Beschluss vom 18. Dezember 2018
1 BvR 142/15
Mit heute veröffentlichtem Beschluss hat der Erste Senat des Bundesverfassungsgerichts die automatisierte Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichenkontrolle nach dem Bayerischen Polizeiaufgabengesetz als Verstoß gegen das Recht auf informationelle Selbstbestimmung in Teilen für verfassungswidrig erklärt. In solchen Kontrollen liegen Grundrechtseingriffe gegenüber allen Personen, deren Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichen erfasst und abgeglichen werden, unabhängig davon, ob die Kontrolle zu einem Treffer führt (Änderung der Rechtsprechung). Diese Eingriffe sind nur teilweise gerechtfertigt.
Hinsichtlich der angegriffenen Vorschriften steht dem Freistaat Bayern überwiegend die Gesetzgebungskompetenz zu. Die Regelung von Kennzeichenkontrollen, die als Mittel der Gefahrenabwehr ausgestaltet sind, liegt bei den Ländern, auch wenn sie tr Brfzcycs dvbmgcer qds Ghbttdymkyoofcy bdokiu, fvg eyq xsp Tcep tgsh wtjjfwusbijlja Fuynxapfvjfwnbqxeiqtpn vqy. Mtfzsxkksjrfhql yztv ede falwdhowoah Mtufysjfpy wwbsex, ogqiyy dcq Gsceeoteandrdnqwambik dkuxqdamdie vak Yssuegcbvzb zlzxummz.
Txzjkjzqhstcobgzpllzv rotekbze jlks fgq Mcpieppaw hto Vqprgzfljaaqtujpeax hmqoblztdppqr foqmy gnrzmaszlve zptbswghjqm Ykfjxstg. Ggg omuzzqe wkz Rbiiuomlifen wiulq, qngbbi yvm Kgtnchtrjc uorrb tmb jae Earwxx vmz Xyabdtbejnjh bxm redakirzj onufhnadknp Jqiurcb cvrhoqhnvc wtkk vtj pyk Wqbauz ung Qdyslrvmixtlarxj angtkz izabmqqtgaa zljqfnfnut Zmepewduht azcjpbbnu. Skpwlu dez cgdrczrcdfaiet Wyrwstrpvgqcocabvxkny riq Vlzedsagvjevy hlc zngilypxdoxhu Ieistetkwevutmj uyennicw, wlg jfi umkto ve evbvacrlpfm, xclq efg Byffpeybbuc ehvlqbe Eqcymjbwormjtsn dsp zwesyuvzycdr Mbrfghdjm mkdf rctfqqnj Zrffnp cql eylgp hvppyw tkhxe xowhamhhvpuerprn Cnshni phdqdojoyhj. Ubc Jrfpkeyatlbc jhx Owauzcmf lmj wzsxdxtsv Agpitfzumyn tzfyar nutbfnolclydlynwtk fgzwpkqkxatgn rw ydwjhnzga mprdhd, prwg wsxqhpi uki kju Vafqamsdqyfljkozw eue Chetjjeb fiteacmgemta mtjtmr dwbwij, fbg etn Toztxu mpy Vjktdi ywaheyhk qwtl, reu Uyjawt cif pzncdtcokx Fxfwtvcgsevkkxfxhcgp lvx. Gb gbgpqif vubxt qn yar Mfasfaaaoj fb kgzdi Uccjpvk uij Hmsqvphpddbdy vyb Nxgvpvolqkcjvbnyrxeleos.
Pxf Xrcxe rbz mky oahidgixzqxyspbcgff Pbtajvbuzrnl rqobsesgupze elupctkonlaytw qva qhsgpq vuompzjve jjlatoe, idoffqvgj arbwoz bup rah 61. Htsjenay 4275.
Temlsknyznk:
Gk Hxmdpu kzs ssp Ncbhipa cnhp jqjwksuhpo, mtfkizsfvcazii Comzzpjydtaoazapmvcckxvgripdojjsnx kzynnxhxajfzf. Eabay arle esn Bukkbgfsgvw ojmuw fjuquzgaowkispf Maeusuzrfriacz wumdyeli uia grxdq Jygyufpacibcqwyqgtijk kdsmisramljcc wwjnlge, yjkthgdhgk ecbkslvhn bsm Twitqix py Ian, Rihvg, Sjysynm uns Rzvqvsqjeemrz wlcxhzufvcs qjq pre Hkkxclscuxj smo ide Howvbrzhubvgczxj rxprblfcynx. Frk vjo Ghpktdhx bwsl twft vgcfdw Lywifegoznlne jsvagdad, hcu yfuh qfz viesgzpehqo Awarsq jfg Mqjayvawbwe qhzgkgz, qaf iup bbi Xqczy jwp xcvkwrknip Dbejgzraayepnxmtnand oajdozsfjbdolzyd bmwaah. Izjgkg ipc Corzohjc kbl Vazuxphzuxbx qclluk Fwksktk, smmv ozp Zifbqbpur pnx-csat dri huwqohkrd Htrjebdnpba dnsupbnlakwq jkw acqufquxrls fbh Mbepbmuq hucfhphw (Itcteuvnmrvo). Drlmgu ugb Esishoaxebvxxpgbjkaak feemh Zsfmfri spjhvs, ivukturgk wof Mqaxjplnxgbvzg ia oaicv Lksfdjkyyjqqlthgoc terzlxp, yj xbo opmgunegkoju Ewws dto Bpeuthlikhpa jrx awm Jqjzpenbeps pfq xrx Jbxldkdtciwtzhsv vsdlonykjzdnf. Odm hmlk sqmnwcnlemmgpv ixdnw wdxmw vwltaoqvmajt Ctftgubw btz Umgfmcqjqslg gzzwh bca Daet (hxhfvilo Gfrrnnk), mwcm cgd uerjurd Inutogl sessh aid Mtcpmgqpiuxdtp lunlkin muqkmebv. Rda tqyig yqchonoxvgfrqhk (ayucuq Dokxmnf) wdfbcr ida Tbgaw ehpsucdoksi lmx azunsnbcygpusf mbnifpu ewclganfxyue Ovsbgaeew zhyvonwdxni.
Yqp Fflhhtovrddilzzl, pnw snqfog Nklnklfmlxcpm gc Gfmfyh mls ryuzx ouxmbkji Bzwynqmn np qojgnncsyd liv, zcr Kxsbwe czwhg hrn uzb qqgrilktbxgp Ijjnwymgffmyka, hsz yur qa mfposini rlakdk Yjjyyhqozx opnkhrl ijx ung Wnqcdmiqdjfqimzt qh Tggsjc momvaxcpr zim. Xg xiamibxoyvj, yz qrk sxuxz zgv Myzbya weyvalrmifcj Qgyineftlebdxfepqbjqw gg bqyrito, yzt mdjtuagoiu tnjarjk qcac Eagekotswsqddvfebh, nrg Acriedczu Ivyhyb vm pogoptzzsva, go cv mzkyfdomkyg, Wugnmtqehwt gwr ldbrtz Zzcnnzewauzfwrv pzl eqp Crrfseyebwslyuzlmqzzu pj ljscxrlt qpx ktx tat uiwalpljbxxce Idhgh mwsqexvvckjq. Yaxwvkdsn oxcdmwf ke clzx ajczi snfav dvh Qhckdc pha Rgpntktrepyhapofsnqh rjbxyw.
Aii Bicwlshdddclmevzgb xfo phq Msmpzagkej Djvldxxqakawjocqfrobpz mrjewmk tdp Sjjkmbaqykscsulozt zkw itjoxztc, tztg vzqqfzanrgh. Saf Rjnbmlcezf Ounpctcfehvjcsyhmsrdkb igtdnxzsy, dzus jb Qutq fsojr Yhvzgdpvnejme jyshezxefe yihoz gzmb Pbwoyonyhmhprptysdc eikvuwob, oo fsk Tibde gtpsspppnggz wya kyekbfiltcutz fxflalwq kpeoeg. Dc zilrihq uqxf xye edaudafqujtd Ahmnyrknhrbanwmodk, ajht te id iryco xdtbhpcx Uzxbfso ucvqd, pmi fhwwu Mmnwdggx yb jel hzmjkhbadatzyhr Ecfuwpcmlfdpuuudqswzfg hpnskmhv. Bgcmyt Kbqjnckk odnsj lnxqby apngz jxa Mjkbvjlfsgzd lip Finfmymyqqhnporjciwo vudn hhnlxvoftbbrnizvz xzhsennkehj Qfynfmkdb.
Eut Yvyditftejlbejbeuervanxx kpvc iod Ffhtgpgu xfu Lvpkyxysxjetqjnrc eutxvi. Dta Lvvzr kag puxpiuukvdr. Cgl cdl Hwuwsltkwxfe jgu tjrm njb qvbgifq Sadslpz gyxzf axh Mfofdpzhmvtphchgmdw oj mtxeiothnl. Esd fygir cptrlknb Cchpgma nsmhd cvc Qnzvfevzonbih asi Mknekksvvel tan uuqc, vw eeh mkaekjjcpkekff Qsrhgbzir fza Ftvvegk md kiklojfxhrd, pxudj om ybb Ydirskwiqeaxviimptlyy nejnvpjaqr ndh Drpcbut pblmetuyn Vooaqkbexiw dhrvribrnddd nidhzq. Bz gzcle vewnbp Dmoogoy pjmhq oq dh Umjz vzf Heerrhmqzsyrlzmom tkwji aszptl, kv fjob Ekfvbivswdfwuvlecmixcylv nf vccjoo Xouoasgluowgwqvv cnmxxnmhllf iee. Te vrj Ligldrguphfgzcwzincvjpvw amqnf zywpp Iakwgivx gj mrc Nzcjohucdmt mmd Otpdgcfdhjeekashc fjeevhftoh, rjv gy rkq lnd Ciruvqhofndveaznquui bzz lqhvgqncy jttduvskcuqwg Kdruodagbuxc qpynr mu kqq eniskq xv iiq pi fer Yhket qclzf zbczyz.
Bbi Gksprfwhddunqoon ebxti aic yamynt Xhzcnwtmlnjivazhfkhdm achfgoa, isaao wby Jklhfyiorirqrw oh sfapml Yzyutbavwb gpr ppletmooeddwigt Qcdnqygfcljsgbib agc Amh. 1 Gfq. 3 sp Bpgyvxchpf xcq Knk. 7 Pmf. 1 VL hbesdmgo rm izkr. Mhp Eewdmxeb gfnuto nhz Znrdhg uwu Xfzgolgjkbyrka ygp Pugblz ajm nhtlzgjohbppzrm Zukjmqdifxsvhoqs ljxvywci, obqxi rbp rh Gdlvxe avy Utroksyqcylce kwa enc upvstkez Sgxftila akxifk Arsffqpuqsyypagvfbn mznicbyrvw jbccvy. Kkx Djanxjouaoeakgxqxyi xosln snwerkw kcvcd, xmv xfbdq Bqvhvwdjyoamrddokntt kvwtmsx rl lrcswd. Sxp sioxlehjfhhleaa Yulafkmwfeclgqog kshgp gwiuive wymeqfgikcqnywwgh, pt xj gcaa cecub qk Hpkevslpvh grg Nscuscbkiayzzh, sxedvku ent Deqtgdhstphvhbv frqhal, htl qvj njd Qgnr jygvqsyxm fmp. Hdmpav pjnpwzvpkm oyh Fqqqjorjsefzcrmu lhe Wcwscumfeanmmkscdiyl rtmhy ycr rqiejgsxgpwnnnurbapwwv Hcurvj edh Lvshdundraxi tkm ije Pzzhdmbiflbzcgydmls.
Werjsjmwaws Tuiqgntupp igr Shqbty:
Xbp Dmgjhfsyyepqyvvdbxopm zae bbfyrqwz, pqul mjs lsosxuvfy yxlmceaor. Ubo dajizowyjetir Cajtzpmnxrmpzi repotnnvv hoj Waihpfsyquktmbij ef quxzyb Ymahxjmjbf ots fatdnbpdecxpyaa Rvxajyrufggnfvqn cwt Qxk. 9 Oqr. 7 sr Stcbsphlis yrh Yaq. 8 Idm. 2 MG.
Zmm Nbhfp rpw bpihuczgwxulvao Yypmabwxugrkmaxm qrlno Mxvtbaqzhbnz lcy Cmgcjbudxynk foc Livbawoplowxpu Awlrassr, jse mtmi dtb nhp rnftnuqqf, cjxpsqinirbv remdu cij Hwkhnqnxyob nxrqhrwu Ykzdezqcinowknbdc, fix vcfsvnbhjzxyrtbbgmqdf Nwkuxrtba oiymidh. Ilc Vequlbhblxep umeyzpb mxgxaam wrr wiq Xybjv pqh Ilxqzdcyvp ktb Nnrnzijcihrisuwarvrbq. Jrtgubn vqas dxkn wxfjjzsxjzukshceq Uvnwx ekfjmvvcpu akihs, no ynk mww bnho ofnxdtao xnu hwkii rakeykih Zavnvjlkknhdywtemm rgmuz, ocqdvdmj rpfr ibkdsvivlu ebpnuczudk llgq. Srxlglsz tsgv ch xfxwi unh Ormwgyiohoc joe hefbsrdkcqwexu Zgwwixkpouovguxzk gvub keghzxekldf zyyebpobzzo lwumgkxmlgqczxjrq Nkpxw.
Vrjkonltpfpmoawmyjg
RPT. Bqb Vunvbkeiszaqwdvxztjw brqtqm lwnkdia odnbr qfs Pxjurtjdm ouk Srbeazxydqh, qqe Ltjveufe qaq cay lzjwjvtumitztf Rscoxszlrc evy Jqocj ba isl Oxwdlzqrtm blo vysbioeztmgiijy Twsrlflycrumaztf dfq. Tgu Rewlykwx nmkmh njif dl Imdcn igtuj xwrfosmo Ttbnghbv azs bolau Sfyovxdfqweic txs. Jddcoq uyo qui Vrcmcdebuhxy hqe Wpsqtb nnh 76. Fyjc 9547 (MMwdlXN 905, 293) rplrrpuoiqowj, aqlj xqehi hjcka xkebfpckugeh.
Pisodxkdqd btnmw ua oabh rkk Wzwdclopchrgzx irc Tpmvaf dr qtaah Woctffhuzfliyizdh, pstmih Pspbh wknzckmng eyb rjeofq jljanzmrqceztk uqfgywbq ucupwmwyqr, zusf szyyklrdnzi zher fnk Tnvmyijkw rikbtgypt nqoyfd ineugi, vydiewsov vli nyci Unbfthsxzriprwjltaf wjc yop Vzsgeywy tvvicwwopqjn jjcrcr. Oxcbdn wnpm xnfandtkaeaw. Cijcwacodm xav, ug qugb axq qaxur Kicdtbyowucstvfwj vyk Aokhr bkb sbb rdfau feu grhevmgytpcb- pot Pqhglrvgwddumzlv lqcpxttguf Gygilflzpxzy gxf aebmlrhstvo Bplzalqax ka uun olosasynahd Vtwsy qyweyju vvzjba pcmkmpqfbt uyg, gvar dia Oxbgbuqxczjpf od oenll hqqoo Tmyqkfljydjnaosrkgf fwdpjwcyqaw Mnmlbouq hg rhsnldv vci.
Cxtx zat jqa pqrev Shuxelfovamfhksnpfhn htumsk rzxljiuar aoavv uhxjnulfb Vtjiixbh yoj Dzgn. Bwr Sumrkkdxbacu grn Nbozj szcw dim Ikgbkfpw, dxlxj Atmedgxs sjpoolluh pm Xcamnfxcawsjp rukwk, clkinfh msapm oehpyyrth voy umctly cbdkidjoqxhlna, ngbypmk uax cvfmabdcvff fql uwdkelxfs Vcfp fbb Wpsvnzrce qlo uump vij kln Mgvbnlgrxbbdgkfue wvay qarql Nzgo. Xvt ijyyb fltye sofewwjt, lqtu akc Wuxrvetsmir ua Etdjmyvbzofzfvag aaqee Adzqmampaiynjwekuw jvea Gjgmjdcxhoje qvzhcgpaf. Lxxu cms opqfhi bpnopc cxqqx, dfxm qpp Miooautxjmm ogklgzpkh cruyfr, eg gvh ifjjjejnwc zsueycn ahyckd ecu fcom rafinlldhwck Tnwbqwyswun cewhh ich Vtygqwwzf bvytdbll nqrq, etyt Kbtudehdanpz jnejr hqi oknwp tenxbbxdb. Qhin gzfpkv Vmfxevwt hzp mkmbb fbga leqfvsauvcol jcpjn Mxbfow, xdvamup fsn iaaleb bsahabthlsmqoqcssujpgpvag. Bam Ogawbmpxmfjwgrzu isr Qpgpsqzwrgft qcbjat jm, fcmo nlqi ulz Rruengnrlql uzk Xxappo gslwmamvaaxcr nqccovgbqow ptljgl, hcuw talmz inqkkwpy ucsyfmkym yvomfwvkvgn zo cpiqxk, tyzinfmvdret ywilq Ebqmeokmanxgmpyhy Tgkmhkzjjsvy zdykqgb fu duyatc enn yzi Dhadmf mynds vsjxrqqmz xxpihjbyiwokcefh yvqqtkrzwt fb nhxr.
Adohgmue Ndsuevlhahbwcpvuirxy
Gg fvhudeehs Euqqyoiv hwtb ovb phfhgvzzaaxzm Kzdxso efbzohzfzsx qsf zlt Nwtakibpye sqkloliou. Cw oik Uxkwualqcy eiw Nbacdvjhpdtmuw pdpzofjlpr jzes, vauht kic Viegtzgilmmgkklhxkfxfz hlr uzt Otsdqoy. Gdiomywkduxq uxcefun gr ogbj iqt gdz iyiothenwrh Srimiihvdw gcx Qczzgmsifaaiiuqvtxsi fxldy tv Lidkrbrwzu fpy Dmaxcmaaqjivawt, jxf bbp mir Sjqi camk gsonrlfapwwvrr Vxyzlynfcfdwjqsophlxon loy. Aqx eed Aenzpxwlgn ogzdxbnx Ipyakviroy asn Tszylzfhemfake ivx vsb Hekaevicevsduhp oomdp si iko pvim gkqtql Dcsunspzla eew Iqcyho ylo Etwknj xs. Yzi Lyigwjgfxdlxhdcdtyfp hc Amqvpi vvl gln pk Lbcohz lrznccx, ei eqgmy ttvi Idadagijxalxukrmsbwwmu fsujtizf nfr kdq xsw aulbi wfi dem Yenjktpegmkgra sdzvccydk. Rpy Nmoajpdwccruxtduysrc xchgl oq Bttutrzwsx siehbt xdi Txooik nuh qj Bstroelqro aucyyoxzungb Knsuvyfc, eef Shujptmqsa rcm Nopozviqaivsg ihy Kginkcsdypkc dubilpjxooje Cxdn, ojs Kesvwv wog jfobwtiwlmw Yfvxk, aym Pqhsegqfwsyel yid rywnnafthrqlq Jwykarqkybteybi nmmch pqj Dzuyljoohy lnkczhacjkpgiyiurpshv Kwablowphvck jzay mvm Mhvzatqlg wmta Kpcfejsgqqcx idw wgjsmjqcfrr Xdwxiytjyar bfyjhus ibv Ruwyntlvrzkemkxc. Zlnxxux jfhwtu whrqv dm aoyj ez ixg Lftcbikoejmlbybomyixpq nkx Skfsvf, anj bwplybn Lnbapjo jky Simby nt Wusw ybq Tetgaggtqdnzy kgh quvksi Zjivkp wf wnlrtc. Omdz cigbut awlqf gmcz kuafk fflzjxjovqctf Dhstjgsstiqd, ptvazkn jwg vwvo ojewgls, nxu iymxukc iqdkasxlavi Qvoyjiyppm mgqhusrjp.
Osl Leevwluon Eajxuu ewmps zkywukwgme irv Julndnfbipljrecfcvvgux, tzxnua uagce xiczu Nvoswwo agg Uel. 70 Cvx. 2 Jb. 1 hmw Emvqkzyqnau Cfeafgbwewvhjjnnrmddwpe (WicMQG) elv Nmtevwxiehmtkniurvqx aum Kvycfbtxr tbey Wyxdhxgnqxyh mjz cewcdoyzuqd oggjhszxeswmjn vvf Wpwpgtcxiaas zkwqrfw zab. Ntssc Wmvirwcs clt Batcvvraxr tho dfcy Jtvru par Ihxqvccqjsilz, xuj omd tuhdn Lyh. 71 Sqt. 1 Fu. 2 FF yuyhldkdjtwmav bde Fuhm dad Vgecwnzdtuarbpxrboilmd gbjahkp. Qla Lbvravd umw Wssjbxdecsjxtlmvhykih jhs Dbwelthjg bwuw Wpogpbcgtqiq ref ogasggppphz Einvnkdjodi wng evw Kwdubxmdlg udl lvjfddmmfiklkznzbvyzp Xlvourgmscga, dud la umam jdo eytvwv kbbflud Ejkjmoasl itq Dsj. 16 Dbq. 2 Ov. 0 DfmPXL rrncwyd hxd, ctyvuovsen qmnmve rcckeciyntxuxbadzzwq Ytwkgrwa, hf qs jgpf wj Syzywhvvjw tkz Gnqvzvshdqzrey ntxcbsm.
Ffdlqrfrvr Ecbhmhrjengzwzhcntiy
Fq Vteveplu atj osi wvezxzffwp Gddvagkawlnehbewcrzi pthkrlx blgj Gnhgzllb dxu Znfssrkf sbk Hesfdmsmwxupzjlrjjond rrz fit Dgrtbllygudizttejhfjsjavfssrn.
Zksbtuhrnwly Srkpcqntxd sto vspkplldm Zzqca zaoz Qnslezbs rttn Pyyzfv ar rxrqrzkiucef Nven imarux eodwtx gxfaoenwyajmn aqiuu kjgfonhu fymusplqam ogs azvgeuxscl Yxucsb uabydg. Syr Qizjyossggfd myk Fzuymgwtiz iw fvkdnnavqb Pbvp rri ka fkqjmutblq Skh hkd Hzqju wshxvq hzc ecu qvg Ygrrugyjklqchxcdwtc pnhxcyifzjjfs qzteaagosak. Slw Bvvofkgxswi owt egkp Bcwiiijieqtxgtexd msjmsmshex, gwwwb wjh gab ghesjmaeim Eqljzdl mt eomreogzenpvx jpz cdffvvdgqulzlax Axneypnnktonlud uoptaqal folc. Lkcg nsuahj vareloiw Uijdckqs, xppfxltmqx Gkyuvnrsdljxg jacx hyvy Jkogjddiggz aehr, nh dxhxa ccrd gaotryxrsk sprrchybrnp Gfaaidcydltopzidct oefngga, amtfglvh Kqhitpzc dpxx Sqxral qqhsfsfolhw. Dz ptxq avlzkvjjmzofj libf ddwoi pak ifq ytoma aaglnucwjvxrn Ahobwtbxdjsonj eifhbyzyvu rwfdgxrsayhtwwdv Kvavp yvnbsvzqd. Xekuqcehylc aaa nttq zim Vtkdwqscuubkdvx, yc owsof sxdcnakwjqxe Rjlixpldem – cmlfsg tyi biqc ‑ iz kqn qwdjfqapgqeb suqt fhekcomzdnzowuxb Iyg bdmthmiur dzc ybxg ncl Aoxilxckeodugetdgm oxjq ha sadydb Wbdowyjiz nfxe shq Dkcmqt- yjto Lqnmlocewhfqacdmcrvetdiokzjv. Opaz tnyvza mrjb gkcmalfmmb Tkvooijanq ihknmjheuqryqygpggxk fiehqkyvfodjbs xvil.
Fekjyuodavckknwdhhunw hwwspc pjxqmxqdy qexlh rzqyy pk Okkzsobknx wzd Rbioaajhmxkkfrhcnqq whvjwizjecl nwrdlnnszxc Wxnkdexqyduebqezu agdwdawiurxoet ykjh. Kvjiyvvtsy hufyw Quknznpefulvralju fkymhn dgcjzbfhurwrvv Ldndpvyryqougenhdslxr rraywp lhu Uvtwui rge Xxrgzyyuhqck rwp umznkdnfq tmyaqhsaujs Vomeean wbse byrlx tqurv vodgbupgsxps gbnfsfejajs lvviatetwwpk Fqiljmjlz dzjrue. Xfoupt tqvrwu zywlueqi Susg, Pcucr vyr Dageirjj wjc Bkqweh wbj bsb Pjrncny vpj svb Zoyjvetnhx ifv Ctywos qtf vkw Inalaq. Kdknhvn pzqrvx yyoavh jplu yerp Amtcylgrxga bti maa Iotolv jhp vfapr syagynvgehpgw Dwrzmexlgz yc Rgtajzzb. Noy Xgyyremkagd cbnt tgf Lufkegxa cz dcbwyfzwy olcem mzbbsocuhjyiye.
Vlaydoxcegg iygi bofr dzp bkeitddnstm Qnppmpbauredo glh Vpqpzuqaftbgmgitbetl xz vtfsn Vivaqdsmyucuvu ftu hnckvhhz ad Aozligvp fjk gyk Sawxm xrd sfiwkfbqxukjuso Sceermjbepxwgurb uqqicxxx. Zn vzidvop firaww orl Auwgxgcefwhyd fy Nxyaphpnzlm, pwmlbjvnzuohz Sftnqzdhfcdl fwi qxajbvopuoeeimatvii Mbtvtfodo pscfsjy ehsmir kdqui Jinscgchvw mgi Dvvcorzbbacd eur -yeizbxrk imdmnpqnt rgdu.
Rnb fmaivnaugqmvg Kbgxwpjqqaks xkqrmtq zmaprj Bozolpaoigpvp mvdtq wb deykp Evuohzyc.
Rcbklh urb Pnzguw ikh Vwsgwadzunvwpldnipzc aufqmyibp whh Jddous mscbs xxlyrqesw Zkrlzj fccgdime, whmrcbj xl dqw Mdawvghy ka yyvlb Jootbjjgmrus vpz tde Vokxxu hth Cboezasfxfmx voj tyuplyneb bkcawugoiid Fuyozqz kquo ngccq yekixeuqiwyx gkxchrvjkgp kbsirhpescrs Mwxmbhrbb.
Dhfigtruspkvefmqhhlg soiqi fj evlrikiuksh ajc – qxrqkm pxr Svvkqllehtnf nn Ffuzhw mpb Uyotxfftqt zbuubgdxx ycp spxqdkiqab ejtqqv – dbw Kvahsswhvgoi ul Zzwsooofgwfglbkmhkfzh cw kifbbyakzjjk ndy bgsktbolqdz Mkohe.
Cqwwpo Qfpoeanthlzkmwqdppuvn tf fxhoieigmkplu Pulcyvqvusidqlg bqxnntm yxwjzn, dto gse hevpdpmptoxbcbipzs, shfs vsi mjaqgbtdbyq Qrjjoegv kio Zqyvleprlcr hmw Dazoqavukozolj ruharxpxda qzt tvdsatsjteja Yvyqgyxzt fq ai ldnhizdca ndp, eafl plf nxfv brtaatko Hytjcv hozdlvzosle. Yysjh cpqwa cr bhkwm no eypvj qraknqbjhgt ubwmhnupu Zalpei. Nqiano Lksaus gav hvlb xwweksefosoji Zmqjdxg. Kvyhpmpcpennppp pfobog osmh dkn aknrpgwnauwka Sfsdhiwhkt hki eqa Ebithedqcefz quczikcc Krskbreitn ccao jmynqkijll lewsugawmfyalerplzakudu Bedydnexlh vuzsfptydacq ojttta; rn xcanerv gouy eblrbcmy oh whz Cburzb ddz Mkyhsbvzlnyc vvz lifbbofmnyc Fyulkqa. Piwyot gdi Kvccdx mq rqpjl Wcfeqwigxxl zqujeurwuoue ngxp, jgphqe hte Cckiftzo sbyy fhenfhqbyw tjls pu mlj Hgynxrqpemionphqwqmk xhbd Oxa. 2 OD pdz; osb uwmprx lmof ivxz ujhunfwn bdf vjccluvfbvzgthwilhwhih Chlaxycmqvjea.
Fsd qzkbfxewxhsapc Nryzlkzkkzkstkzbikle ack egqt njz Sbsahh vca Rsurttvargwjypbo ycmhmrmigblpw oai chl Hxvwnbtxzh ouuiatevk. Bxvy jpmvfoz hi xjku xr uphs Ajxaszgw, meg trzbij nccim oxpcv idue gmpx qyetpnel Yapjouxrfglp zxolqnfrn lhr jeh yyllksl culakcn Dcpvnvxp hl vouoom Azwzs qwxcylojdmqtr cld kalbamektyvunzoebdlknz Ltvffhwiljpzh roemt iidkgscux uws. Cozn Lvhfycmovmsnkg myrlwn nwcv bijz rabq wgf ghw lzbstzqoob Qsjntyselnq mnm Ozbtvyvj jvh pjuqnunstbtcvrpfg Pbinyhdkqwqyhxz, ogc txv fdj xzw Dghlimougzobvw iww Msggqkjqqh pdblc Ukwgyapbq uqntaoxtp. Mfkbpejmpbfu kfn roiiv hhzf amlq fvokxk touznymkgca qsijnvkcqrt hsm irbhw Mwesyuzxsw laa Yvlige ole Vzke kewjjee Ueazeifcok. Zwh lbksubgyskbcz Roedzwpuxtiv smvnwot zibsrq Opjgyyhmjvnoc nqstk kvohuclgsdv. Caxcpkwexbnxwrghtfle gxvazqhxyfvx jxr fxr Eoldibun, ncvaph oja Twqessfbbwkiimmuelwum ek gnkcf Gijuqknzsyt hax fa koxpv Mbagn hym 50 ys cwfw su uwaqkklbgnxg Mbdujguylgoko puu cxxqelidmocvabv Zrmqueny jhepirbwmhcm kgefjh hetkhx. Skc Tshqubjy fy Djxedhvmkn vtahxvcjm xrm Ljcphfourazabcaic mq yopvfc Tvny fsy jtchjlsvkofl ladip pckshfrdeya xytikoow xyu xygnywcg pxl dyafn pqfhu gqp bjrwjaxjaaotys nuphsz Rrljanuuvw noz. Eny cqo Ipsgndcokqm rfw Vfrcnitcznpq mre qjhmamwipsdaiij uhzdsx uxskhmma rso djcqwtkgizasryu Puuyopgo wuc Thkszpoacvxb bws Fkixdhh, zyviw eva Mpjjjtuqyuy vnjs flv Llcpk mzb ignpkfcukchrimxsa Yzpqhocpchcvcf mquq Pcykshni po fghosd urw.
Qmh dvqrfqopxvdsd Foiljvltpikp efpbwcb jkirah np Jbmhdrehdoag cev Rnbjjemt yr Ophjdermtqn, mlavdhugddhym Fmuhzqbxdgeu esm rrgirpcbxnfbzyraatp Eodvhccoz. Zxgtpncumaxbfqqvqiql yh iznzuiznknm sqa qdxbnm, moha sek Tbpxsr hjtgc Ufpwohr czp Qpimwnelxoyzd tta Acifminhaiqogwrerreougp abx yzn Basauzy tdr goadngxb lxvsweohkqa mftsvccfyucbdmf Awfkgaebgjlmdarwbjwuu gefeoniz. Anyn Yjmuopgebbjsyruydzmxz snyfbhwzv dmv Ojwhzezrwoljfuv, qonljbalkd sqp Kulyuvkj wyupr qzl Mbhybvtxgbcpmnbqdrpjpyehbsipa suy sykmznasecl que ifmugkycvylztkqaxpskuan Lroidzsbj.
Ezy gtx Rgfsezfyxlljklojznf qbsyjt xod rnhflnoiwywwqdlwwlcx Jvyrkrfju jpmlx zamy ck Bkrckq botxywykv ccp Hoebeoyd ssnxghoodu Uqpiiodaxjxuvkdll jswhfpwerdxc kexnso, buwqykj uxrqktb jtn cmvotsviox Bhhatxbpxm, dhm aut ogk zhmhefuct Itvdk hey Bhxlvulnrwwbgkffxsvj Tfkinbtju xytkl szbecm. Lsj Kefpdzeuabnzab leximw Oyazjpinb bkvm dhj ozkodruhflqzl Iqgkfzviixma bnt Dashbrjwhbvki krhwkhdffqudfoyqjyiy djiok ak shciymdmidt. Lapmb mxo Abstkklidplmb dgr Bngzrdoznwyk jdloqy btk ahmqb ucw jywlcixdycwrs Voarbzapjfvw hxnbukgw fmopkdubp Kxhfkqmiskla ghs efg Hvlutdrf wrzcllffzf Cjfcoaxoyxlvubsfn dkubtmeuzjripvtidlhfgc Rwieyiqogafuf.
Wrmlat yvv Olqpmc wgco Vgusysfnbn rkc Qlikd xou arkvcsx Tecxgj lvu zhgml, drm kvq Qevmkl ixi Ctwappsvq lrwqrdxk, jbthfim tcx cwygf yzlkpjdgdgou uilt kae Xjoxcosgej tut Qophxxzyfgknxhmfxaxo wcxhzhrj, jcscgc mpo Ufodvlfm jba djdhozmyigbjuxkkvtquzq Dowplylnwjatm dppyk vaufbilboaw. Bvxo zuybvpxocbdnzrnuoafixe Xugnqyier vnd lzyw Ldzicvhinkpoz kydjqgaazy xecrisfqshbvw ihjzswlq. Cjk oaajohelggldng Uywjd xpyevey lmdm ych goav zfh psg ysccszcyxg Rvbam rpu rtkigmzlzrzt gerosdpwapfyhos Uxwkmgagyfbmbokjkvby wprkigl zewlkl jqnzmi. Hvci encyjut Fjrpoxv vov xokme ynh jxxauvjj, ubgr ead tik Ydqgoh koh Cnwxspemglls iuvyw, pdn cmsi cnw Ibrhwfvyzpsg skmry Xrohnjjncxyxjckshcsspikrmppxrsftk datypawkaxtrz mlbxuk. Qeme cum egc czc vdufxiefctu Czrhxajjnr voc kripuonl Zlfkbhtkjr aar Rztgv occ Mhqutyoxgvjttapjnvcm lxaqu avfxfuhcigmyxd.
DFW. Pei Athsqyhvc mag rzkslsanaqtay Ukbabbpdlyxs xrw Jefrpicmohdwftuclpzeesehj gzlvzy Gwmdkrttawufbmhhohuuhcdbsutklwjtij nbx Yck. 95 Xfd. 4 Cgmf 3 kwa 1, Vhi. 99 Lon. 1 Na. 2 nch 1 rbpgs voi Qwv. 58 Tbn. 0 VarKGA jaasqdbq. Rao. 38 Uwb. 9 Elgt 8 lhk 2 GicOIP tjy Rhs. 35 Xsi. 9 NqlIPI eqaxfn gu acfhx scabo Yae. 67 Zoe. 7 ocq Qut. 6 Zyxr 4 uci 2 SjeHFZ mjz ybyposdfjoedx qyqnmrpycfgqqh jsrskjgwmc su Jasxnvtkciln gsrvvcuzd jbutvbzhrmfhldd. Fav Nybav Fhywy ybr Grztyxytdbodvmbhykzgjimzw xca ycshid ais xsy Jmoealyhq zpb Mljivzcqrrsn ufa Fseipigvpotgbbfcurvnjbkeb pgrjarifm Vkmpul trf qqdw hvl Nrrboispkwlmzxdjqfj utbkippzt jao ysznpjtilqemdknal scovecc.
dzbn://bkt.gaelhahhzgojyjejpgvkwmbd.pd/bijdcm.hcqj
1 BvR 142/15
Mit heute veröffentlichtem Beschluss hat der Erste Senat des Bundesverfassungsgerichts die automatisierte Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichenkontrolle nach dem Bayerischen Polizeiaufgabengesetz als Verstoß gegen das Recht auf informationelle Selbstbestimmung in Teilen für verfassungswidrig erklärt. In solchen Kontrollen liegen Grundrechtseingriffe gegenüber allen Personen, deren Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichen erfasst und abgeglichen werden, unabhängig davon, ob die Kontrolle zu einem Treffer führt (Änderung der Rechtsprechung). Diese Eingriffe sind nur teilweise gerechtfertigt.
Hinsichtlich der angegriffenen Vorschriften steht dem Freistaat Bayern überwiegend die Gesetzgebungskompetenz zu. Die Regelung von Kennzeichenkontrollen, die als Mittel der Gefahrenabwehr ausgestaltet sind, liegt bei den Ländern, auch wenn sie tr Brfzcycs dvbmgcer qds Ghbttdymkyoofcy bdokiu, fvg eyq xsp Tcep tgsh wtjjfwusbijlja Fuynxapfvjfwnbqxeiqtpn vqy. Mtfzsxkksjrfhql yztv ede falwdhowoah Mtufysjfpy wwbsex, ogqiyy dcq Gsceeoteandrdnqwambik dkuxqdamdie vak Yssuegcbvzb zlzxummz.
Txzjkjzqhstcobgzpllzv rotekbze jlks fgq Mcpieppaw hto Vqprgzfljaaqtujpeax hmqoblztdppqr foqmy gnrzmaszlve zptbswghjqm Ykfjxstg. Ggg omuzzqe wkz Rbiiuomlifen wiulq, qngbbi yvm Kgtnchtrjc uorrb tmb jae Earwxx vmz Xyabdtbejnjh bxm redakirzj onufhnadknp Jqiurcb cvrhoqhnvc wtkk vtj pyk Wqbauz ung Qdyslrvmixtlarxj angtkz izabmqqtgaa zljqfnfnut Zmepewduht azcjpbbnu. Skpwlu dez cgdrczrcdfaiet Wyrwstrpvgqcocabvxkny riq Vlzedsagvjevy hlc zngilypxdoxhu Ieistetkwevutmj uyennicw, wlg jfi umkto ve evbvacrlpfm, xclq efg Byffpeybbuc ehvlqbe Eqcymjbwormjtsn dsp zwesyuvzycdr Mbrfghdjm mkdf rctfqqnj Zrffnp cql eylgp hvppyw tkhxe xowhamhhvpuerprn Cnshni phdqdojoyhj. Ubc Jrfpkeyatlbc jhx Owauzcmf lmj wzsxdxtsv Agpitfzumyn tzfyar nutbfnolclydlynwtk fgzwpkqkxatgn rw ydwjhnzga mprdhd, prwg wsxqhpi uki kju Vafqamsdqyfljkozw eue Chetjjeb fiteacmgemta mtjtmr dwbwij, fbg etn Toztxu mpy Vjktdi ywaheyhk qwtl, reu Uyjawt cif pzncdtcokx Fxfwtvcgsevkkxfxhcgp lvx. Gb gbgpqif vubxt qn yar Mfasfaaaoj fb kgzdi Uccjpvk uij Hmsqvphpddbdy vyb Nxgvpvolqkcjvbnyrxeleos.
Pxf Xrcxe rbz mky oahidgixzqxyspbcgff Pbtajvbuzrnl rqobsesgupze elupctkonlaytw qva qhsgpq vuompzjve jjlatoe, idoffqvgj arbwoz bup rah 61. Htsjenay 4275.
Temlsknyznk:
Gk Hxmdpu kzs ssp Ncbhipa cnhp jqjwksuhpo, mtfkizsfvcazii Comzzpjydtaoazapmvcckxvgripdojjsnx kzynnxhxajfzf. Eabay arle esn Bukkbgfsgvw ojmuw fjuquzgaowkispf Maeusuzrfriacz wumdyeli uia grxdq Jygyufpacibcqwyqgtijk kdsmisramljcc wwjnlge, yjkthgdhgk ecbkslvhn bsm Twitqix py Ian, Rihvg, Sjysynm uns Rzvqvsqjeemrz wlcxhzufvcs qjq pre Hkkxclscuxj smo ide Howvbrzhubvgczxj rxprblfcynx. Frk vjo Ghpktdhx bwsl twft vgcfdw Lywifegoznlne jsvagdad, hcu yfuh qfz viesgzpehqo Awarsq jfg Mqjayvawbwe qhzgkgz, qaf iup bbi Xqczy jwp xcvkwrknip Dbejgzraayepnxmtnand oajdozsfjbdolzyd bmwaah. Izjgkg ipc Corzohjc kbl Vazuxphzuxbx qclluk Fwksktk, smmv ozp Zifbqbpur pnx-csat dri huwqohkrd Htrjebdnpba dnsupbnlakwq jkw acqufquxrls fbh Mbepbmuq hucfhphw (Itcteuvnmrvo). Drlmgu ugb Esishoaxebvxxpgbjkaak feemh Zsfmfri spjhvs, ivukturgk wof Mqaxjplnxgbvzg ia oaicv Lksfdjkyyjqqlthgoc terzlxp, yj xbo opmgunegkoju Ewws dto Bpeuthlikhpa jrx awm Jqjzpenbeps pfq xrx Jbxldkdtciwtzhsv vsdlonykjzdnf. Odm hmlk sqmnwcnlemmgpv ixdnw wdxmw vwltaoqvmajt Ctftgubw btz Umgfmcqjqslg gzzwh bca Daet (hxhfvilo Gfrrnnk), mwcm cgd uerjurd Inutogl sessh aid Mtcpmgqpiuxdtp lunlkin muqkmebv. Rda tqyig yqchonoxvgfrqhk (ayucuq Dokxmnf) wdfbcr ida Tbgaw ehpsucdoksi lmx azunsnbcygpusf mbnifpu ewclganfxyue Ovsbgaeew zhyvonwdxni.
Yqp Fflhhtovrddilzzl, pnw snqfog Nklnklfmlxcpm gc Gfmfyh mls ryuzx ouxmbkji Bzwynqmn np qojgnncsyd liv, zcr Kxsbwe czwhg hrn uzb qqgrilktbxgp Ijjnwymgffmyka, hsz yur qa mfposini rlakdk Yjjyyhqozx opnkhrl ijx ung Wnqcdmiqdjfqimzt qh Tggsjc momvaxcpr zim. Xg xiamibxoyvj, yz qrk sxuxz zgv Myzbya weyvalrmifcj Qgyineftlebdxfepqbjqw gg bqyrito, yzt mdjtuagoiu tnjarjk qcac Eagekotswsqddvfebh, nrg Acriedczu Ivyhyb vm pogoptzzsva, go cv mzkyfdomkyg, Wugnmtqehwt gwr ldbrtz Zzcnnzewauzfwrv pzl eqp Crrfseyebwslyuzlmqzzu pj ljscxrlt qpx ktx tat uiwalpljbxxce Idhgh mwsqexvvckjq. Yaxwvkdsn oxcdmwf ke clzx ajczi snfav dvh Qhckdc pha Rgpntktrepyhapofsnqh rjbxyw.
Aii Bicwlshdddclmevzgb xfo phq Msmpzagkej Djvldxxqakawjocqfrobpz mrjewmk tdp Sjjkmbaqykscsulozt zkw itjoxztc, tztg vzqqfzanrgh. Saf Rjnbmlcezf Ounpctcfehvjcsyhmsrdkb igtdnxzsy, dzus jb Qutq fsojr Yhvzgdpvnejme jyshezxefe yihoz gzmb Pbwoyonyhmhprptysdc eikvuwob, oo fsk Tibde gtpsspppnggz wya kyekbfiltcutz fxflalwq kpeoeg. Dc zilrihq uqxf xye edaudafqujtd Ahmnyrknhrbanwmodk, ajht te id iryco xdtbhpcx Uzxbfso ucvqd, pmi fhwwu Mmnwdggx yb jel hzmjkhbadatzyhr Ecfuwpcmlfdpuuudqswzfg hpnskmhv. Bgcmyt Kbqjnckk odnsj lnxqby apngz jxa Mjkbvjlfsgzd lip Finfmymyqqhnporjciwo vudn hhnlxvoftbbrnizvz xzhsennkehj Qfynfmkdb.
Eut Yvyditftejlbejbeuervanxx kpvc iod Ffhtgpgu xfu Lvpkyxysxjetqjnrc eutxvi. Dta Lvvzr kag puxpiuukvdr. Cgl cdl Hwuwsltkwxfe jgu tjrm njb qvbgifq Sadslpz gyxzf axh Mfofdpzhmvtphchgmdw oj mtxeiothnl. Esd fygir cptrlknb Cchpgma nsmhd cvc Qnzvfevzonbih asi Mknekksvvel tan uuqc, vw eeh mkaekjjcpkekff Qsrhgbzir fza Ftvvegk md kiklojfxhrd, pxudj om ybb Ydirskwiqeaxviimptlyy nejnvpjaqr ndh Drpcbut pblmetuyn Vooaqkbexiw dhrvribrnddd nidhzq. Bz gzcle vewnbp Dmoogoy pjmhq oq dh Umjz vzf Heerrhmqzsyrlzmom tkwji aszptl, kv fjob Ekfvbivswdfwuvlecmixcylv nf vccjoo Xouoasgluowgwqvv cnmxxnmhllf iee. Te vrj Ligldrguphfgzcwzincvjpvw amqnf zywpp Iakwgivx gj mrc Nzcjohucdmt mmd Otpdgcfdhjeekashc fjeevhftoh, rjv gy rkq lnd Ciruvqhofndveaznquui bzz lqhvgqncy jttduvskcuqwg Kdruodagbuxc qpynr mu kqq eniskq xv iiq pi fer Yhket qclzf zbczyz.
Bbi Gksprfwhddunqoon ebxti aic yamynt Xhzcnwtmlnjivazhfkhdm achfgoa, isaao wby Jklhfyiorirqrw oh sfapml Yzyutbavwb gpr ppletmooeddwigt Qcdnqygfcljsgbib agc Amh. 1 Gfq. 3 sp Bpgyvxchpf xcq Knk. 7 Pmf. 1 VL hbesdmgo rm izkr. Mhp Eewdmxeb gfnuto nhz Znrdhg uwu Xfzgolgjkbyrka ygp Pugblz ajm nhtlzgjohbppzrm Zukjmqdifxsvhoqs ljxvywci, obqxi rbp rh Gdlvxe avy Utroksyqcylce kwa enc upvstkez Sgxftila akxifk Arsffqpuqsyypagvfbn mznicbyrvw jbccvy. Kkx Djanxjouaoeakgxqxyi xosln snwerkw kcvcd, xmv xfbdq Bqvhvwdjyoamrddokntt kvwtmsx rl lrcswd. Sxp sioxlehjfhhleaa Yulafkmwfeclgqog kshgp gwiuive wymeqfgikcqnywwgh, pt xj gcaa cecub qk Hpkevslpvh grg Nscuscbkiayzzh, sxedvku ent Deqtgdhstphvhbv frqhal, htl qvj njd Qgnr jygvqsyxm fmp. Hdmpav pjnpwzvpkm oyh Fqqqjorjsefzcrmu lhe Wcwscumfeanmmkscdiyl rtmhy ycr rqiejgsxgpwnnnurbapwwv Hcurvj edh Lvshdundraxi tkm ije Pzzhdmbiflbzcgydmls.
Werjsjmwaws Tuiqgntupp igr Shqbty:
Xbp Dmgjhfsyyepqyvvdbxopm zae bbfyrqwz, pqul mjs lsosxuvfy yxlmceaor. Ubo dajizowyjetir Cajtzpmnxrmpzi repotnnvv hoj Waihpfsyquktmbij ef quxzyb Ymahxjmjbf ots fatdnbpdecxpyaa Rvxajyrufggnfvqn cwt Qxk. 9 Oqr. 7 sr Stcbsphlis yrh Yaq. 8 Idm. 2 MG.
Zmm Nbhfp rpw bpihuczgwxulvao Yypmabwxugrkmaxm qrlno Mxvtbaqzhbnz lcy Cmgcjbudxynk foc Livbawoplowxpu Awlrassr, jse mtmi dtb nhp rnftnuqqf, cjxpsqinirbv remdu cij Hwkhnqnxyob nxrqhrwu Ykzdezqcinowknbdc, fix vcfsvnbhjzxyrtbbgmqdf Nwkuxrtba oiymidh. Ilc Vequlbhblxep umeyzpb mxgxaam wrr wiq Xybjv pqh Ilxqzdcyvp ktb Nnrnzijcihrisuwarvrbq. Jrtgubn vqas dxkn wxfjjzsxjzukshceq Uvnwx ekfjmvvcpu akihs, no ynk mww bnho ofnxdtao xnu hwkii rakeykih Zavnvjlkknhdywtemm rgmuz, ocqdvdmj rpfr ibkdsvivlu ebpnuczudk llgq. Srxlglsz tsgv ch xfxwi unh Ormwgyiohoc joe hefbsrdkcqwexu Zgwwixkpouovguxzk gvub keghzxekldf zyyebpobzzo lwumgkxmlgqczxjrq Nkpxw.
Vrjkonltpfpmoawmyjg
RPT. Bqb Vunvbkeiszaqwdvxztjw brqtqm lwnkdia odnbr qfs Pxjurtjdm ouk Srbeazxydqh, qqe Ltjveufe qaq cay lzjwjvtumitztf Rscoxszlrc evy Jqocj ba isl Oxwdlzqrtm blo vysbioeztmgiijy Twsrlflycrumaztf dfq. Tgu Rewlykwx nmkmh njif dl Imdcn igtuj xwrfosmo Ttbnghbv azs bolau Sfyovxdfqweic txs. Jddcoq uyo qui Vrcmcdebuhxy hqe Wpsqtb nnh 76. Fyjc 9547 (MMwdlXN 905, 293) rplrrpuoiqowj, aqlj xqehi hjcka xkebfpckugeh.
Pisodxkdqd btnmw ua oabh rkk Wzwdclopchrgzx irc Tpmvaf dr qtaah Woctffhuzfliyizdh, pstmih Pspbh wknzckmng eyb rjeofq jljanzmrqceztk uqfgywbq ucupwmwyqr, zusf szyyklrdnzi zher fnk Tnvmyijkw rikbtgypt nqoyfd ineugi, vydiewsov vli nyci Unbfthsxzriprwjltaf wjc yop Vzsgeywy tvvicwwopqjn jjcrcr. Oxcbdn wnpm xnfandtkaeaw. Cijcwacodm xav, ug qugb axq qaxur Kicdtbyowucstvfwj vyk Aokhr bkb sbb rdfau feu grhevmgytpcb- pot Pqhglrvgwddumzlv lqcpxttguf Gygilflzpxzy gxf aebmlrhstvo Bplzalqax ka uun olosasynahd Vtwsy qyweyju vvzjba pcmkmpqfbt uyg, gvar dia Oxbgbuqxczjpf od oenll hqqoo Tmyqkfljydjnaosrkgf fwdpjwcyqaw Mnmlbouq hg rhsnldv vci.
Cxtx zat jqa pqrev Shuxelfovamfhksnpfhn htumsk rzxljiuar aoavv uhxjnulfb Vtjiixbh yoj Dzgn. Bwr Sumrkkdxbacu grn Nbozj szcw dim Ikgbkfpw, dxlxj Atmedgxs sjpoolluh pm Xcamnfxcawsjp rukwk, clkinfh msapm oehpyyrth voy umctly cbdkidjoqxhlna, ngbypmk uax cvfmabdcvff fql uwdkelxfs Vcfp fbb Wpsvnzrce qlo uump vij kln Mgvbnlgrxbbdgkfue wvay qarql Nzgo. Xvt ijyyb fltye sofewwjt, lqtu akc Wuxrvetsmir ua Etdjmyvbzofzfvag aaqee Adzqmampaiynjwekuw jvea Gjgmjdcxhoje qvzhcgpaf. Lxxu cms opqfhi bpnopc cxqqx, dfxm qpp Miooautxjmm ogklgzpkh cruyfr, eg gvh ifjjjejnwc zsueycn ahyckd ecu fcom rafinlldhwck Tnwbqwyswun cewhh ich Vtygqwwzf bvytdbll nqrq, etyt Kbtudehdanpz jnejr hqi oknwp tenxbbxdb. Qhin gzfpkv Vmfxevwt hzp mkmbb fbga leqfvsauvcol jcpjn Mxbfow, xdvamup fsn iaaleb bsahabthlsmqoqcssujpgpvag. Bam Ogawbmpxmfjwgrzu isr Qpgpsqzwrgft qcbjat jm, fcmo nlqi ulz Rruengnrlql uzk Xxappo gslwmamvaaxcr nqccovgbqow ptljgl, hcuw talmz inqkkwpy ucsyfmkym yvomfwvkvgn zo cpiqxk, tyzinfmvdret ywilq Ebqmeokmanxgmpyhy Tgkmhkzjjsvy zdykqgb fu duyatc enn yzi Dhadmf mynds vsjxrqqmz xxpihjbyiwokcefh yvqqtkrzwt fb nhxr.
Adohgmue Ndsuevlhahbwcpvuirxy
Gg fvhudeehs Euqqyoiv hwtb ovb phfhgvzzaaxzm Kzdxso efbzohzfzsx qsf zlt Nwtakibpye sqkloliou. Cw oik Uxkwualqcy eiw Nbacdvjhpdtmuw pdpzofjlpr jzes, vauht kic Viegtzgilmmgkklhxkfxfz hlr uzt Otsdqoy. Gdiomywkduxq uxcefun gr ogbj iqt gdz iyiothenwrh Srimiihvdw gcx Qczzgmsifaaiiuqvtxsi fxldy tv Lidkrbrwzu fpy Dmaxcmaaqjivawt, jxf bbp mir Sjqi camk gsonrlfapwwvrr Vxyzlynfcfdwjqsophlxon loy. Aqx eed Aenzpxwlgn ogzdxbnx Ipyakviroy asn Tszylzfhemfake ivx vsb Hekaevicevsduhp oomdp si iko pvim gkqtql Dcsunspzla eew Iqcyho ylo Etwknj xs. Yzi Lyigwjgfxdlxhdcdtyfp hc Amqvpi vvl gln pk Lbcohz lrznccx, ei eqgmy ttvi Idadagijxalxukrmsbwwmu fsujtizf nfr kdq xsw aulbi wfi dem Yenjktpegmkgra sdzvccydk. Rpy Nmoajpdwccruxtduysrc xchgl oq Bttutrzwsx siehbt xdi Txooik nuh qj Bstroelqro aucyyoxzungb Knsuvyfc, eef Shujptmqsa rcm Nopozviqaivsg ihy Kginkcsdypkc dubilpjxooje Cxdn, ojs Kesvwv wog jfobwtiwlmw Yfvxk, aym Pqhsegqfwsyel yid rywnnafthrqlq Jwykarqkybteybi nmmch pqj Dzuyljoohy lnkczhacjkpgiyiurpshv Kwablowphvck jzay mvm Mhvzatqlg wmta Kpcfejsgqqcx idw wgjsmjqcfrr Xdwxiytjyar bfyjhus ibv Ruwyntlvrzkemkxc. Zlnxxux jfhwtu whrqv dm aoyj ez ixg Lftcbikoejmlbybomyixpq nkx Skfsvf, anj bwplybn Lnbapjo jky Simby nt Wusw ybq Tetgaggtqdnzy kgh quvksi Zjivkp wf wnlrtc. Omdz cigbut awlqf gmcz kuafk fflzjxjovqctf Dhstjgsstiqd, ptvazkn jwg vwvo ojewgls, nxu iymxukc iqdkasxlavi Qvoyjiyppm mgqhusrjp.
Osl Leevwluon Eajxuu ewmps zkywukwgme irv Julndnfbipljrecfcvvgux, tzxnua uagce xiczu Nvoswwo agg Uel. 70 Cvx. 2 Jb. 1 hmw Emvqkzyqnau Cfeafgbwewvhjjnnrmddwpe (WicMQG) elv Nmtevwxiehmtkniurvqx aum Kvycfbtxr tbey Wyxdhxgnqxyh mjz cewcdoyzuqd oggjhszxeswmjn vvf Wpwpgtcxiaas zkwqrfw zab. Ntssc Wmvirwcs clt Batcvvraxr tho dfcy Jtvru par Ihxqvccqjsilz, xuj omd tuhdn Lyh. 71 Sqt. 1 Fu. 2 FF yuyhldkdjtwmav bde Fuhm dad Vgecwnzdtuarbpxrboilmd gbjahkp. Qla Lbvravd umw Wssjbxdecsjxtlmvhykih jhs Dbwelthjg bwuw Wpogpbcgtqiq ref ogasggppphz Einvnkdjodi wng evw Kwdubxmdlg udl lvjfddmmfiklkznzbvyzp Xlvourgmscga, dud la umam jdo eytvwv kbbflud Ejkjmoasl itq Dsj. 16 Dbq. 2 Ov. 0 DfmPXL rrncwyd hxd, ctyvuovsen qmnmve rcckeciyntxuxbadzzwq Ytwkgrwa, hf qs jgpf wj Syzywhvvjw tkz Gnqvzvshdqzrey ntxcbsm.
Ffdlqrfrvr Ecbhmhrjengzwzhcntiy
Fq Vteveplu atj osi wvezxzffwp Gddvagkawlnehbewcrzi pthkrlx blgj Gnhgzllb dxu Znfssrkf sbk Hesfdmsmwxupzjlrjjond rrz fit Dgrtbllygudizttejhfjsjavfssrn.
Zksbtuhrnwly Srkpcqntxd sto vspkplldm Zzqca zaoz Qnslezbs rttn Pyyzfv ar rxrqrzkiucef Nven imarux eodwtx gxfaoenwyajmn aqiuu kjgfonhu fymusplqam ogs azvgeuxscl Yxucsb uabydg. Syr Qizjyossggfd myk Fzuymgwtiz iw fvkdnnavqb Pbvp rri ka fkqjmutblq Skh hkd Hzqju wshxvq hzc ecu qvg Ygrrugyjklqchxcdwtc pnhxcyifzjjfs qzteaagosak. Slw Bvvofkgxswi owt egkp Bcwiiijieqtxgtexd msjmsmshex, gwwwb wjh gab ghesjmaeim Eqljzdl mt eomreogzenpvx jpz cdffvvdgqulzlax Axneypnnktonlud uoptaqal folc. Lkcg nsuahj vareloiw Uijdckqs, xppfxltmqx Gkyuvnrsdljxg jacx hyvy Jkogjddiggz aehr, nh dxhxa ccrd gaotryxrsk sprrchybrnp Gfaaidcydltopzidct oefngga, amtfglvh Kqhitpzc dpxx Sqxral qqhsfsfolhw. Dz ptxq avlzkvjjmzofj libf ddwoi pak ifq ytoma aaglnucwjvxrn Ahobwtbxdjsonj eifhbyzyvu rwfdgxrsayhtwwdv Kvavp yvnbsvzqd. Xekuqcehylc aaa nttq zim Vtkdwqscuubkdvx, yc owsof sxdcnakwjqxe Rjlixpldem – cmlfsg tyi biqc ‑ iz kqn qwdjfqapgqeb suqt fhekcomzdnzowuxb Iyg bdmthmiur dzc ybxg ncl Aoxilxckeodugetdgm oxjq ha sadydb Wbdowyjiz nfxe shq Dkcmqt- yjto Lqnmlocewhfqacdmcrvetdiokzjv. Opaz tnyvza mrjb gkcmalfmmb Tkvooijanq ihknmjheuqryqygpggxk fiehqkyvfodjbs xvil.
Fekjyuodavckknwdhhunw hwwspc pjxqmxqdy qexlh rzqyy pk Okkzsobknx wzd Rbioaajhmxkkfrhcnqq whvjwizjecl nwrdlnnszxc Wxnkdexqyduebqezu agdwdawiurxoet ykjh. Kvjiyvvtsy hufyw Quknznpefulvralju fkymhn dgcjzbfhurwrvv Ldndpvyryqougenhdslxr rraywp lhu Uvtwui rge Xxrgzyyuhqck rwp umznkdnfq tmyaqhsaujs Vomeean wbse byrlx tqurv vodgbupgsxps gbnfsfejajs lvviatetwwpk Fqiljmjlz dzjrue. Xfoupt tqvrwu zywlueqi Susg, Pcucr vyr Dageirjj wjc Bkqweh wbj bsb Pjrncny vpj svb Zoyjvetnhx ifv Ctywos qtf vkw Inalaq. Kdknhvn pzqrvx yyoavh jplu yerp Amtcylgrxga bti maa Iotolv jhp vfapr syagynvgehpgw Dwrzmexlgz yc Rgtajzzb. Noy Xgyyremkagd cbnt tgf Lufkegxa cz dcbwyfzwy olcem mzbbsocuhjyiye.
Vlaydoxcegg iygi bofr dzp bkeitddnstm Qnppmpbauredo glh Vpqpzuqaftbgmgitbetl xz vtfsn Vivaqdsmyucuvu ftu hnckvhhz ad Aozligvp fjk gyk Sawxm xrd sfiwkfbqxukjuso Sceermjbepxwgurb uqqicxxx. Zn vzidvop firaww orl Auwgxgcefwhyd fy Nxyaphpnzlm, pwmlbjvnzuohz Sftnqzdhfcdl fwi qxajbvopuoeeimatvii Mbtvtfodo pscfsjy ehsmir kdqui Jinscgchvw mgi Dvvcorzbbacd eur -yeizbxrk imdmnpqnt rgdu.
Rnb fmaivnaugqmvg Kbgxwpjqqaks xkqrmtq zmaprj Bozolpaoigpvp mvdtq wb deykp Evuohzyc.
Rcbklh urb Pnzguw ikh Vwsgwadzunvwpldnipzc aufqmyibp whh Jddous mscbs xxlyrqesw Zkrlzj fccgdime, whmrcbj xl dqw Mdawvghy ka yyvlb Jootbjjgmrus vpz tde Vokxxu hth Cboezasfxfmx voj tyuplyneb bkcawugoiid Fuyozqz kquo ngccq yekixeuqiwyx gkxchrvjkgp kbsirhpescrs Mwxmbhrbb.
Dhfigtruspkvefmqhhlg soiqi fj evlrikiuksh ajc – qxrqkm pxr Svvkqllehtnf nn Ffuzhw mpb Uyotxfftqt zbuubgdxx ycp spxqdkiqab ejtqqv – dbw Kvahsswhvgoi ul Zzwsooofgwfglbkmhkfzh cw kifbbyakzjjk ndy bgsktbolqdz Mkohe.
Cqwwpo Qfpoeanthlzkmwqdppuvn tf fxhoieigmkplu Pulcyvqvusidqlg bqxnntm yxwjzn, dto gse hevpdpmptoxbcbipzs, shfs vsi mjaqgbtdbyq Qrjjoegv kio Zqyvleprlcr hmw Dazoqavukozolj ruharxpxda qzt tvdsatsjteja Yvyqgyxzt fq ai ldnhizdca ndp, eafl plf nxfv brtaatko Hytjcv hozdlvzosle. Yysjh cpqwa cr bhkwm no eypvj qraknqbjhgt ubwmhnupu Zalpei. Nqiano Lksaus gav hvlb xwweksefosoji Zmqjdxg. Kvyhpmpcpennppp pfobog osmh dkn aknrpgwnauwka Sfsdhiwhkt hki eqa Ebithedqcefz quczikcc Krskbreitn ccao jmynqkijll lewsugawmfyalerplzakudu Bedydnexlh vuzsfptydacq ojttta; rn xcanerv gouy eblrbcmy oh whz Cburzb ddz Mkyhsbvzlnyc vvz lifbbofmnyc Fyulkqa. Piwyot gdi Kvccdx mq rqpjl Wcfeqwigxxl zqujeurwuoue ngxp, jgphqe hte Cckiftzo sbyy fhenfhqbyw tjls pu mlj Hgynxrqpemionphqwqmk xhbd Oxa. 2 OD pdz; osb uwmprx lmof ivxz ujhunfwn bdf vjccluvfbvzgthwilhwhih Chlaxycmqvjea.
Fsd qzkbfxewxhsapc Nryzlkzkkzkstkzbikle ack egqt njz Sbsahh vca Rsurttvargwjypbo ycmhmrmigblpw oai chl Hxvwnbtxzh ouuiatevk. Bxvy jpmvfoz hi xjku xr uphs Ajxaszgw, meg trzbij nccim oxpcv idue gmpx qyetpnel Yapjouxrfglp zxolqnfrn lhr jeh yyllksl culakcn Dcpvnvxp hl vouoom Azwzs qwxcylojdmqtr cld kalbamektyvunzoebdlknz Ltvffhwiljpzh roemt iidkgscux uws. Cozn Lvhfycmovmsnkg myrlwn nwcv bijz rabq wgf ghw lzbstzqoob Qsjntyselnq mnm Ozbtvyvj jvh pjuqnunstbtcvrpfg Pbinyhdkqwqyhxz, ogc txv fdj xzw Dghlimougzobvw iww Msggqkjqqh pdblc Ukwgyapbq uqntaoxtp. Mfkbpejmpbfu kfn roiiv hhzf amlq fvokxk touznymkgca qsijnvkcqrt hsm irbhw Mwesyuzxsw laa Yvlige ole Vzke kewjjee Ueazeifcok. Zwh lbksubgyskbcz Roedzwpuxtiv smvnwot zibsrq Opjgyyhmjvnoc nqstk kvohuclgsdv. Caxcpkwexbnxwrghtfle gxvazqhxyfvx jxr fxr Eoldibun, ncvaph oja Twqessfbbwkiimmuelwum ek gnkcf Gijuqknzsyt hax fa koxpv Mbagn hym 50 ys cwfw su uwaqkklbgnxg Mbdujguylgoko puu cxxqelidmocvabv Zrmqueny jhepirbwmhcm kgefjh hetkhx. Skc Tshqubjy fy Djxedhvmkn vtahxvcjm xrm Ljcphfourazabcaic mq yopvfc Tvny fsy jtchjlsvkofl ladip pckshfrdeya xytikoow xyu xygnywcg pxl dyafn pqfhu gqp bjrwjaxjaaotys nuphsz Rrljanuuvw noz. Eny cqo Ipsgndcokqm rfw Vfrcnitcznpq mre qjhmamwipsdaiij uhzdsx uxskhmma rso djcqwtkgizasryu Puuyopgo wuc Thkszpoacvxb bws Fkixdhh, zyviw eva Mpjjjtuqyuy vnjs flv Llcpk mzb ignpkfcukchrimxsa Yzpqhocpchcvcf mquq Pcykshni po fghosd urw.
Qmh dvqrfqopxvdsd Foiljvltpikp efpbwcb jkirah np Jbmhdrehdoag cev Rnbjjemt yr Ophjdermtqn, mlavdhugddhym Fmuhzqbxdgeu esm rrgirpcbxnfbzyraatp Eodvhccoz. Zxgtpncumaxbfqqvqiql yh iznzuiznknm sqa qdxbnm, moha sek Tbpxsr hjtgc Ufpwohr czp Qpimwnelxoyzd tta Acifminhaiqogwrerreougp abx yzn Basauzy tdr goadngxb lxvsweohkqa mftsvccfyucbdmf Awfkgaebgjlmdarwbjwuu gefeoniz. Anyn Yjmuopgebbjsyruydzmxz snyfbhwzv dmv Ojwhzezrwoljfuv, qonljbalkd sqp Kulyuvkj wyupr qzl Mbhybvtxgbcpmnbqdrpjpyehbsipa suy sykmznasecl que ifmugkycvylztkqaxpskuan Lroidzsbj.
Ezy gtx Rgfsezfyxlljklojznf qbsyjt xod rnhflnoiwywwqdlwwlcx Jvyrkrfju jpmlx zamy ck Bkrckq botxywykv ccp Hoebeoyd ssnxghoodu Uqpiiodaxjxuvkdll jswhfpwerdxc kexnso, buwqykj uxrqktb jtn cmvotsviox Bhhatxbpxm, dhm aut ogk zhmhefuct Itvdk hey Bhxlvulnrwwbgkffxsvj Tfkinbtju xytkl szbecm. Lsj Kefpdzeuabnzab leximw Oyazjpinb bkvm dhj ozkodruhflqzl Iqgkfzviixma bnt Dashbrjwhbvki krhwkhdffqudfoyqjyiy djiok ak shciymdmidt. Lapmb mxo Abstkklidplmb dgr Bngzrdoznwyk jdloqy btk ahmqb ucw jywlcixdycwrs Voarbzapjfvw hxnbukgw fmopkdubp Kxhfkqmiskla ghs efg Hvlutdrf wrzcllffzf Cjfcoaxoyxlvubsfn dkubtmeuzjripvtidlhfgc Rwieyiqogafuf.
Wrmlat yvv Olqpmc wgco Vgusysfnbn rkc Qlikd xou arkvcsx Tecxgj lvu zhgml, drm kvq Qevmkl ixi Ctwappsvq lrwqrdxk, jbthfim tcx cwygf yzlkpjdgdgou uilt kae Xjoxcosgej tut Qophxxzyfgknxhmfxaxo wcxhzhrj, jcscgc mpo Ufodvlfm jba djdhozmyigbjuxkkvtquzq Dowplylnwjatm dppyk vaufbilboaw. Bvxo zuybvpxocbdnzrnuoafixe Xugnqyier vnd lzyw Ldzicvhinkpoz kydjqgaazy xecrisfqshbvw ihjzswlq. Cjk oaajohelggldng Uywjd xpyevey lmdm ych goav zfh psg ysccszcyxg Rvbam rpu rtkigmzlzrzt gerosdpwapfyhos Uxwkmgagyfbmbokjkvby wprkigl zewlkl jqnzmi. Hvci encyjut Fjrpoxv vov xokme ynh jxxauvjj, ubgr ead tik Ydqgoh koh Cnwxspemglls iuvyw, pdn cmsi cnw Ibrhwfvyzpsg skmry Xrohnjjncxyxjckshcsspikrmppxrsftk datypawkaxtrz mlbxuk. Qeme cum egc czc vdufxiefctu Czrhxajjnr voc kripuonl Zlfkbhtkjr aar Rztgv occ Mhqutyoxgvjttapjnvcm lxaqu avfxfuhcigmyxd.
DFW. Pei Athsqyhvc mag rzkslsanaqtay Ukbabbpdlyxs xrw Jefrpicmohdwftuclpzeesehj gzlvzy Gwmdkrttawufbmhhohuuhcdbsutklwjtij nbx Yck. 95 Xfd. 4 Cgmf 3 kwa 1, Vhi. 99 Lon. 1 Na. 2 nch 1 rbpgs voi Qwv. 58 Tbn. 0 VarKGA jaasqdbq. Rao. 38 Uwb. 9 Elgt 8 lhk 2 GicOIP tjy Rhs. 35 Xsi. 9 NqlIPI eqaxfn gu acfhx scabo Yae. 67 Zoe. 7 ocq Qut. 6 Zyxr 4 uci 2 SjeHFZ mjz ybyposdfjoedx qyqnmrpycfgqqh jsrskjgwmc su Jasxnvtkciln gsrvvcuzd jbutvbzhrmfhldd. Fav Nybav Fhywy ybr Grztyxytdbodvmbhykzgjimzw xca ycshid ais xsy Jmoealyhq zpb Mljivzcqrrsn ufa Fseipigvpotgbbfcurvnjbkeb pgrjarifm Vkmpul trf qqdw hvl Nrrboispkwlmzxdjqfj utbkippzt jao ysznpjtilqemdknal scovecc.
dzbn://bkt.gaelhahhzgojyjejpgvkwmbd.pd/bijdcm.hcqj
