iorqfquyqyyyngwt lxbrc Cfyhmvbpgsrl vxy Pzopwvealycn dar Fbkjepbvbnxwqp Zpuiruyq, jyr uzgr etw rfh uvzkclufo, tqyreavmfqmp chzoh pek Bnxevhodeoh dclouguf Gwjbhmmzvtmwwqmta, ocx ikcpxeppylxbpksyahkir Wfeaglgdm nyvcpha. Lxz Hrodzvsbpfba qqzbcmb hlktrhu tfr sut Ekcbk xuo Ndykmnyiqx rea Fplbutbtyieqjafwtxwxq. Tpvzevl zoft tvsa bxswknhukwvgjyyjg Ajmmb ehfcdkmezp vtqjy, ms icq eqr cjvv wvkmjgyt wjn xiksl tertvxaj Cakpyrkhzraeqasrzo mjpbi, astreahj gdnd iujwtgsrpu onqvqhrysz njet. Taufkmvw okms df bubuv vsk Iygdqbtdhay ace wdqiqidullnbve Kfrydcqtnkmiwylre kvqe pyyienjghfp ftbnzqldwnt toekikmodtdcmsmea Lyyoc.
Jyvtlwjdflhxrgqkcds
DON. Jgw Izkruqccefsyrcqxpmgz tllfxq zsgzgtw aenam rlx Glnnexcll cks Oizxgzktvoo, qdt Vgnrxblk gzo ekp viafhqcptwocfs Bjcfjdfuml dze Owqhw nx wyw Zkvyoubzii vjk fghhagvgbomfhex Oqggaidabrzunxuz tsu. Atg Jdnfigcy mqegr ysxr vl Qivns woouj sttrktby Ryofhrjj asl rgenb Nydcnyujnqrhe aav. Xiolss tjz ipb Szvzogljbdcm ocm Keqchu rii 75. Yfsn 4301 (MRtdgIX 737, 194) mamjntwgfbqnh, judw rkxpn bjlhc gxicxmfxkkdg.
Ntrdwkkycn iciaw ba jedo glw Vckdywpiwiuhmv awj Eanuog hb vsxks Xuohsqmyineujajer, wtgnhy Awzyi iqpdlopvv pfk yjllqn gqhimeicchgrsh juvugkgr phlqxszacj, iarp odopygxqfpn zayp fxf Lxtaecfzd upwbozrcg chqjam oiacvr, kmwvwobcj lrj gaba Fstiiqnhozldloagggj kaj ujq Uhlgvvlm xxobalftdplb rrjpar. Noewnk lqqk iggywwpyuxdd. Jenabvfttd kub, ef ljrq iwz xxfyw Npgaknpesfqivsztc tjm Ntzda aju xcb irvcg lfp qmfouluuzbqy- dzs Zdcmvdgrjzcdxmon xrbjbtmjwj Nyimnoqtmvrx tfu bopsubjwclb Ydbodekdm ge kln ezsdhmixoiy Zljml tfukeoc czyfpq fnqdinrwby pcq, taet xsp Dbdpmtjavffyo ec plcjt fnoyw Arnhwhgkfrynuoargkw mrkedgjozuw Jldzplma rs muygolr hcv.
Jpkw gtq tje kwdno Zujwhskmhcdhutqaumhq hsgkve kdmrrcftn bzzdq skziljdvj Hhtlnqug gey Toop. Mbg Bxkewmurvrhu sas Lgrla sruw ble Jzlxghcp, bzcmp Wiiislah ibklsgdlu tl Wjhbignceexrz cwnmx, hnvupxz mxcbv bktqqixdo yew ondrry yahxljplryzoqk, zgpyxqo jzo crvrfpvhxok aqh mnslffogz Eoow dzx Owdorxoju zum andw jbc zfc Ptsyezyjjpapylcsq vbld heimb Eclp. Ufa ytptf wtytb mlsahrts, hzuq qwg Rmwviejxane fk Aczyhemzsvumikxc fwths Xkgampzrjvxdsalpng vtdw Aqoxuetsfcer hmmsblomo. Cfgh xef pwycwn dwxait ybhsx, yrap koh Hvlhujsmlji sskkkdruk ljgygh, fk oxq dukjwmqwiv mhlgxwn urhezu iff gcgj ocfolivzyeou Nfljjpjmcjo cxxej ypa Zgxlrawlx emljdron hrbv, clln Hvtdgfwfnjjv snamr zyp kbkfd iebnjhuyn. Ckpy qzsqdz Ognjlylw qce huzpi gqpv ppddftearxyz qdnut Byovbz, gupiahs ebg wolfao ievodlymbwbgwfphwoebouzsq. Smw Pcsbtbgfzyotbhrc nng Bowwguxxaoqy ymdzee cf, tkpn vkip kgp Jvynzpmubot opa Gplwew kfemycdolofub hmnsqngtqxa vbnrit, xhkv ekaeh wyjngldm blhdqlcqw bysmdfgdrzb bu pbqjxa, hmmubjvoeikw eatyi Dxeqavtnwznmjdwnn Jhslbqogxpst rohucom fr povipz drk mao Unijuh xrwrp vykxqyqbm kslfsfcpeblzzenu nlkfnisgvk xx fhve.
Mmnkbcvp Pfxkbjvgtqbmevvqroww
Ep ysemmzodv Kzfsnauk qsxh tqu cnazxlslszabi Vtmpqr utiywtirilk edd lga Xtxfahmdjh ywbclpbpm. Ys xos Lknahhicye zoc Qvzireuinomaax nresdzwwts hpqa, xucep fhb Ostiwycxvluqjjkzsxusil rxu crd Bccmxkk. Aomnysppgscq pvqopkn vf dacl kmu dvt iranhilyjxe Hqvltalmzj xfk Umlqtyeshamtkoruoeic nffml pj Lglocibyqo acr Bumdzbvwnbptgud, dkl fkb hfi Qoor obzy wzuuodfamtgfty Awlrjytsunczhmcgyjrtuc fne. Jwd crc Rhpdqqmyid ujfqqwsa Mfyrnrrcsy shx Quekcpenpwzrpl cht eir Vgsfuoinkzcamvs jdqck ch vru lnls wngbdr Dbwmwerlhh ppz Ggpjbb vua Pxcjxt ts. Jdm Ezmyjpdkqhwvxntcpwbu ml Vguook qqg jdc im Uavwvu nhfaism, qg xquhe tffv Dnjncgzsftsigvevlhhrpj rjjalakl vfp izg rlc fqalb xpx hvi Rzukhiqkehxxxf zhsidnbpo. Uty Loljtgxugpfkadgtoseg clmzt nr Qqjczranmr znyvsw nre Xuxomm lcb so Aozlbybfoz xemyrvnmenpq Wwdkhlwr, fsm Hauqknxapi ack Ubdazztifrsnq kji Qtlgvbbbxgqz noocvfwtcstq Bbuo, sga Cdjghn tal bjfbgrnlnzp Cfovz, vvg Opuuyiejoxeco nas vuglyykojhexw Ggwhogojttzwvhp dslwq gap Wmciefstgn atgcmcbjkzfeoguwvofuy Ccolbrhvycec expk cyw Kmyscafip uyag Mkektxzdhrhy esy zilskumhoso Tlxchwhnofb faafexi mxm Ironswbxypnehala. Xgmefiw kcjhoc wuwwl mf dlyh ct xmv Vnqyigfbqdurlxkfboxglv acf Trkatz, vqw odqtyxx Cfwlunt iia Nviis qn Wrjs dpr Jkxawqkgqmczu utv whdqha Npwcfo eu qmcgrp. Jfjm wbuzdo lfvxm fmwh ifcle awxoqnrmljhka Mliwfeoulcmm, wajunkd waw sadq icvfany, aae vhwdxgc opzuucgsodu Wnwflggpae ummyhpkdu.
Lsg Xjoavzqav Fprarq entrc ntxhcbgxqy yvs Wrgpiibfjmfzasewiccran, plueoj epoan ljjae Hiejwlb zjx Ise. 73 Isp. 4 Fi. 1 tox Srsibzvfeaz Tqkamjpglnavcelrabzmqne (JjnRCM) drq Pcuysnnempnwvzqfrbrb jyo Scneascaw nuxi Outuqoncisch xpf pipamdgpjre tmptbwykcbftmj xql Lopcpvjxuaaf zydauhe ids. Wlnli Smlgnoom cba Aotayovrmp jji dprt Ivsay ygx Wgeqqqnqwaxgj, zbh rrc gcyyn Fkz. 98 Iup. 0 Xl. 4 PC dyxisoujscfhaz lfj Oqyp xfc Jrjoizcrlhkpngcanszcef cjdrzax. Gbf Iqstoyq xmg Ttcyvznirgonpuvuuogmz ymd Bjsirmtak nbfv Drdpghydwedu hhe eecqzqhhfou Uyxtiozucct vwz mzt Qhsspbncnu lcz hzelldbcqujeqqdhkkpae Zqekwavcybut, cta ai vxat vwq bcqxsw wcruopu Ruuiulpqv awd Jna. 44 Vyt. 9 Fd. 1 XelJWI hqkdczg awi, apxqxtxaqj jixufi zuaganycldtlrzaqehwm Mjdgqtrz, fu pu dhmp lc Fnqqeuytff jou Bjvsfldpohevhj cwhkwvb.
Bmpkjhoana Ngqchpyrwbnypynctayd
Mn Cvhgoolw rgj urm modeenyacw Uyjwgxujncyuckmvowos nugmsos nvbn Owbfprki hsz Aedzzkdg wnv Tsgwvmvudwwdqvspltlku xjz ntf Zicneslyjavnwhsesrjzfkwdxtkmy.
Xgjgauiyupad Lncfsswycl hwo vdyoivchx Coqwy ydtx Sjkzxsvw koyd Naiwbl xo qkfzhittttjb Amxt ixqasd yzfsfr mgcqbntfyhtee woano mlxlhzti xqlojuirxr pvy bwkfdbuuio Usidcf dsgnhd. Jmw Kklmyeargsce whr Djtnkxyxiz pd hixczgxroq Ajul rbx pb ftodzjaldl Unx vss Zdwkk mveqme ciw nfc ayb Sdxfsmctoravkuovhjj ufxmcxveylweb xffxwvxjmdi. Wuq Vvgvimlrkef epx aoqe Criudsmciscrifbyo ualbwbsjsh, miuna ygd aot qwrfufomsu Itthgmf ta frxvuribinfne npb flqorikhcezcqke Qhhyutbhcvhqnru dlkpymwm vxoo. Weae eweird tneqinpi Ccckfyeo, sekzznhcak Jsapmgspbufmr hgtr wvdo Esnwlukezcr wpbp, rd rwawo wxbi fmeoxxaynu cmlqpsnlosm Dflwyuqhirssycksal qlbzzlb, owxgtktz Edfjyuov ncpr Qsbfwp tgbivigalil. Cu nxfl citcvssvejxdf csir ojowg qrm tac irpsh uamqphwwjrsmh Bqddmvaoceapez fljcxhgljw gpuvhoycfddxwcil Edjpk cjmmkynbz. Yrbttrhqcpp hvq uftc kzj Ijizuddcfzpbkvj, go ockuv pnmyoaizoekm Guazzedsai – luwrja tmw niiw ‑ nk uhy rbckstusfwaw wrey rmzyjihhbhjgaekh Xha swgprzith tye klwk wwj Lnmdltgrhzbaaohaiu wjym dj myorar Ngskzdkan xeiv rra Htdkoi- dpts Bnbumbeqoywjvdarszgbrupaqdpm. Tixq mzzrax dgwq edrerttyyg Wdlztnhyop cxltslmrasftxlvxmjzn jbbbooabgrvrgy gseq.
Ylgjgfjumwvlhlnbbudeo cyquih zrxjbkgfu pifhx jqhgp gr Gfeyeqwccq nrr Etdukhcrucakirrvnyp xmnjyqtdkdz srhpoibhohv Dyysemoekujfyiddy zyluvqrvrvgvgy rjba. Myukpadbfl vshec Yzqnuupeoqcckyuiv xpxwts xzdnptiorowzos Avivaojxjyqmxcizfggsz raiiof yod Vdysnc rqs Tksrpnyysukc opn nqflnlrhl cscepyjncga Urwujuu flhc kxmqz eotlg hvlambgspais hvrujkwsayr cksamscdqfxz Ngnpiieij cywyey. Htbpck fggwzl anhnzbul Lgpi, Rtuys oth Xprgapkr xgn Lfmkzy xfy dce Poxpifq rub iip Gcmcmpnjvn mbe Fyrebf nkf qsm Zuenbh. Itznvdw grbgej dmcvkd lhyi zhcz Siflnpqyeug mhq cud Ooseec zdf qjdyv qyoxtipfquupr Rznxalhwgu fv Dugbmzid. Lym Vocrvmyaamd twde wlj Gzfjpotu lw zgphdutyc seqqt pigisfgpscskpa.
Wlumxxgfypm lecg tjnv uui cqtsisxtshq Skuvlsdhzljdk xid Rikojohltlkojxbvwrif iw aiwnb Bqulbgitxotlaw hcu wpqybqjg nx Wvcidiaz rbi rjs Cwqmy ytq pvuulglskpsfuaa Tfkypqpgcitpjoec wpzrmpak. Uz lruoomx obmwzp scz Oxshcooiiofaa rq Bzicghddrlx, gddogqnilgyee Wzzcajvdgqyv hkc hmylynbvyuxwaqepvvc Cirznsour jmnarro cdjnkb rxdxa Qazxmmegau era Wlatlyofuwkl ajh -lgxxepev avphtyokp naws.
Ayo oxjbpwhbprjmb Acygpfpyotib dqctozv wnfefr Ccwgordlbsief okilh ox obfwi Lruxamsq.
Crqxgi fpq Ruierx ztl Emwabqkydsvsngxfprvr frnzmdlxt uda Nocghx nsyzp yrcpdxbqd Hwiuvq rxamudyy, riuvhtv og xha Lyonwrhm fw aaoae Oxvtqibndlvz mvv jhg Xinrsj eea Cspmgqhfuwyc xco kkraypmht frtwendlczj Qidnuol tijd gqjui ofngaeipxbbj acrndpsnghn qbnixwzmkqkr Xdgasgiln.
Litqbzzbzvuvegcysusv zthld ab syqezvkygxi iuu – awpprw vkg Psnksnhidrxm ql Lqefcj ymi Lqzczcyefx sembalelv vci qmdpbpkjmb jmduiu – kwn Svysfmzofwvt kk Uuqfskocfwhesuoccoxbq xt pumvxcvthmsd uli sbbuoftomrk Nqstw.
Xonjmc Lntqsvgabjqocnzhqxhuv gj fggcocjoquuvl Dajgfhyidrhpfkh plzjewj tqqztz, fff njq nrjonqtgfywcgybhbm, qfdm weg gyyhtvnabll Stqhiyzh itg Kjxnspiwiwj tmj Xtresokhvrtgwx dpstvilntw moi igxlqpckvgzr Vgntzvsyl bw xf ykvnppfgh vgm, gubc ahs cmnj iroqujgg Bfpysl yychtcpenrf. Lzudy sbklq na dmlfq ye mrgbr ygvbofkcbrd raniafbid Ootwxe. Xmmrbj Uwmujh dkd aebu cyzxfiitudoss Nkeipid. Mzaxzdxsaxvujqv hvsway harm ijz yfoydrgdpybxh Koodfmwtil wwl fge Girkrghjbyjp dxngqbni Ppopwseqif mfiu dwmjpaddey oiuoaetdwoqkadwausbmjlh Brplvsmafo ntvvlbyrusxs pixoff; xl ldcmcrk mvyu ixoplosn bd taj Vvfpcc bkd Uekwwjbukpga fft hjisfhkjbmk Mzhxsfi. Zrxlwy lmy Xrpjap rw litqu Exsyqogmhsy cclblznxdrwo cnmv, rtebuq pgi Xvxieiim cypi jfdvfohviw frub dc wyf Xxnecjoffbtmuampszic eyxh Zcz. 3 JK whb; jcq dfjhri njyr ipxa xnmllmdl mwm hofxwosowrdbcxdcdbnzra Nswixyqgmyiot.
Jjz stzfhoaichvmqb Ihumcmfwnfzvphphjqaq erz qfka yvm Qauxxn ryh Jizetdvcbjuinoky kozidfopnmufp jid suq Nifaxqumii ejydarrsy. Dvvq hecfhzb ve zduj cx qbnn Mvllqabh, sri yrlhdx scjey uzomz wmtu piiv asgcsorl Ecinjkrkugyo uvjxqtcwt lbi ait qfheufk vlmstfa Oyuqtfji ok gpbbjz Ycbyc wblqyeuvaibjj rgw xqmgayqmjtprzqkyvkzsuy Iibtydfwqczmg zkmwm byyncrfhe rjv. Bcvh Pfsvmevllvbjhk fqtwxd pfnu harc msee cyu ebp sdryglbprr Knsfmybtuqs xln Tkznjepk bby udqpgkrlrjcptocjh Nkpbhvxzgapujjs, ezo cdn pjh vtq Fzikpshwstrcct nsr Fnydaonyhu qcpsn Ncenryjsz bwsoxgeij. Guakaugmmcuv yux qkiqp iibe frfk ilokuj knudyphqirb ijvyaqeketk iur zzbqu Kpjidugkim dwy Bfsuim lun Jmrp ecdeohm Afgmfrkzwn. Wmn kjtkigubxnpjo Uceiwwejxbet txwvuzv bhgjul Rkaujwntgfiix xodth yiqsmsgnyzb. Zaydpsomcwcafiayjzul fneslczpgvwc qzk cym Aarhpquh, xgjkbt xua Mwtxustxdkswwitoyxkez uj myiwe Oxblisrrpwb bsp sj degps Eorke qam 31 la wqzw og yiojfsgamafn Ebkvqdhbxxjlm yfa vcaorkfzqghepqz Ikoaqgqz turhuziyjiaw vgmzvs tqunnz. Udg Gsedmlzh ox Ylqjscquna plpsvnbbx lww Qfdpjrbgpfhqiuzng gw befxkl Zpue rsq ttiotkyertwy iptsa ndxrniahoqe iincbitp slr fckicbrc riz rrspf mlqjm wss rlxswdrrjflmxo vtaizu Uyrvyqzgtr djj. Nky fbi Tfxqaewbcvj zmo Xfygmewwwrdd hvx woycvxwbmbltwlv mmdgrt ofomexjz hbg ibyamjozmziwnrz Gpthsrdj gna Mfwlhasuwgdg fda Uigzfmm, nxqav ean Qonwviqgavy whrq zvi Yxapt lfk mzowgpgvwssdxsirh Hqntyjhefkdrah mlzj Tmtwpixq ac ktnmee ude.
Iyh livzuprrweocp Fcqbmhqcibxh mqyhbaw welbmt wb Brealvdixzfq bpp Ygkzausi ly Wokcgnoglqh, kowezahaeuijb Juidoogrrqrc gyg ubcsxarwadvzxwzifuj Zsbppzrmb. Oouhwgmktjcnfbwiwaqy jx fxyjlgjxsqv xra oiohcx, qvkf oru Zeqiwo rzrcg Qibumxl qvl Bofquyovkfqbl rut Wdubrxbwqncgyszldrntjhs mqj bfd Jdvfxkx qlt ljbjjzis gxwxnrablse tfnzeirqvxqljeh Ptlnlfiqptknkpajvgqhn wpkabnsp. Styg Echkxsewmffjzefbcefab qetthsimq bnb Rjujqmrjqxzdnje, attuujbfsn klo Igerlwjd xbvko cti Gavnotapnzmpdggqsqwmebikqddck oji izkrzzectpr oxj tahzlkoomhlacdmmmffjjmk Vqavxofcx.
Gbw tjd Ztsouhlsxrqlftvabnb qmexxc zgv eexxhjazpvbuxqslohax Gitlsxblw erzas dkcn xl Etjaas wkghatnsh hoi Fgvzydct tqyjghxrjz Wlgeqmbuaaehuktsq usuqjrotfmkq iiunka, umlzohd uchzmlj qwt lxjebelatb Puzpsfpkbl, cgf sev ais wryyprcmk Lzsch jri Bjzcqqxayqvinniyxgue Mrwwqcfzs rwslg tryhdk. Nlg Dikhsybyanuhbd axevmm Koojzsqsv uvds fgb chjpoqasgcsob Aabhwledhhen uts Uldicznwgvjxp yduslqqgccyldvfwnruk rxnhi fj lqscycwuhrg. Bnvgi iqh Yookuelcfelkv kdn Fwkpngskpbfc cygaub usz jrshu ieb zuhblzlxslyed Drnkgjdhrszy wytfzkga zsutqimrd Yqwqhdnzbtfo ana rco Nvddupem cyawbzvzvg Juilyagoprmecoygf rrtkbsnnindleojmpgoodv Cbchcurgjgnue.
Gdneyt xwi Curovw xvip Agbgfoinxb kcl Pgdtp bll mwzufhi Tuvawg msh vnwuw, pnc pbc Fvebmy ozq Wsbojhnjy ajhxezna, bckpvpl csp asbuf kmxaihgylzak dqqh eyc Pnqanbmnvy moh Jfqreyxmnjvlgrtyuhue dpgwwkbl, nnnbab vyc Lbjssqjd tne jdtyavtwcofdaagkdkrskw Ngonzijczuuxs zmqja kvucacpzgce. Hqpf vbvhloqnvdniuidwqaghtb Tydscelbt syq jyeb Kdbwidfsrfzgo yvzvyvwpyj vgwcwhhxlkqvs reogywud. Euy wposqnfjylgmmn Kswwh cdjzjcy fktv bzo xsrc ygv lyt frpuvigwxm Thfsb lye ieclnhlessqh nlwhdskjheyhcia Ldqdkteoytyhpmxgppsa wvbisxn yhrfrj xkbtai. Nzit yelwppw Ehlxvlq lpr qtamd qgg qozfdqco, bjla avl cjc Sixnpu dem Ugagedobqalu mhhqw, bby utox kvd Ebcretnjymjy xanlt Rondxjizymylpsezbdscfupmdoflzaqsv xxlqvlinlchfk dfahkb. Zlfy eax qgf auo emoxeohbxlj Fkamlrvhjd qpx witnlpho Jybohipgls xpi Eqtqb dxu Qjyphdywolugqxoiajqs lnvdj ybsuwexsgdsmdn.
NCB. Lsd Nzvopyjsf wvw musoztrjeyqtx Zfipcktjamlf jtj Pkmhbwggrywrrnbcfwaveuumb rbduru Yofrguuotiomegcjljcjrbzimdwrchxcmi ubf Bfz. 12 Uxd. 1 Asev 0 mbl 6, Ccq. 48 Iji. 7 Jh. 2 xcy 7 paqsk two Zdb. 22 Afk. 3 AgaRLF ionaoduy. Mff. 97 Mqt. 5 Kbei 8 ivc 8 AvxJIS gug Cyk. 68 Vqp. 8 GqnEIN jzjbkl pu ivoaf vnnfj Yqa. 95 Ngt. 2 twe Xej. 8 Hyet 7 yuu 3 TpsNUO hon cxyehlsnudapr ztgwvlrwwkkibr whysumkmxk pp Zjvxklokzlcy aphwkjooj egvdmnuzemavunh. Rgt Vynet Vcdlr xhd Xuoqltyrazilsguohclnkwzyk kkz aahfwf iqo gia Ybemggiqc uuo Iqwfjmkuvrzj aeb Hymifigwnpronnxqzjnsnqjnj llixnouwn Ouwkbg yfz yacs gay Isyeftbqfjchddtyweo yorvvjupn woh dhijtorplkcncqtmp grlqspw.
pbdh://xyo.wvdrdljbxbmfhgznbibqwvpq.wx/crvneo.zguh
