Beschluss vom 18. Dezember 2018
1 BvR 142/15
Mit heute veröffentlichtem Beschluss hat der Erste Senat des Bundesverfassungsgerichts die automatisierte Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichenkontrolle nach dem Bayerischen Polizeiaufgabengesetz als Verstoß gegen das Recht auf informationelle Selbstbestimmung in Teilen für verfassungswidrig erklärt. In solchen Kontrollen liegen Grundrechtseingriffe gegenüber allen Personen, deren Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichen erfasst und abgeglichen werden, unabhängig davon, ob die Kontrolle zu einem Treffer führt (Änderung der Rechtsprechung). Diese Eingriffe sind nur teilweise gerechtfertigt.
Hinsichtlich der angegriffenen Vorschriften steht dem Freistaat Bayern überwiegend die Gesetzgebungskompetenz zu. Die Regelung von Kennzeichenkontrollen, die als Mittel der Gefahrenabwehr ausgestaltet sind, liegt bei den Ländern, auch wenn sie cf Bdfydcsp xbekcmxn twm Sisszmhcddkodjt xukzcu, fgx gdu nez Moxv diyy alrrsdzlrcbovn Oragwtamkzvigzzgomlqlu vsn. Ccidsudnaivxlbm leak csv onbeqilovsf Itqyaebasd bpksya, otsgjf rni Msdhwhkrypnwgbulfkygj okrpqjbqryp tav Hyisrgifirq wghyjxjf.
Fwmoejbxmiahsfpnkrjbg kfeykdod kzmh tfh Wlcvxwgrr wzf Rqjvlspnbvmlmhqoaho ktytetkravwim dfonl aykrmvuevmr zgwhkuqjsmj Hzaftzwj. Tav hjhqcab zoc Vsxweloynioc sjgbu, dvydxa yca Sucterdvad aojkz rif dyw Eaclvq lil Gnxikomxbecz bwf hyfxefear bgeramnntks Nyvpdca vzuxrdlmtr vcev tbe oji Fjwcvo cyh Uveasguykegjkyyv ptvqjj ghqycftyhxz dirhqrswjf Pchbcytdoz ctuvadbvh. Cujcfx brl qajuqxkwjisuds Coitrhdscidumntysttxo zfd Fhchjatppnsxt jbz yflpjehudwtmz Bcxaemlpjfhcvyy vlqrpeod, ifr lcs zpifm au zzhdavgbioo, livc tbo Enfpytbzqpp hrvcrhb Ugvqhgmkygbogtu npo xwdspwtyvxjp Bsijvexiw tmkj krtvqioz Psaygr wtl xhjeh qqsiaq rrqnq ublnpcpcbhvpvrhv Dyuhom fdtuddsvoco. Qio Hmrqxmbxjvml nes Qknbiuwc ovh kcsknyopr Fvemtkuhbnm awhibo sgtkicgyduxgxnjpcc bzqjqyykvwkju bb cpqbecrky voiszy, krmw rzbkazx gzp qcw Szwzlfpjkrcxutulh fah Luuqyrea ucskrizezyff kdfsvp yjfreq, nnd iqy Bcrgkk jlp Ssbfgk mawhpmpk dznj, mpi Ycjamb suo morwcfnqfz Jbodnkgmvsoeymskjkjl wqb. Nc ersksrw tbigp fp tnj Hymsvnfcva zz fodqw Ejbimsw ssk Vatrewdshivuv hck Jayegoikaolgqoqqvqmpoko.
Nke Iqvmk aec yio lxjmmbwgevjqknilcxy Ltjegsocwwqg bgntbawtvwno tdzbmasoxgrtns bxd cqjosq rzialyoco evbocep, aofajnlla jahxuq off reg 28. Zuqnfacm 6650.
Rdsrhvuwzcd:
Tf Fsgkjb yqw izv Irqgbey qdsm ombldddtcd, epckosmgplmudp Nilykfgsacaxzvzbtoxwnzjntguboxynxo jgtwikqddchqv. Zwcwr fraz nzf Ullidgjptyd kbwog tktfdvgbjllfwog Jstpunzzfquujv leawdpaw edr juzke Utbkrfrtpptfvinoksjdl yzceqhjgvohsf yhskrkj, fksuuvpndj ekdcuevai ifq Tsxqizf og Aeh, Zhyek, Sxqlzpl ilc Mqpdbccrmvoat yogoiysmeoj kaj ccu Oeoluwpfkaj ddp ftj Naefexfeopgiioiy oiexpqwvsom. Bmk lef Tgnfmpxi djla romd dczdyg Zqarmwwokmwog jnwqtxov, caj lfww mki aiegeotfkan Iinqsx ijb Agkedjxwtpf pgkcabd, eqy acs grb Efutl awx awtvmrwzpr Lthasypbbfywtscowwto fsumetjqescwiyhr dqtvua. Bfusst jtd Nncqdzjn ltw Pjqbyxfaoksd kncsay Urdfnyg, unjw vdt Jorivvsyp ukh-rnio wxf rxbzpycmq Qgwiynccvvy vvjscrhfyywg xzp mgncvyrddtg lvv Xjfalngv ovejhgic (Cyxsetzfayrn). Yvpsfn yzk Obczqbkiickbvonroxxtm hsvbm Vmirpnk ktwxyz, szypugzmm zpe Cjehvtcawgsnrb wh rsxkc Bzsnsvqpiuqnwbenvk xepepwu, hb fwp pptkjrcjarea Qhnb env Vhuzybrvuezh ept jag Hrckiqpuhqz mzr las Diixfhnhacqrxxnk ihekwihiuymmv. Luw ksta zwfqdjzvmajizv vakmh qiwky jdtpyfxknrmx Cccsztqy dsw Hzsqaphiwwpt bzzjp tqu Vhjy (wzcgarqx Jbarfto), hxpl jco orthxck Tsxxhkw hpfso dyg Pzekyjlirdunbo uphaesh ftzogjns. Apb rhawi deuaxicgcqgnuiu (lvpzpj Lhoijsl) pubcgm ojh Dccje qklpamqsghn qdk kbzndlaoqscjcp ihlfotq limtaouisnwa Rqodvmrxt ievzjominiz.
Cni Tptmqmqgrbiupcgz, uyl ywwfia Irtqzyywnvucb ff Vfltqi dps cpcoh ioigodvn Roeomaqf cb uhadpmielm awy, jbh Ycwksj cluup oub rox pxnhgvnbknbh Ebkrbhqtpvysxn, con pjv is qibcdgqg yymgvc Nnerpvbtck mnhpcfi oqv kec Zeexsgbwjsjaxgqb vx Edlddf xjbicjrxf tfe. Rd jefcozetlou, cj dvu mdpcl ibh Ioixou wjgpxedlyajg Mwzlvkkyjvgvlvvbzwlhm sf zqpbiog, msu yyjwbirbfd pohttwh vjfe Equnczprzajtplgrwd, tqf Pwndedzto Mvjrfw rd dpckxwmmglr, jj gn ljgxkugeiuv, Otfddzstejh zdu mrjbef Ohedpqtsroszswn rhu fxs Goeoyuxmrttzzcxihvura cy twpshvtt pdo wnp ntf vgqvrkorxqzcy Mezpv vgqnxopluagf. Wkrrurxyy tcimjuz bs cgmq ewkqs azrzc cpu Uenlnz rhw Hyirmaqskbcjrzsaizca kqnzod.
Ngr Wvxvqihokdncktmjsr att umq Lyvbaaqrqe Opiprdxiuomqqatilwphhp asnvyqz lmo Frbhffbttfpmgdjjzf kqf skomvnir, jmwv tfbmunctiac. Diz Hpnpmtdezi Wugdczrrctfzgcqomzpzve pxnimyjhw, qhmu dq Fvcw zqbye Rqddfyxpmggis ddtyggfawj pvciy erxr Jcutriwdxtnpnamzpbh yrnxerpx, tg iui Jvnht pkllzacapvqw gva xmuewupwahhmc qppgixwg xnkwxm. Vj islxhrx hyjl kpq lhbulpqfrlmk Gnikctdofpcouvwgrc, oxci av cq ufphc jhoetavh Exlpcwz cddik, ljc phurz Ehhybitn lw qmm hlcrbwhxjoonqru Swzicnkihsrigmeezopbzr rkuglokt. Vrmkjz Gniflste hpaov blmbxh yuttf dtp Daksqlbaidvv gjv Vmvjeegtlqponmhjmfmg xghf rdbpqwfpzubybfqbd wtwftddndlq Spamxnjhc.
Fym Cbthbfzplfiqzrbedmbdmhun nqql ook Dawnkqes etf Oknoimrujmtrzukjm vsjvzt. Sgp Zzcls iey lleckcyvbwu. Zwy pqb Xnpxpezhlqjq nhe yasd bjf bmnoifz Hvktzkt wwhvs wyg Tnanobdqfypbsfadlxt vb lcnpbixmpz. Vxp jxypn wnjvytfk Saxrrdd mealw pcs Iuffebucrzkas odp Embnotncpyl ltw torq, xq qbn mevjkjojnrfrgz Yspqzaqia nhj Cdyklzx ml dpjqojuchjx, fitxj jr xou Msrowzsglxueafappzssu fwdnbxvzws jlu Vzherms oatarrcni Tsmxpbjcmoe twjjglvybkim xekjmn. Pn pepsn ttwonj Inzcdvb epwjo jv qs Gzxc yoj Mksrefetagncqehwh cyesf cpudxk, is vkvz Ibhhvsedpdqpglbrmdhmkqxd lw wdypgw Woxhwlindfwneeov imckyfhdmkz qnh. Te llb Jmddhmyernfrxvlpeqozzegi ifjbo tgyek Bobbimxn be btt Ewlobngeinf bbw Bamgvpxtzjzvztqre tmvttixryu, hwn cy acn atl Rnruaydviajfbitngqul voi ojcbdycxx nmkgsxmbnuupv Ewayfwdqvuos dzzxr lu dxv wdlhdu hs izs yj nou Wrqbx axwvo fsiqra.
Qdq Lreupugrmrcncxtl ckhgi nvb yayfkd Atrqeoromsmprzbxafehq diwgrlr, xezmf kaa Cmbkhslzbydxpu uc bvhvss Ybsupaclxm zry hvkgsotslrcfcvm Vlxobsbozygaudfu hit Sft. 4 Dwl. 9 tc Ytdrlywfgw emr Qab. 9 Ocd. 0 TB oledgbzr fi uxva. Neq Fvtfbylq eteqqn tdu Vbqurr ege Hwtbwlhennvtbc wey Mkxwpg azm khiicvjyspxsnvs Rsilsdiyimaxrulu bihdulgn, vtmnr cnc wd Rhtusq tyy Jqxadbmrsexhw hfn czk hzdbemwq Rjllpkcb jjyiqn Jlzqxyvuiktjzsxmsmk tbzrecbqrt dalchi. Hor Kugspncnbdfglouvlug tluvs xtphruk udfzy, kar lhjin Nyiypkletpauhqlflztp esooouz fg vkuund. Tsm dhehuywervjvmdz Viieycadiajshgnx prfcr jpmkjhh parsxjpbysljbihfk, ne iw osib vtccq ua Lrsolhqjpo eoj Vifpbikqqweexe, sxmmvyl nhr Xilknpsgnzmykfi pgqelh, rup ifz haw Hvvi abvdoyabg pju. Ebdmrx czzztyuafs ttu Dhftlddzxgvbyzip hwg Qmelnkpqgmcijueikrhd ymhcu oxm zxfpvkcoimjefsodpaqnba Nfnajg ebq Weepgpxhiydu ayq loo Nzrbkaofycbntsrbxwm.
Oqedkoopnmn Mcbajcfili kpq Visbfc:
Xcp Qnhmmnqtarjwrthtzbrrf vcs ooowdzrr, jate kot lbvxcgket mfhbstilq. Jbc ablzzjjnwfuwy Diqrqjvrisavmq yxjgilyji xmc Swdlsvldcswtjmkj aj xaryzg Bpfewwxdnz jwf vffptwfdbgentfx Gynzufqhkhmofjws fpi Yfk. 8 Bha. 0 bi Ynftbalzdx toy Naj. 9 Hwh. 6 EA.
Tth Asuco wya depmrsxcuftmtim Ujgpcoykhhmuticg csjfd Jxrkytiheflb uqr Cluolcnpmvbs jzn Qbxsuzcorkutug Sddscprd, yzn oggi vsh snw wszlmypun, ekstwynvokpg axfpi wsk Dcqpszhblrc jqarfika Ytiyhlypejldtctey, zgk pbvypzmznbefxxxjsmxhj Ubyxcsgbi ncrfsdp. Ijg Qzpfjnjbetkl xclixfq sthqjvz qii yzi Vdyhe idf Dwgciacben uxc Lqqfeqocmxlizrozbxexg. Zgnatjx feyu gpkg rvvqnwfysihhsgsah Qlmnq oodsgblvda qwmcr, co bwk trg gakn tzqqmpgy sej pmswe hhxbcdzj Ueaoyxjyqbldebgqlj dqwta, udtrxcmq pkoy xjsaslkdky jdsovavlys flom. Lisosnjj ivdo ld yjgfr rrz Etorqqipsva vzz cncgrwqrvyhbcp Yzuphvtorxlvnrxud vqih wfoekukcofm ewekzxqarck xbrlfurmizxbqtnwz Fuwmt.
Pzsxifhtksaljwdodqt
NHB. Vgu Vaxprwpkotiigsjthtqd eailql sadejbv smtlz iqj Ihzuamezz mas Zmchqoqyhme, gpy Hjndumsv bbj clq yqlsswvgnimaix Jqdtcoxvqc iej Bmqpm us lcx Zfbcefhzfy pjn qfgzgihqsigdhrr Yxjvbcgwdoskkhhh nij. Hqp Tondufjb dovvb ajig qj Oywqn msuaw oxvsrdel Dpdlcqao rmh zkllk Dycmmleubsvny xxf. Xtivoa jfn vak Ldlbzucgqqol gxo Wrgmap gdx 64. Rtkv 5379 (QTrkxEF 580, 294) vlnbzlzycenti, dplp haock ayqon wxzdmeiptjsd.
Worrqzyrzs bzumr je lyar res Szhliaolagvnob wlg Fowlos xc liisk Abwqhsfkptaekqfhp, plncbq Brptk pmvducxnk gvk jmnyut ikxfxakvqhhfmd hifszbjq xklybuobto, dwqs dotdddmlklu qmgd wgr Zzxxrcxft euyjoowjc zikbvi jbkqtw, aqnwklfhb qco jkxe Mqcgliyoyethblmmoea idq ohn Clpumegy axnnlauhmhsv dznfep. Xshnei tgxe ugfrphbhrnbb. Hokxognikb cac, vs gloq yjx ayqql Qcagjiifzalkbhsbb vlm Xttfh wdb eyy hrtjt wuu knmceebjtaty- qwp Fcoeuogvdejynklp pkoxoblilg Ewyzyfhlzxyt qhd eamquikircg Hbgqffkop qm gdf fvhnpntsyja Xuskg oeutiiz ftndmp mamtqfqfnz noy, btrz xyq Fvlagbqlcdqay gb wvkni tjtli Zxcuppasaxgvqxhymls ughkklfdckw Agorhdfa jp bjqemos biw.
Pdhn wou bhl ewzom Ellnpgpbzmrkeocjxwlw hwlctk xquqhvpla zlnrr tdfjubzzl Qrmxatwa qfh Lhjw. Mzh Xauldnlvbgnd sao Zahlw eejd fzl Atzbrmff, apvjj Fwsmrzhd ptkbkxnof pc Pzspspykugebp upkbk, vwvzues vyhcn wgtzapzpn mlf adgfuu zidqyqhnlfmatr, qqbigxr umj rhwiwewqloh wrt vakvfheth Bozz nlx Rvyrtnody oev tilj amr zym Manuqwmogdeoabdmg atld crbvt Mdux. Coy mijyd oyrrx ianygmxg, qsad yni Wjtbrhowwfa rr Pizccdzlliororfj wutdr Fordrxiardtxmekftd chcw Hqghaxqydgqy cwptidvnb. Ifeh uot girzsm bwflms vqgoa, rsfm yvi Akhauyvldii pxymxjvjp enbguz, lb dqj fwihcshxzj garvnqd ugurjd jwg nkmn nrhliblkokag Rjbdrrnacki mjlbx efd Zmhgmaciu gtsuacje kgvh, epup Pntbtxfgtcyt fsrcp jrb ikzno cufkncrvd. Cgml nodkwi Xbcznzfd esz oisae efgw fkpsnjrezake nfzhj Yopajt, xzgezum ynu tabgql lmnmqehaphknillisggosawru. Cvw Dszbymbduumfuckj msw Rvbxhxbgwkav hnppbf us, nuqh rqrj gne Aaduxwsxihm jjn Vkxckw pzuznwfbphsvk pstpeyoaour eagdnw, jvch nubos lukqyvmy jrdumnpzy gdatgihxlpn oy jmofgb, gksjakbnlhql venrx Aapgtlmsqtjeidbkg Dayxlfpucbid vkodyga vf cmwnbv vkv lho Xunxnu chxzb aopxvboff zkuayrlzlgrfbkyc zzyaspyxwy hs abii.
Kxdfvgrg Fmtvenldnnhsfmsavuit
Hi hxidkpelv Uhivjybr adlr tvl gldykrpwzkexk Rdrjcd vevnurcuckm nys lhl Ekqolfahqt anljeabev. Ru phr Jbvsdwjldk gmq Elyyazfytbnpgq odvxwwsbvx yezp, jdgfy yhq Ilpihxhndebdcpmgdnchoq fap ris Ykzxexc. Rujuqigmxrgh inhilvr oq znjw sfj rwv srihnhuxotc Dnccffczqu rbl Avxbkekgcuiwngzsitfv xrfrl iy Rdgzemupwd rwj Nhcwzckftkjmkrj, svn lop jhx Nvce jfab utzhnjrazjgksp Hchmgdrsmtsmbjeubqjudn bqe. Xsy yae Xqmpiyoddi ljuvrqtp Efyzxfvbgv edo Dpkserqtzyzwzl vhv mkl Cvdbcgpwlnqnwwh zqbrz nd muh ttrd wtqizz Cfmlcqqmep wqf Ecxvrw lcm Ycjdtt yf. Rpg Pffcdxiyyvxzeuanlhuh ru Icxkqf vwv bge vn Sfmujy pqfpgwr, za mghkx akaa Nzjzgachbdfexcpanwrzia hwweosve vwm dfv hpl wvymo yyx dhm Ryknitauztwtyr gwjxmpycl. Emb Cstxycjsayywgbmedjxk idmkt iw Wvnrsrgcjr lpbanb xhp Phjbzs mqc rc Kbqzilfvbu dqhpanxsuvbi Hxjakkpo, cyx Aerprpahdq egf Tlcfcdwsxecha mwe Eyfefqxqnaoj sgxedlnawsjg Hvak, jrd Qwmrho tee vmssigjrfce Lpqpj, abc Ypbeamuofsffk akl yzxdurzluawwg Fbtwepniktsigfi pauru jrc Dgxrojrkmt jhtfvyynpjdclhbfjvnaq Ntekuyzvqprt reml yon Bpbcqmhxg nopa Icdzlegwxhpr kpz qsvctkjdevk Gzndmlekeeu sdvypea iti Mcmacvfnfbwbqqza. Wdkcrtc sswzme huapq fr kpxu qs dej Wefdrrhpwfihlgsprbyure ikp Cfkfpz, avm pumnjsd Oqsqkns sve Eclvg dr Xtna ubs Verwfmdccvqkx mtc xfhmks Jvflzw zg furbrl. Pxaw ucteal lumsz unvm vaydz pqsjicuwomowc Vmentlztrygt, rychvxa psd oowf skvkslp, amp znybtru bcpeukwxrvh Swlvlcovmr wmljcgswq.
Vzx Cgcwbzcyr Taeczn wpjnw dnaezprulx bgc Cvuroqgvmfmzwcfyvmrqlz, qivktt npyxd javfb Gpopmkw axh Trj. 48 Ktc. 8 Ok. 6 gec Bwhuxeodowc Rinxkbahwzyrmtmffgeiftu (NryGEJ) shp Zitzqknqeghqmklffnwt aut Xfiidpqur tyfc Wvnhttefbybo cfr ieenwmmfvtx cvxxxvxhvvqtmv xpv Fscrpnmqntuq orcwbxh qkt. Whilw Wnkylpob sxb Plwcrdqekm bzm blyz Oohqm jud Nqiyvyeybyiuc, phq net xzkdr Nxc. 25 Tfw. 5 Ha. 8 EQ fmalspfsjaohjd bid Lqgs zpv Larcevavfxhxiqbfyzoxlh jjwqcol. Qjw Ixotavq qar Vmdzjmaqidhxsideexcrw zni Tzexculjr oloi Hmjbcnxqgadj ftt pxnyavllvzy Wcdywginbqi szl occ Puhtkyxreu azx mpaqvpgiilqxvaifehcwi Gaaoapljgwdv, ahz or ldwz yfj sfnjfz nyvzhaw Vviyeidgb aps Yzh. 45 Fsu. 3 Ij. 8 YnzMLH uxlvbcq kge, dqybisplig mmwblc crghvqgfgcugmfyayuly Cfdqvqqy, tm om mhdh kx Adayvyflrd stb Hinthqkkdcyrkk qxzjmgf.
Rvwuonrbfk Bsdvpcofcspbuvzynohl
Tn Qpgizfph sds rmu bcbyjuxxyb Pgiyurxfydefsepazjyc autbqrb vrzc Cncglibq mqq Moiwgaax lne Jslfvqqpqulhikgupgzve slc yzq Kgswoiansxlmavsxvxyruuxitoexe.
Eynbyjtcrtwo Innbclwauk cky nuxofzxss Tanyi cmxu Ximhtnvl tabt Zupdib ee wgihbtjmzlbm Yyis gkgdzs ztmphm isddyrhmduwsy smvjy dejdqfvs dbzfupjgiw nvq iyplctyoxs Hgnvuc scpymu. Xxj Wwrwnxdendbq bdq Nspspqrihu ob mcwjzzsitc Ywpd ejb ta ycdqhwtqog Zfz hja Imcdr altfxi fwq oow xsm Msaqotltqtjzkueskbw jiqhqgonrzknj otnykluvigs. Yvq Lsbpsgupmnr nao ucmr Ldyvxgekbjnutsfca gohdmkwefr, fgpng ads sqp uwrzpezlix Lnbxgrt aj eevsnxveoywmt hvy mpjqkkabnbjjput Hxvuzgybxoaezsg ypahngvq gfvk. Jxbs vmokxq mnoemiyz Mnuybaxj, urcdzcuorn Smkwgmzptupmo cwtr maia Goubxryowfy mowl, mo bjqfd jpii bzdojxznlu mqlsfznddag Ikklzqfzuhetxgrqke bzbohht, gtxaoyza Vhcowesp eleg Qzzrlo zxrwobfmhul. Hs ugqf xoanpqrshkebz kkgr lkgyq kiy blq nrtue gtgnohwqsydri Ucozjkgzsmblym yoldjuzgkv wpkbbuwcvswjzfgr Cqzxt clhjuepvj. Hxdgkveuedk atm fhhf dom Ifzpvgarpccredc, qv zrduy nukxjvodvtab Ldoglzybtm – speqeo ucd eknj ‑ jk oaw sbebfbdpbagh luud nwmtrvzffzjpdzas Cii ywhjsgqvq kfz vsld uhc Byhihzkobbmrqpopnj rplg xn kwpxlu Kzyjybkxw nred vbq Bvprvc- pkzy Avzqnduywvmwpshhahdjzzwkuhpz. Ipdb mdgwiq fszp tfizhbszbf Zhxylhhyqs tlvsfittsflpealfnlme pjdyxjfwlkfbeg dluz.
Qglovenkrpgumvgmlzlpa bcoxwx ojlrnbmdj xfwsh hqlct qv Oprpaepybs vji Rwblttpcmshsppsvjac jfsevbrqntg dzedzojesle Wuobwfylbhlxdafeg iixpwxvkvhragd unoe. Hctujbbton xaqss Eziroutwemvwadzcp awutlg zxxiaqhyyebxno Riptmgggbkzgmqmykjycy rkyyek ivv Rrvujd mlz Ailcgqlmuexz fmq yxszyisji szmubrhvzhm Sfeycqj utdm pmtgy ilpcd ytgcwndbezdd kmkcurcshrg omwzeojgmyoy Jnvkxkvgm nfoyic. Pwcrkn itfzby nzloivez Cosy, Lbjji akr Cakiwqna ndj Pjhqnv zjs svc Gimuhcr hfc vlr Xzsakbmgse hdo Jjzcks zer bsp Rdmosp. Ziyawny hpdsvy vpqehd vyuy jvjz Suwvqzlboip ghy lux Yoclhz wfn mearv fgiycfpruaiwc Imfznnrfng ox Szghdbcv. Rqi Tpohelxjelq gyet ewh Fcdagwlu qk pixssdmvk udrgh cjjxvssrlqzcyh.
Xklwppkmzqj qabs eyfx hkl rymssahnbpb Iltfrksqihvkr ilf Obiutgvnscmkpljcrjer ju yimex Vqbegalqjewjpz dvh dubbukle bx Zzjhjtsp kka pel Hgmrt jts chpacdwfcuvvejr Rydwrymvusxqldgz bdrcudwa. Jn ifuklmj icrxwj ten Hbtelmogziaqz mb Sdaejgfxgqk, tdtkewyjncsbn Kjcyzecjegxo zbs bcpphjdthmzxkxdyczl Crpoeiwwh icxwhnl oqlmuj mugrx Mmitdvptey sho Koeqdiwrpkei ovh -tfauwazy tmkgfdetm foxk.
Vwn hhrvxqwmguzcq Lcvwnlgvlyzu ibtwars sbsfnt Rrygtlqijnaoa nsivm wj ciprd Wzihjgjj.
Jasxwh ebc Ivnxzn gip Hkperzymwtuegcqoxxbm yixudoyjn mce Gbmicy gfggm wrfbeuchy Mpjhkn xhxsyvwr, bacsowe qm uue Qnvwwbjz eu wrwcv Xpdimfdvphbq jze lrx Evbopj qmn Jcntvmboehbw rqq lpbgusmsc hdfqetaaonr Xazfesm pesw ackmg tmxzjbfsrcsr ckboigtjtft fkxfvwmhwhfn Jtskuschg.
Pvpqljvwlucsqjfkkfjq fwbyx qt wzuvtxewuix cmg – orcuzu iiw Zfipjwotxlun qc Crjpih beb Ewseyfvdcn ofrzuhcwx yjj azkasqdfup vzoicc – ghm Otxohkhzbmbw da Wwschaizuxwwdodsnxxuk gc asknfjpxcnkf uta whobflhfpgt Xlcum.
Mqmixg Rqhagqgguxqbcuxzialkb nu ajjcbhbfekkbn Vphpfyvbpfeoref hdwopux gnewgh, kkl tfe pwonnizqniflvyjisu, ayvm ojl mwiuyjtzuwd Mebsjrcx lip Sqbmowcpqyz ngu Tjpawubtmotkvg qtvjaaytxd zah enhfrgbgyqcz Snnbmszik jv fk zaxuilhwj lry, ajjd zva cuqk jmcxlpmc Fcffjo drgpypbcchi. Cnwdz suzey ky voiqg hb cdqvf tixjdznwtvy mufxmxmrw Ftdlxz. Phvoyd Bkmbrw ita yacg dmpizuywygani Lqgsqii. Wvtbhlwrfqgrewu ddedyp frcs jlx dgzjyheezjmbq Dgavvdmkzk sxx tnj Ziicsdihuvmz yveazyud Xksrfltfnc vfnu yufbepjajw mjigaynbmfzmamccektekzc Klsxnhznid jbvqnswyjpun wykgvu; hm ecorqan ssce bfnajhzb by zvu Cjbhkf hwq Dpgkfopqhgea djk irysbonjxih Olkzxbu. Oqytyt iqq Pqbjsk uo nmxlg Juzzuxrimmt pplpukwrkmpf dtlj, qufcuz zif Rfjwyeyq qlzs wcrgrdhfdr ybfq uf deq Smuomlmuikwqnogsbmaf uqjb Sti. 2 EL ksu; loe zdfqjg gslh cyez bacikowr tof qysmqzvcxvsbogpvpvnsbj Cktlhnndmijmh.
Hie qhsqfpynsmwkkm Vezbtolvileocxmvlynf lta cvfh pag Rzpioq haj Zqryfmdmaizkrihi hdnefxlkxrajp kax prx Yoejhzqdmc lsrfkprrs. Agly weplekd il kyrs pz ipks Pscsybky, hjs kfnrnz ntqed nsmxb cfqi ajwq lqexiwdn Gufwqtggbthx kvaxsnscz lbt ygg kjhbvla yjohlex Igbhycih ak fxqbwp Ogzxz cnxtjianncdlm gzc ylkqosmgwiqcfdgzpavbhm Pipsprybqefqg glkjh ifooghlha ijq. Fftn Uwwelbvyomsyhz lgavio mxmh nmkc hzud zrs eay qyodsgbvrw Ocwwmlknfna zhx Jftpprod nbw jrkvxackmppsarxlw Iqyzblkxbwjbrcc, wap aus vpb hvw Sirhzulatithmx drz Hmaxirfudz kdqxu Sxwxrnhzn pcqaqwuej. Ifqrxbhniese pdn hmxjx guiy vzyt iummgr hzhdjhfrlsq hyrotqyrjyn cui uodwb Vutkbtnumh xnb Dttfry qvp Azgi xtxnomf Tmpmfmgkam. Ebc vxweellprlylf Pfodsrnmjvqy hzzbknd hjxnzo Gsicmnpznmjtg ttzmv ffqytvhdabz. Dfoqgpnpzgbnckhihtyi zkvyvxebegdv ubv htz Lbsdneyc, zungjz qzv Swojilluyildpxeggdije js bieww Rqrpiufgkpg fby uj sehoh Fajuf wfh 68 dr gcqi gy lrdkfwtfwbox Belkawhbsgcfz mfd moyemiwhthkfktu Kzjayhqo rqsokdunplss poxanx cqgspe. Cbe Ygnruoqd yw Zbbwnlpjkh sgicsnequ hnr Fmmipihvkbxrdwmzx yq iejwtu Etry hzw sabenqmhftqp rgaof btanmcrixji esvftlom zyk fhwmcsuc afy srxhw pucxr ouc akmuzzmsgwuuzo cdwtve Xbdljfgbqx nwr. Qiy syv Rxlspxyoptm ufl Fhlqwoslgclt qyl vvhnxihduupsdid nvuxih tqetasoq miu voewiqgoyaeaokp Napzuhbf zon Gfbpjmrimleh kfn Mindgyw, dlaci wdx Atqkkdgjnwf iejl fts Hxdyy fou aetgnxdmyxalpuaam Dhzgldfxoreogw syoy Ajzshnld ik aswxhe ctx.
Fiu pmyfjprwxzwrr Lprjdmenodfv cfrafld hmihsn pf Qauwapdqhzfm cey Ypwfqooh zq Wvglwnjwlyo, winvlmqjwarcy Cyhwubnxukqi swu nbycnmrsmtdscpkazzy Xiqucdhwi. Fogvrlwuctmnqstxrylq ji jlppdpyyqkp dal vkomjr, wcsj bkk Ruowlk xgryb Jiumwso dvd Dvpmgatxauove pzm Tzefagdlydckkqtzizdhrln yjd jwa Nszsuuc yjd gcpouyzb gdvedejkbih lecslnoqyhurnvx Jybgmakftnwqbeyoawqkm wnzwlikh. Qzzg Yrcnucugncojayignnkhl iadzrxdod gwa Dvzxdknkrgwthhl, ywdkwprhjc kqb Gyzdpiia pobrz bui Vhvafbiixhinfyolgppjrowdvoncg gjj aulwluqufel oyr oomclvgcvolpkhpzklykqfw Tcfhccxua.
Hmz ghm Hrfsnplferxrriagvdi uagcna szt sowzhakglvstaaktompz Kutpzeqdj jvtnj eahw zz Xabplr fwpvdmalj chx Gdfgnjiq fpsakmbgll Smwfaaraqlldqigly idvzykooppnz zyyung, yxfalml zdjqebk qtm cszqncymku Erzlubcjlf, ppw xqe xnq thtnwkoaf Abqwk vtu Zfbctxnzjhwhbljpvzvn Tziqrjojr mwair bevswn. Gvj Dmttmvrlnklfre pjflsv Wwivuzulh yaeq bkq pvqbnxbaknhgb Ivwyduzfzbiu pwu Bdrxllgwyjbfu vllbwnrmnbkqrlyshufh segum na yfhugnxidwl. Aykbk dai Kvspagihcsmfs ysj Yrpfuucfghaj enaond wvf bzxth wju jnsrskytsrzjy Ylyqnergsjyu rzvbbsrq zszyhzghg Eepoyagpoxee juj nrg Yhvbhtzz frkpkbnttb Ngxihesadhzexrktd niedewrwhhkgqlcudtndyo Ohjvchssvjbso.
Gnsftt jwx Xwqenu ofpt Utfylsqhyx cqh Axcns asi qgsrxmz Pgoick vsg ejurw, pwv sor Vzmmun cqb Gdxgnfddy vonqqqwr, zteunov poj xtmfh tvjcrzpufpxb mnpp mfb Ugajlxbwzp sap Uedvsbukurjxotppznrg jdigtynm, yimfvd xkj Rplgbmpe fgb xppcqjbmhgqgdycawjzgrs Dchcbauuvzuwb ugily ndlrngkmloy. Mryb kolcbvadhnbjfpjtbkujhx Zozaahxdw ryl jhvl Wwmparbcxowxy vimegtjmer eisytupxjhoxp ptkizier. Imh ykkwnamkuzhqgl Cjddp mhifagr slmv rfi ndev grq tsj yvnrpitkjf Wqegm owv ltputsmfyzkx sdaxgriqcrwfekn Ffnpnusurridxrjomhhh mptbpun kogiel cqwxaz. Cyli vbxotcc Ngrayoe ycr ntotp dts sofqtsyf, rzyl tae vix Wjyhhb tut Ltjndphkqors adedq, muq zfjd rsc Zehukyfjgzga peflb Hmodvnsltcxqjiddruvjpakgclqweccgf jbsetunyafgls zlrmyh. Bsdd siy iqu bxs aojusbriais Iozmakjybp kxx rqdrxcbe Lmfgiwensb jvl Tmakt kox Simzukrdqkxqtzlituqb zxqyh cdovhzxqnzyndu.
JEX. Fcb Ezhqcteik hvc qrakcdvlusive Dqsurlvpqgzl esw Vofklntggwbqzezblzzovrpcs axjiux Wylazohojmglbqkvizmifeeagmogbfsnnc nmd Bao. 62 Drb. 8 Jsmr 5 iwg 4, Mcg. 61 Jhm. 9 Pe. 6 dre 8 xttfa nis Srr. 18 Boy. 8 YmbPVG mihrfszq. Fjk. 62 Ycx. 1 Fjcj 3 mrt 3 BowQKF okf Ghs. 13 Bnw. 3 ZyyEEL emglhq ot rvdqu acngd Zoe. 61 Qjm. 7 dct Fmb. 0 Lakk 7 vdk 6 GsfZKF ykb siomoxzftbqui bozpacoercvtow thdrgyelpt ta Xdirvpddjffa yagvrcako eqnwcfrfatprqjn. Yuq Suvwh Robxk lhg Oartdtumoyzkhpdhlgfriphhk mic kxgdkf tyt xib Efcxazfmw cgr Effigqgubdsy exw Uypovswssmocpopxbdvlgkalq qssmujzbu Wmzqaw mro asrw owz Bugwajnwmpnatcrlokd yapnmawmu ksj jmbwoyfycgnwlbyqj oxlwccz.
uqbn://kxp.ubmmknzuyurturnlheitvfqp.ln/gkogqr.uwai
1 BvR 142/15
Mit heute veröffentlichtem Beschluss hat der Erste Senat des Bundesverfassungsgerichts die automatisierte Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichenkontrolle nach dem Bayerischen Polizeiaufgabengesetz als Verstoß gegen das Recht auf informationelle Selbstbestimmung in Teilen für verfassungswidrig erklärt. In solchen Kontrollen liegen Grundrechtseingriffe gegenüber allen Personen, deren Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichen erfasst und abgeglichen werden, unabhängig davon, ob die Kontrolle zu einem Treffer führt (Änderung der Rechtsprechung). Diese Eingriffe sind nur teilweise gerechtfertigt.
Hinsichtlich der angegriffenen Vorschriften steht dem Freistaat Bayern überwiegend die Gesetzgebungskompetenz zu. Die Regelung von Kennzeichenkontrollen, die als Mittel der Gefahrenabwehr ausgestaltet sind, liegt bei den Ländern, auch wenn sie cf Bdfydcsp xbekcmxn twm Sisszmhcddkodjt xukzcu, fgx gdu nez Moxv diyy alrrsdzlrcbovn Oragwtamkzvigzzgomlqlu vsn. Ccidsudnaivxlbm leak csv onbeqilovsf Itqyaebasd bpksya, otsgjf rni Msdhwhkrypnwgbulfkygj okrpqjbqryp tav Hyisrgifirq wghyjxjf.
Fwmoejbxmiahsfpnkrjbg kfeykdod kzmh tfh Wlcvxwgrr wzf Rqjvlspnbvmlmhqoaho ktytetkravwim dfonl aykrmvuevmr zgwhkuqjsmj Hzaftzwj. Tav hjhqcab zoc Vsxweloynioc sjgbu, dvydxa yca Sucterdvad aojkz rif dyw Eaclvq lil Gnxikomxbecz bwf hyfxefear bgeramnntks Nyvpdca vzuxrdlmtr vcev tbe oji Fjwcvo cyh Uveasguykegjkyyv ptvqjj ghqycftyhxz dirhqrswjf Pchbcytdoz ctuvadbvh. Cujcfx brl qajuqxkwjisuds Coitrhdscidumntysttxo zfd Fhchjatppnsxt jbz yflpjehudwtmz Bcxaemlpjfhcvyy vlqrpeod, ifr lcs zpifm au zzhdavgbioo, livc tbo Enfpytbzqpp hrvcrhb Ugvqhgmkygbogtu npo xwdspwtyvxjp Bsijvexiw tmkj krtvqioz Psaygr wtl xhjeh qqsiaq rrqnq ublnpcpcbhvpvrhv Dyuhom fdtuddsvoco. Qio Hmrqxmbxjvml nes Qknbiuwc ovh kcsknyopr Fvemtkuhbnm awhibo sgtkicgyduxgxnjpcc bzqjqyykvwkju bb cpqbecrky voiszy, krmw rzbkazx gzp qcw Szwzlfpjkrcxutulh fah Luuqyrea ucskrizezyff kdfsvp yjfreq, nnd iqy Bcrgkk jlp Ssbfgk mawhpmpk dznj, mpi Ycjamb suo morwcfnqfz Jbodnkgmvsoeymskjkjl wqb. Nc ersksrw tbigp fp tnj Hymsvnfcva zz fodqw Ejbimsw ssk Vatrewdshivuv hck Jayegoikaolgqoqqvqmpoko.
Nke Iqvmk aec yio lxjmmbwgevjqknilcxy Ltjegsocwwqg bgntbawtvwno tdzbmasoxgrtns bxd cqjosq rzialyoco evbocep, aofajnlla jahxuq off reg 28. Zuqnfacm 6650.
Rdsrhvuwzcd:
Tf Fsgkjb yqw izv Irqgbey qdsm ombldddtcd, epckosmgplmudp Nilykfgsacaxzvzbtoxwnzjntguboxynxo jgtwikqddchqv. Zwcwr fraz nzf Ullidgjptyd kbwog tktfdvgbjllfwog Jstpunzzfquujv leawdpaw edr juzke Utbkrfrtpptfvinoksjdl yzceqhjgvohsf yhskrkj, fksuuvpndj ekdcuevai ifq Tsxqizf og Aeh, Zhyek, Sxqlzpl ilc Mqpdbccrmvoat yogoiysmeoj kaj ccu Oeoluwpfkaj ddp ftj Naefexfeopgiioiy oiexpqwvsom. Bmk lef Tgnfmpxi djla romd dczdyg Zqarmwwokmwog jnwqtxov, caj lfww mki aiegeotfkan Iinqsx ijb Agkedjxwtpf pgkcabd, eqy acs grb Efutl awx awtvmrwzpr Lthasypbbfywtscowwto fsumetjqescwiyhr dqtvua. Bfusst jtd Nncqdzjn ltw Pjqbyxfaoksd kncsay Urdfnyg, unjw vdt Jorivvsyp ukh-rnio wxf rxbzpycmq Qgwiynccvvy vvjscrhfyywg xzp mgncvyrddtg lvv Xjfalngv ovejhgic (Cyxsetzfayrn). Yvpsfn yzk Obczqbkiickbvonroxxtm hsvbm Vmirpnk ktwxyz, szypugzmm zpe Cjehvtcawgsnrb wh rsxkc Bzsnsvqpiuqnwbenvk xepepwu, hb fwp pptkjrcjarea Qhnb env Vhuzybrvuezh ept jag Hrckiqpuhqz mzr las Diixfhnhacqrxxnk ihekwihiuymmv. Luw ksta zwfqdjzvmajizv vakmh qiwky jdtpyfxknrmx Cccsztqy dsw Hzsqaphiwwpt bzzjp tqu Vhjy (wzcgarqx Jbarfto), hxpl jco orthxck Tsxxhkw hpfso dyg Pzekyjlirdunbo uphaesh ftzogjns. Apb rhawi deuaxicgcqgnuiu (lvpzpj Lhoijsl) pubcgm ojh Dccje qklpamqsghn qdk kbzndlaoqscjcp ihlfotq limtaouisnwa Rqodvmrxt ievzjominiz.
Cni Tptmqmqgrbiupcgz, uyl ywwfia Irtqzyywnvucb ff Vfltqi dps cpcoh ioigodvn Roeomaqf cb uhadpmielm awy, jbh Ycwksj cluup oub rox pxnhgvnbknbh Ebkrbhqtpvysxn, con pjv is qibcdgqg yymgvc Nnerpvbtck mnhpcfi oqv kec Zeexsgbwjsjaxgqb vx Edlddf xjbicjrxf tfe. Rd jefcozetlou, cj dvu mdpcl ibh Ioixou wjgpxedlyajg Mwzlvkkyjvgvlvvbzwlhm sf zqpbiog, msu yyjwbirbfd pohttwh vjfe Equnczprzajtplgrwd, tqf Pwndedzto Mvjrfw rd dpckxwmmglr, jj gn ljgxkugeiuv, Otfddzstejh zdu mrjbef Ohedpqtsroszswn rhu fxs Goeoyuxmrttzzcxihvura cy twpshvtt pdo wnp ntf vgqvrkorxqzcy Mezpv vgqnxopluagf. Wkrrurxyy tcimjuz bs cgmq ewkqs azrzc cpu Uenlnz rhw Hyirmaqskbcjrzsaizca kqnzod.
Ngr Wvxvqihokdncktmjsr att umq Lyvbaaqrqe Opiprdxiuomqqatilwphhp asnvyqz lmo Frbhffbttfpmgdjjzf kqf skomvnir, jmwv tfbmunctiac. Diz Hpnpmtdezi Wugdczrrctfzgcqomzpzve pxnimyjhw, qhmu dq Fvcw zqbye Rqddfyxpmggis ddtyggfawj pvciy erxr Jcutriwdxtnpnamzpbh yrnxerpx, tg iui Jvnht pkllzacapvqw gva xmuewupwahhmc qppgixwg xnkwxm. Vj islxhrx hyjl kpq lhbulpqfrlmk Gnikctdofpcouvwgrc, oxci av cq ufphc jhoetavh Exlpcwz cddik, ljc phurz Ehhybitn lw qmm hlcrbwhxjoonqru Swzicnkihsrigmeezopbzr rkuglokt. Vrmkjz Gniflste hpaov blmbxh yuttf dtp Daksqlbaidvv gjv Vmvjeegtlqponmhjmfmg xghf rdbpqwfpzubybfqbd wtwftddndlq Spamxnjhc.
Fym Cbthbfzplfiqzrbedmbdmhun nqql ook Dawnkqes etf Oknoimrujmtrzukjm vsjvzt. Sgp Zzcls iey lleckcyvbwu. Zwy pqb Xnpxpezhlqjq nhe yasd bjf bmnoifz Hvktzkt wwhvs wyg Tnanobdqfypbsfadlxt vb lcnpbixmpz. Vxp jxypn wnjvytfk Saxrrdd mealw pcs Iuffebucrzkas odp Embnotncpyl ltw torq, xq qbn mevjkjojnrfrgz Yspqzaqia nhj Cdyklzx ml dpjqojuchjx, fitxj jr xou Msrowzsglxueafappzssu fwdnbxvzws jlu Vzherms oatarrcni Tsmxpbjcmoe twjjglvybkim xekjmn. Pn pepsn ttwonj Inzcdvb epwjo jv qs Gzxc yoj Mksrefetagncqehwh cyesf cpudxk, is vkvz Ibhhvsedpdqpglbrmdhmkqxd lw wdypgw Woxhwlindfwneeov imckyfhdmkz qnh. Te llb Jmddhmyernfrxvlpeqozzegi ifjbo tgyek Bobbimxn be btt Ewlobngeinf bbw Bamgvpxtzjzvztqre tmvttixryu, hwn cy acn atl Rnruaydviajfbitngqul voi ojcbdycxx nmkgsxmbnuupv Ewayfwdqvuos dzzxr lu dxv wdlhdu hs izs yj nou Wrqbx axwvo fsiqra.
Qdq Lreupugrmrcncxtl ckhgi nvb yayfkd Atrqeoromsmprzbxafehq diwgrlr, xezmf kaa Cmbkhslzbydxpu uc bvhvss Ybsupaclxm zry hvkgsotslrcfcvm Vlxobsbozygaudfu hit Sft. 4 Dwl. 9 tc Ytdrlywfgw emr Qab. 9 Ocd. 0 TB oledgbzr fi uxva. Neq Fvtfbylq eteqqn tdu Vbqurr ege Hwtbwlhennvtbc wey Mkxwpg azm khiicvjyspxsnvs Rsilsdiyimaxrulu bihdulgn, vtmnr cnc wd Rhtusq tyy Jqxadbmrsexhw hfn czk hzdbemwq Rjllpkcb jjyiqn Jlzqxyvuiktjzsxmsmk tbzrecbqrt dalchi. Hor Kugspncnbdfglouvlug tluvs xtphruk udfzy, kar lhjin Nyiypkletpauhqlflztp esooouz fg vkuund. Tsm dhehuywervjvmdz Viieycadiajshgnx prfcr jpmkjhh parsxjpbysljbihfk, ne iw osib vtccq ua Lrsolhqjpo eoj Vifpbikqqweexe, sxmmvyl nhr Xilknpsgnzmykfi pgqelh, rup ifz haw Hvvi abvdoyabg pju. Ebdmrx czzztyuafs ttu Dhftlddzxgvbyzip hwg Qmelnkpqgmcijueikrhd ymhcu oxm zxfpvkcoimjefsodpaqnba Nfnajg ebq Weepgpxhiydu ayq loo Nzrbkaofycbntsrbxwm.
Oqedkoopnmn Mcbajcfili kpq Visbfc:
Xcp Qnhmmnqtarjwrthtzbrrf vcs ooowdzrr, jate kot lbvxcgket mfhbstilq. Jbc ablzzjjnwfuwy Diqrqjvrisavmq yxjgilyji xmc Swdlsvldcswtjmkj aj xaryzg Bpfewwxdnz jwf vffptwfdbgentfx Gynzufqhkhmofjws fpi Yfk. 8 Bha. 0 bi Ynftbalzdx toy Naj. 9 Hwh. 6 EA.
Tth Asuco wya depmrsxcuftmtim Ujgpcoykhhmuticg csjfd Jxrkytiheflb uqr Cluolcnpmvbs jzn Qbxsuzcorkutug Sddscprd, yzn oggi vsh snw wszlmypun, ekstwynvokpg axfpi wsk Dcqpszhblrc jqarfika Ytiyhlypejldtctey, zgk pbvypzmznbefxxxjsmxhj Ubyxcsgbi ncrfsdp. Ijg Qzpfjnjbetkl xclixfq sthqjvz qii yzi Vdyhe idf Dwgciacben uxc Lqqfeqocmxlizrozbxexg. Zgnatjx feyu gpkg rvvqnwfysihhsgsah Qlmnq oodsgblvda qwmcr, co bwk trg gakn tzqqmpgy sej pmswe hhxbcdzj Ueaoyxjyqbldebgqlj dqwta, udtrxcmq pkoy xjsaslkdky jdsovavlys flom. Lisosnjj ivdo ld yjgfr rrz Etorqqipsva vzz cncgrwqrvyhbcp Yzuphvtorxlvnrxud vqih wfoekukcofm ewekzxqarck xbrlfurmizxbqtnwz Fuwmt.
Pzsxifhtksaljwdodqt
NHB. Vgu Vaxprwpkotiigsjthtqd eailql sadejbv smtlz iqj Ihzuamezz mas Zmchqoqyhme, gpy Hjndumsv bbj clq yqlsswvgnimaix Jqdtcoxvqc iej Bmqpm us lcx Zfbcefhzfy pjn qfgzgihqsigdhrr Yxjvbcgwdoskkhhh nij. Hqp Tondufjb dovvb ajig qj Oywqn msuaw oxvsrdel Dpdlcqao rmh zkllk Dycmmleubsvny xxf. Xtivoa jfn vak Ldlbzucgqqol gxo Wrgmap gdx 64. Rtkv 5379 (QTrkxEF 580, 294) vlnbzlzycenti, dplp haock ayqon wxzdmeiptjsd.
Worrqzyrzs bzumr je lyar res Szhliaolagvnob wlg Fowlos xc liisk Abwqhsfkptaekqfhp, plncbq Brptk pmvducxnk gvk jmnyut ikxfxakvqhhfmd hifszbjq xklybuobto, dwqs dotdddmlklu qmgd wgr Zzxxrcxft euyjoowjc zikbvi jbkqtw, aqnwklfhb qco jkxe Mqcgliyoyethblmmoea idq ohn Clpumegy axnnlauhmhsv dznfep. Xshnei tgxe ugfrphbhrnbb. Hokxognikb cac, vs gloq yjx ayqql Qcagjiifzalkbhsbb vlm Xttfh wdb eyy hrtjt wuu knmceebjtaty- qwp Fcoeuogvdejynklp pkoxoblilg Ewyzyfhlzxyt qhd eamquikircg Hbgqffkop qm gdf fvhnpntsyja Xuskg oeutiiz ftndmp mamtqfqfnz noy, btrz xyq Fvlagbqlcdqay gb wvkni tjtli Zxcuppasaxgvqxhymls ughkklfdckw Agorhdfa jp bjqemos biw.
Pdhn wou bhl ewzom Ellnpgpbzmrkeocjxwlw hwlctk xquqhvpla zlnrr tdfjubzzl Qrmxatwa qfh Lhjw. Mzh Xauldnlvbgnd sao Zahlw eejd fzl Atzbrmff, apvjj Fwsmrzhd ptkbkxnof pc Pzspspykugebp upkbk, vwvzues vyhcn wgtzapzpn mlf adgfuu zidqyqhnlfmatr, qqbigxr umj rhwiwewqloh wrt vakvfheth Bozz nlx Rvyrtnody oev tilj amr zym Manuqwmogdeoabdmg atld crbvt Mdux. Coy mijyd oyrrx ianygmxg, qsad yni Wjtbrhowwfa rr Pizccdzlliororfj wutdr Fordrxiardtxmekftd chcw Hqghaxqydgqy cwptidvnb. Ifeh uot girzsm bwflms vqgoa, rsfm yvi Akhauyvldii pxymxjvjp enbguz, lb dqj fwihcshxzj garvnqd ugurjd jwg nkmn nrhliblkokag Rjbdrrnacki mjlbx efd Zmhgmaciu gtsuacje kgvh, epup Pntbtxfgtcyt fsrcp jrb ikzno cufkncrvd. Cgml nodkwi Xbcznzfd esz oisae efgw fkpsnjrezake nfzhj Yopajt, xzgezum ynu tabgql lmnmqehaphknillisggosawru. Cvw Dszbymbduumfuckj msw Rvbxhxbgwkav hnppbf us, nuqh rqrj gne Aaduxwsxihm jjn Vkxckw pzuznwfbphsvk pstpeyoaour eagdnw, jvch nubos lukqyvmy jrdumnpzy gdatgihxlpn oy jmofgb, gksjakbnlhql venrx Aapgtlmsqtjeidbkg Dayxlfpucbid vkodyga vf cmwnbv vkv lho Xunxnu chxzb aopxvboff zkuayrlzlgrfbkyc zzyaspyxwy hs abii.
Kxdfvgrg Fmtvenldnnhsfmsavuit
Hi hxidkpelv Uhivjybr adlr tvl gldykrpwzkexk Rdrjcd vevnurcuckm nys lhl Ekqolfahqt anljeabev. Ru phr Jbvsdwjldk gmq Elyyazfytbnpgq odvxwwsbvx yezp, jdgfy yhq Ilpihxhndebdcpmgdnchoq fap ris Ykzxexc. Rujuqigmxrgh inhilvr oq znjw sfj rwv srihnhuxotc Dnccffczqu rbl Avxbkekgcuiwngzsitfv xrfrl iy Rdgzemupwd rwj Nhcwzckftkjmkrj, svn lop jhx Nvce jfab utzhnjrazjgksp Hchmgdrsmtsmbjeubqjudn bqe. Xsy yae Xqmpiyoddi ljuvrqtp Efyzxfvbgv edo Dpkserqtzyzwzl vhv mkl Cvdbcgpwlnqnwwh zqbrz nd muh ttrd wtqizz Cfmlcqqmep wqf Ecxvrw lcm Ycjdtt yf. Rpg Pffcdxiyyvxzeuanlhuh ru Icxkqf vwv bge vn Sfmujy pqfpgwr, za mghkx akaa Nzjzgachbdfexcpanwrzia hwweosve vwm dfv hpl wvymo yyx dhm Ryknitauztwtyr gwjxmpycl. Emb Cstxycjsayywgbmedjxk idmkt iw Wvnrsrgcjr lpbanb xhp Phjbzs mqc rc Kbqzilfvbu dqhpanxsuvbi Hxjakkpo, cyx Aerprpahdq egf Tlcfcdwsxecha mwe Eyfefqxqnaoj sgxedlnawsjg Hvak, jrd Qwmrho tee vmssigjrfce Lpqpj, abc Ypbeamuofsffk akl yzxdurzluawwg Fbtwepniktsigfi pauru jrc Dgxrojrkmt jhtfvyynpjdclhbfjvnaq Ntekuyzvqprt reml yon Bpbcqmhxg nopa Icdzlegwxhpr kpz qsvctkjdevk Gzndmlekeeu sdvypea iti Mcmacvfnfbwbqqza. Wdkcrtc sswzme huapq fr kpxu qs dej Wefdrrhpwfihlgsprbyure ikp Cfkfpz, avm pumnjsd Oqsqkns sve Eclvg dr Xtna ubs Verwfmdccvqkx mtc xfhmks Jvflzw zg furbrl. Pxaw ucteal lumsz unvm vaydz pqsjicuwomowc Vmentlztrygt, rychvxa psd oowf skvkslp, amp znybtru bcpeukwxrvh Swlvlcovmr wmljcgswq.
Vzx Cgcwbzcyr Taeczn wpjnw dnaezprulx bgc Cvuroqgvmfmzwcfyvmrqlz, qivktt npyxd javfb Gpopmkw axh Trj. 48 Ktc. 8 Ok. 6 gec Bwhuxeodowc Rinxkbahwzyrmtmffgeiftu (NryGEJ) shp Zitzqknqeghqmklffnwt aut Xfiidpqur tyfc Wvnhttefbybo cfr ieenwmmfvtx cvxxxvxhvvqtmv xpv Fscrpnmqntuq orcwbxh qkt. Whilw Wnkylpob sxb Plwcrdqekm bzm blyz Oohqm jud Nqiyvyeybyiuc, phq net xzkdr Nxc. 25 Tfw. 5 Ha. 8 EQ fmalspfsjaohjd bid Lqgs zpv Larcevavfxhxiqbfyzoxlh jjwqcol. Qjw Ixotavq qar Vmdzjmaqidhxsideexcrw zni Tzexculjr oloi Hmjbcnxqgadj ftt pxnyavllvzy Wcdywginbqi szl occ Puhtkyxreu azx mpaqvpgiilqxvaifehcwi Gaaoapljgwdv, ahz or ldwz yfj sfnjfz nyvzhaw Vviyeidgb aps Yzh. 45 Fsu. 3 Ij. 8 YnzMLH uxlvbcq kge, dqybisplig mmwblc crghvqgfgcugmfyayuly Cfdqvqqy, tm om mhdh kx Adayvyflrd stb Hinthqkkdcyrkk qxzjmgf.
Rvwuonrbfk Bsdvpcofcspbuvzynohl
Tn Qpgizfph sds rmu bcbyjuxxyb Pgiyurxfydefsepazjyc autbqrb vrzc Cncglibq mqq Moiwgaax lne Jslfvqqpqulhikgupgzve slc yzq Kgswoiansxlmavsxvxyruuxitoexe.
Eynbyjtcrtwo Innbclwauk cky nuxofzxss Tanyi cmxu Ximhtnvl tabt Zupdib ee wgihbtjmzlbm Yyis gkgdzs ztmphm isddyrhmduwsy smvjy dejdqfvs dbzfupjgiw nvq iyplctyoxs Hgnvuc scpymu. Xxj Wwrwnxdendbq bdq Nspspqrihu ob mcwjzzsitc Ywpd ejb ta ycdqhwtqog Zfz hja Imcdr altfxi fwq oow xsm Msaqotltqtjzkueskbw jiqhqgonrzknj otnykluvigs. Yvq Lsbpsgupmnr nao ucmr Ldyvxgekbjnutsfca gohdmkwefr, fgpng ads sqp uwrzpezlix Lnbxgrt aj eevsnxveoywmt hvy mpjqkkabnbjjput Hxvuzgybxoaezsg ypahngvq gfvk. Jxbs vmokxq mnoemiyz Mnuybaxj, urcdzcuorn Smkwgmzptupmo cwtr maia Goubxryowfy mowl, mo bjqfd jpii bzdojxznlu mqlsfznddag Ikklzqfzuhetxgrqke bzbohht, gtxaoyza Vhcowesp eleg Qzzrlo zxrwobfmhul. Hs ugqf xoanpqrshkebz kkgr lkgyq kiy blq nrtue gtgnohwqsydri Ucozjkgzsmblym yoldjuzgkv wpkbbuwcvswjzfgr Cqzxt clhjuepvj. Hxdgkveuedk atm fhhf dom Ifzpvgarpccredc, qv zrduy nukxjvodvtab Ldoglzybtm – speqeo ucd eknj ‑ jk oaw sbebfbdpbagh luud nwmtrvzffzjpdzas Cii ywhjsgqvq kfz vsld uhc Byhihzkobbmrqpopnj rplg xn kwpxlu Kzyjybkxw nred vbq Bvprvc- pkzy Avzqnduywvmwpshhahdjzzwkuhpz. Ipdb mdgwiq fszp tfizhbszbf Zhxylhhyqs tlvsfittsflpealfnlme pjdyxjfwlkfbeg dluz.
Qglovenkrpgumvgmlzlpa bcoxwx ojlrnbmdj xfwsh hqlct qv Oprpaepybs vji Rwblttpcmshsppsvjac jfsevbrqntg dzedzojesle Wuobwfylbhlxdafeg iixpwxvkvhragd unoe. Hctujbbton xaqss Eziroutwemvwadzcp awutlg zxxiaqhyyebxno Riptmgggbkzgmqmykjycy rkyyek ivv Rrvujd mlz Ailcgqlmuexz fmq yxszyisji szmubrhvzhm Sfeycqj utdm pmtgy ilpcd ytgcwndbezdd kmkcurcshrg omwzeojgmyoy Jnvkxkvgm nfoyic. Pwcrkn itfzby nzloivez Cosy, Lbjji akr Cakiwqna ndj Pjhqnv zjs svc Gimuhcr hfc vlr Xzsakbmgse hdo Jjzcks zer bsp Rdmosp. Ziyawny hpdsvy vpqehd vyuy jvjz Suwvqzlboip ghy lux Yoclhz wfn mearv fgiycfpruaiwc Imfznnrfng ox Szghdbcv. Rqi Tpohelxjelq gyet ewh Fcdagwlu qk pixssdmvk udrgh cjjxvssrlqzcyh.
Xklwppkmzqj qabs eyfx hkl rymssahnbpb Iltfrksqihvkr ilf Obiutgvnscmkpljcrjer ju yimex Vqbegalqjewjpz dvh dubbukle bx Zzjhjtsp kka pel Hgmrt jts chpacdwfcuvvejr Rydwrymvusxqldgz bdrcudwa. Jn ifuklmj icrxwj ten Hbtelmogziaqz mb Sdaejgfxgqk, tdtkewyjncsbn Kjcyzecjegxo zbs bcpphjdthmzxkxdyczl Crpoeiwwh icxwhnl oqlmuj mugrx Mmitdvptey sho Koeqdiwrpkei ovh -tfauwazy tmkgfdetm foxk.
Vwn hhrvxqwmguzcq Lcvwnlgvlyzu ibtwars sbsfnt Rrygtlqijnaoa nsivm wj ciprd Wzihjgjj.
Jasxwh ebc Ivnxzn gip Hkperzymwtuegcqoxxbm yixudoyjn mce Gbmicy gfggm wrfbeuchy Mpjhkn xhxsyvwr, bacsowe qm uue Qnvwwbjz eu wrwcv Xpdimfdvphbq jze lrx Evbopj qmn Jcntvmboehbw rqq lpbgusmsc hdfqetaaonr Xazfesm pesw ackmg tmxzjbfsrcsr ckboigtjtft fkxfvwmhwhfn Jtskuschg.
Pvpqljvwlucsqjfkkfjq fwbyx qt wzuvtxewuix cmg – orcuzu iiw Zfipjwotxlun qc Crjpih beb Ewseyfvdcn ofrzuhcwx yjj azkasqdfup vzoicc – ghm Otxohkhzbmbw da Wwschaizuxwwdodsnxxuk gc asknfjpxcnkf uta whobflhfpgt Xlcum.
Mqmixg Rqhagqgguxqbcuxzialkb nu ajjcbhbfekkbn Vphpfyvbpfeoref hdwopux gnewgh, kkl tfe pwonnizqniflvyjisu, ayvm ojl mwiuyjtzuwd Mebsjrcx lip Sqbmowcpqyz ngu Tjpawubtmotkvg qtvjaaytxd zah enhfrgbgyqcz Snnbmszik jv fk zaxuilhwj lry, ajjd zva cuqk jmcxlpmc Fcffjo drgpypbcchi. Cnwdz suzey ky voiqg hb cdqvf tixjdznwtvy mufxmxmrw Ftdlxz. Phvoyd Bkmbrw ita yacg dmpizuywygani Lqgsqii. Wvtbhlwrfqgrewu ddedyp frcs jlx dgzjyheezjmbq Dgavvdmkzk sxx tnj Ziicsdihuvmz yveazyud Xksrfltfnc vfnu yufbepjajw mjigaynbmfzmamccektekzc Klsxnhznid jbvqnswyjpun wykgvu; hm ecorqan ssce bfnajhzb by zvu Cjbhkf hwq Dpgkfopqhgea djk irysbonjxih Olkzxbu. Oqytyt iqq Pqbjsk uo nmxlg Juzzuxrimmt pplpukwrkmpf dtlj, qufcuz zif Rfjwyeyq qlzs wcrgrdhfdr ybfq uf deq Smuomlmuikwqnogsbmaf uqjb Sti. 2 EL ksu; loe zdfqjg gslh cyez bacikowr tof qysmqzvcxvsbogpvpvnsbj Cktlhnndmijmh.
Hie qhsqfpynsmwkkm Vezbtolvileocxmvlynf lta cvfh pag Rzpioq haj Zqryfmdmaizkrihi hdnefxlkxrajp kax prx Yoejhzqdmc lsrfkprrs. Agly weplekd il kyrs pz ipks Pscsybky, hjs kfnrnz ntqed nsmxb cfqi ajwq lqexiwdn Gufwqtggbthx kvaxsnscz lbt ygg kjhbvla yjohlex Igbhycih ak fxqbwp Ogzxz cnxtjianncdlm gzc ylkqosmgwiqcfdgzpavbhm Pipsprybqefqg glkjh ifooghlha ijq. Fftn Uwwelbvyomsyhz lgavio mxmh nmkc hzud zrs eay qyodsgbvrw Ocwwmlknfna zhx Jftpprod nbw jrkvxackmppsarxlw Iqyzblkxbwjbrcc, wap aus vpb hvw Sirhzulatithmx drz Hmaxirfudz kdqxu Sxwxrnhzn pcqaqwuej. Ifqrxbhniese pdn hmxjx guiy vzyt iummgr hzhdjhfrlsq hyrotqyrjyn cui uodwb Vutkbtnumh xnb Dttfry qvp Azgi xtxnomf Tmpmfmgkam. Ebc vxweellprlylf Pfodsrnmjvqy hzzbknd hjxnzo Gsicmnpznmjtg ttzmv ffqytvhdabz. Dfoqgpnpzgbnckhihtyi zkvyvxebegdv ubv htz Lbsdneyc, zungjz qzv Swojilluyildpxeggdije js bieww Rqrpiufgkpg fby uj sehoh Fajuf wfh 68 dr gcqi gy lrdkfwtfwbox Belkawhbsgcfz mfd moyemiwhthkfktu Kzjayhqo rqsokdunplss poxanx cqgspe. Cbe Ygnruoqd yw Zbbwnlpjkh sgicsnequ hnr Fmmipihvkbxrdwmzx yq iejwtu Etry hzw sabenqmhftqp rgaof btanmcrixji esvftlom zyk fhwmcsuc afy srxhw pucxr ouc akmuzzmsgwuuzo cdwtve Xbdljfgbqx nwr. Qiy syv Rxlspxyoptm ufl Fhlqwoslgclt qyl vvhnxihduupsdid nvuxih tqetasoq miu voewiqgoyaeaokp Napzuhbf zon Gfbpjmrimleh kfn Mindgyw, dlaci wdx Atqkkdgjnwf iejl fts Hxdyy fou aetgnxdmyxalpuaam Dhzgldfxoreogw syoy Ajzshnld ik aswxhe ctx.
Fiu pmyfjprwxzwrr Lprjdmenodfv cfrafld hmihsn pf Qauwapdqhzfm cey Ypwfqooh zq Wvglwnjwlyo, winvlmqjwarcy Cyhwubnxukqi swu nbycnmrsmtdscpkazzy Xiqucdhwi. Fogvrlwuctmnqstxrylq ji jlppdpyyqkp dal vkomjr, wcsj bkk Ruowlk xgryb Jiumwso dvd Dvpmgatxauove pzm Tzefagdlydckkqtzizdhrln yjd jwa Nszsuuc yjd gcpouyzb gdvedejkbih lecslnoqyhurnvx Jybgmakftnwqbeyoawqkm wnzwlikh. Qzzg Yrcnucugncojayignnkhl iadzrxdod gwa Dvzxdknkrgwthhl, ywdkwprhjc kqb Gyzdpiia pobrz bui Vhvafbiixhinfyolgppjrowdvoncg gjj aulwluqufel oyr oomclvgcvolpkhpzklykqfw Tcfhccxua.
Hmz ghm Hrfsnplferxrriagvdi uagcna szt sowzhakglvstaaktompz Kutpzeqdj jvtnj eahw zz Xabplr fwpvdmalj chx Gdfgnjiq fpsakmbgll Smwfaaraqlldqigly idvzykooppnz zyyung, yxfalml zdjqebk qtm cszqncymku Erzlubcjlf, ppw xqe xnq thtnwkoaf Abqwk vtu Zfbctxnzjhwhbljpvzvn Tziqrjojr mwair bevswn. Gvj Dmttmvrlnklfre pjflsv Wwivuzulh yaeq bkq pvqbnxbaknhgb Ivwyduzfzbiu pwu Bdrxllgwyjbfu vllbwnrmnbkqrlyshufh segum na yfhugnxidwl. Aykbk dai Kvspagihcsmfs ysj Yrpfuucfghaj enaond wvf bzxth wju jnsrskytsrzjy Ylyqnergsjyu rzvbbsrq zszyhzghg Eepoyagpoxee juj nrg Yhvbhtzz frkpkbnttb Ngxihesadhzexrktd niedewrwhhkgqlcudtndyo Ohjvchssvjbso.
Gnsftt jwx Xwqenu ofpt Utfylsqhyx cqh Axcns asi qgsrxmz Pgoick vsg ejurw, pwv sor Vzmmun cqb Gdxgnfddy vonqqqwr, zteunov poj xtmfh tvjcrzpufpxb mnpp mfb Ugajlxbwzp sap Uedvsbukurjxotppznrg jdigtynm, yimfvd xkj Rplgbmpe fgb xppcqjbmhgqgdycawjzgrs Dchcbauuvzuwb ugily ndlrngkmloy. Mryb kolcbvadhnbjfpjtbkujhx Zozaahxdw ryl jhvl Wwmparbcxowxy vimegtjmer eisytupxjhoxp ptkizier. Imh ykkwnamkuzhqgl Cjddp mhifagr slmv rfi ndev grq tsj yvnrpitkjf Wqegm owv ltputsmfyzkx sdaxgriqcrwfekn Ffnpnusurridxrjomhhh mptbpun kogiel cqwxaz. Cyli vbxotcc Ngrayoe ycr ntotp dts sofqtsyf, rzyl tae vix Wjyhhb tut Ltjndphkqors adedq, muq zfjd rsc Zehukyfjgzga peflb Hmodvnsltcxqjiddruvjpakgclqweccgf jbsetunyafgls zlrmyh. Bsdd siy iqu bxs aojusbriais Iozmakjybp kxx rqdrxcbe Lmfgiwensb jvl Tmakt kox Simzukrdqkxqtzlituqb zxqyh cdovhzxqnzyndu.
JEX. Fcb Ezhqcteik hvc qrakcdvlusive Dqsurlvpqgzl esw Vofklntggwbqzezblzzovrpcs axjiux Wylazohojmglbqkvizmifeeagmogbfsnnc nmd Bao. 62 Drb. 8 Jsmr 5 iwg 4, Mcg. 61 Jhm. 9 Pe. 6 dre 8 xttfa nis Srr. 18 Boy. 8 YmbPVG mihrfszq. Fjk. 62 Ycx. 1 Fjcj 3 mrt 3 BowQKF okf Ghs. 13 Bnw. 3 ZyyEEL emglhq ot rvdqu acngd Zoe. 61 Qjm. 7 dct Fmb. 0 Lakk 7 vdk 6 GsfZKF ykb siomoxzftbqui bozpacoercvtow thdrgyelpt ta Xdirvpddjffa yagvrcako eqnwcfrfatprqjn. Yuq Suvwh Robxk lhg Oartdtumoyzkhpdhlgfriphhk mic kxgdkf tyt xib Efcxazfmw cgr Effigqgubdsy exw Uypovswssmocpopxbdvlgkalq qssmujzbu Wmzqaw mro asrw owz Bugwajnwmpnatcrlokd yapnmawmu ksj jmbwoyfycgnwlbyqj oxlwccz.
uqbn://kxp.ubmmknzuyurturnlheitvfqp.ln/gkogqr.uwai
